Better Series: Kobe vs. PHO ('10) or Dirk vs. OKC ('11)

Moderators: Clyde Frazier, Doctor MJ, trex_8063, penbeast0, PaulieWal

Better Series: Kobe vs. '10 Suns or Dirk vs. '11 Thunder

Kobe vs. '10 Suns
9
56%
Dirk vs. '11 Thunder
7
44%
 
Total votes: 16

O_6
Rookie
Posts: 1,179
And1: 1,586
Joined: Aug 25, 2010

Better Series: Kobe vs. PHO ('10) or Dirk vs. OKC ('11) 

Post#1 » by O_6 » Sat Sep 21, 2019 10:12 pm

So I was watching highlights from both of these series and they are just ridiculous displays of offensive prowess. I was just wondering which series you thought was the better individual performance?

Kobe: 33.7 PPG -- 7.2 RPG -- 8.3 APG -- 2.5 TOV -- 52/43/88 splits -- .589 eFG% -- .637 TS% -- (+43 On / -15 Off)
Dirk: 32.2 PPG -- 5.8 RPG -- 2.6 APG -- 4.2 TOV -- 56/36/97 splits -- .580 eFG% -- .701 TS% -- (+22 On / -2 Off)

'10 Suns: 54-28 record -- 4.67 SRS (6th) -- 110.2 DRtg (23rd)
'11 OKC: 55-27 record -- 3.81 SRS (9th) -- 107.2 DRtg (15th)

Series Highlights:


I remember at the time I was just so in awe of Dirk vs. the Thunder. The way he made Ibaka look helpless is something I'll never forget. Even though I was also amazed at what Kobe did to the Suns in 2010, it just felt like what Dirk did to the Thunder in 2011 was crazier. But after analyzing the numbers and videos from each series, I feel like Kobe may have had the better overall performance.

Dirk was more efficient scoring because of his foul drawing ability this series. Dirk scored 59 on his 161 PTS in his series from the FT line while Kobe scored only 37 of his 201 PTS from the FT line. Drawing fouls is obviously an important part of the game so you have to give credit to Dirk. Ibaka/Collison/Durant just could not guard him without fouling him.

But Kobe being a far superior ball-handler and playmaker is why I'm leaning towards his Suns series as better. Kobe averaged 5.7 more APG and 1.7 less TOV than Dirk did in their respective series. That's a massive difference and more than makes up for the TS% difference imo.

Dirk was an absolute mid-range God against OKC, but he only made 4 threes in the series though. Whereas Kobe made 19 threes or about 3.2 per game on .432 3P% vs. the Suns... aka Steph Curry numbers.

48 PTS on 15 FGA and 0 3PA in Game 1... that statline from Dirk still makes no sense and is definitely the best game between either player in these 2 series. But overall, after really thinking about it I believe Kobe's performance against the Suns was better because he was a more complete offensive weapon while being at the very least a more versatile defender.

Both of these performances were legendary. They're both on the short-list of best offensive series in a Conference Finals or Finals. Which one do you think was better?
Johnny Firpo
RealGM
Posts: 14,184
And1: 9,517
Joined: Apr 17, 2009
 

Re: Better Series: Kobe vs. PHO ('10) or Dirk vs. OKC ('11) 

Post#2 » by Johnny Firpo » Sun Sep 22, 2019 4:17 pm

Watched both series', and to me, what Dirk did was more impressive for the simple fact that Kobe had way more help. Not just generally, but in the two series'. Both Jet and Kidd shot 36% in the series, Peja was degrading fast. In the Suns series, Pau averaged 20 on 60%TS, and was obviously miles better than anyone Dirk had, and they had Odom when he was still quite good, Bynum, and a very solid version of Metta. Gimme Dirk.
HeartBreakKid
RealGM
Posts: 22,395
And1: 18,828
Joined: Mar 08, 2012
     

Re: Better Series: Kobe vs. PHO ('10) or Dirk vs. OKC ('11) 

Post#3 » by HeartBreakKid » Sun Sep 22, 2019 4:20 pm

Dirk pretty easily. I don't really get the point of bringing up 3%, Dirk was way more efficient than Kobe regardless if he took less 3s than him.

Dirk's team was out matched and it felt like the Mavericks had less margin for error. Did anyone think the Suns were going to beat the Lakers that year? I can't recall that.


The Suns were also a bad defense as well.
Strepbacter
Bench Warmer
Posts: 1,329
And1: 2,367
Joined: Dec 18, 2018

Re: Better Series: Kobe vs. PHO ('10) or Dirk vs. OKC ('11) 

Post#4 » by Strepbacter » Sun Sep 22, 2019 8:45 pm

Kobe pretty easily. He just completely crushes Dirk as a passer/play-maker and was way better at taking care of the ball. He was much more efficient overall.

Kobe: 135 ORTG (+25)
Dirk:. 125 ORTG (+18)

Return to Player Comparisons