Page 1 of 4

fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Thu Nov 11, 2021 4:09 am
by falcolombardi
like if you had access to all nba players in history. which 3 man combination (spexyfing for which era) would dominate the most? assuming average role players after the top 3


or put another way which would be your ultimate big 3 to make a dinasty even without anyone particularly good for depht?

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Thu Nov 11, 2021 4:12 am
by HeartBreakKid
Bill Russell, Lebron James and Michael Jordan. Who are also the top 3 players of all time imo.

90s or 2000s could be good.

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Thu Nov 11, 2021 4:17 am
by Cavsfansince84
I think dropping young Magic, Kareem and Bird in about 1985 would be pretty good. I chose 1985 because the league was still fast from then until about 96 and would be more friendly to Bird for 3pt shooting than the early 80's were. Also all 3 could play as offensive anchors so not much drop off when you sit one or two at a time. Plus young Kareem can anchor the defense for a good 10-12 years. Taking Magic over Steph because I like how he could impose his game more in the playoffs plus less injury prone.

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Thu Nov 11, 2021 4:52 am
by Colbinii
Jordan/Bird/Garnett in the mid/late 2000s

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Thu Nov 11, 2021 8:11 am
by uberhikari
LeBron, KG, West.

Going for maximum versatility on offense and defense. On offense, this team has on and off-ball creation, passing, and shooting. And on defense, every player is a top 5 defender at their position and can guard multiple positions.

Also, the synergy is perfect. LeBron plays the 4 and has space to operate inside given the shooting of West and KG. Plus, West and KG are perfectly fine playing off-ball. On defense, this is the perfect switching team.

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Thu Nov 11, 2021 2:13 pm
by feyki
16 Lebron, 61/63 Russell, 66/68 Wilt in the early 60's; contend 80W.

Edit: First one was pace profit situation. And also need to make space one; Curry, West, Dirk in the 2021, over of 15 SRS and 75W.

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Thu Nov 11, 2021 2:41 pm
by Colbinii
feyki wrote:16 Lebron, 61/63 Russell, 66/68 Wilt in the early 60's; contend 80W.

Edit: First one was pace profit situation. And also need to make space one; Curry, West, Dirk in the 2021, over of 15 SRS and 75W.


I think the second team would be better with Garnett than Dirk. Dirk isn't really going to be able to maximize the off-ball movement of Curry due to being worse as a screener and passer when compared with Garnett.

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Thu Nov 11, 2021 3:20 pm
by G35
Jordan
Pippen
DRob

I think they could legitimately hold teams to 70PPG over a season......

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Thu Nov 11, 2021 3:32 pm
by Texas Chuck
Colbinii wrote:
feyki wrote:16 Lebron, 61/63 Russell, 66/68 Wilt in the early 60's; contend 80W.

Edit: First one was pace profit situation. And also need to make space one; Curry, West, Dirk in the 2021, over of 15 SRS and 75W.


I think the second team would be better with Garnett than Dirk. Dirk isn't really going to be able to maximize the off-ball movement of Curry due to being worse as a screener and passer when compared with Garnett.


I see the obvious advantages of KG's defense and passing. But Dirk is arguably the best PNR big of all-time. There is zero issues with him as a screener. Even if you tell me the slighter KG sets a firmer pick than Dirk which isn't something I've noticed, there is really no argument he's a more effective screener in terms of how defenses will react to him. Surprised to see screening singled out here.

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Thu Nov 11, 2021 3:54 pm
by Ryoga Hibiki
jordon/Garnett/Durant

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Thu Nov 11, 2021 6:27 pm
by Colbinii
Texas Chuck wrote:
Colbinii wrote:
feyki wrote:16 Lebron, 61/63 Russell, 66/68 Wilt in the early 60's; contend 80W.

Edit: First one was pace profit situation. And also need to make space one; Curry, West, Dirk in the 2021, over of 15 SRS and 75W.


I think the second team would be better with Garnett than Dirk. Dirk isn't really going to be able to maximize the off-ball movement of Curry due to being worse as a screener and passer when compared with Garnett.


I see the obvious advantages of KG's defense and passing. But Dirk is arguably the best PNR big of all-time. There is zero issues with him as a screener. Even if you tell me the slighter KG sets a firmer pick than Dirk which isn't something I've noticed, there is really no argument he's a more effective screener in terms of how defenses will react to him. Surprised to see screening singled out here.


You're right. Both Garnett and Dirk are tier-0 in terms of pick and roll big men.

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Thu Nov 11, 2021 6:30 pm
by penbeast0
Mikan, Arizin, and Davies playing in the early 50s. Mikan absolutely dominated everyone already; add the best wing and the best PG and it could close the league down.

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Thu Nov 11, 2021 7:24 pm
by Whopper_Sr
I'd roll with Curry/LBJ/KG and not look back.

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Thu Nov 11, 2021 7:27 pm
by KobesScarf
84 Bird
80 Magic
72 Wilt

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Thu Nov 11, 2021 7:35 pm
by Jack Dempsey
We were so close on watching young Hakeem, Jordan and Drexler together on the Rockets.

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Fri Nov 12, 2021 7:02 am
by Sebastian
MJ, Kawhi, Wilt. Mid/late 20s version of each.

Any era before the three point barrage started recently, they win 75+ games/season by an average of 25-30 points/game. Scoring everywhere, playmaking everywhere, without question best defensive squad of all-time. What wing or big is getting a night of good shots off against this team?

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Fri Nov 12, 2021 2:17 pm
by Doctor MJ
My immediate thought is the Big 3 Celtics who harmonized better than any Big 3 I can think of.

So if I take the same model but just go with the rich man’s version of each player:

Paul Pierce -> Michael Jordan
Ray Allen -> Steph Curry
Kevin Garnett -> Kevin Garnett

I will say I’m very tempted to substitute Larry Bird in specifically.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Fri Nov 12, 2021 3:28 pm
by Statlanta
Curry Pippen Russell

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Fri Nov 12, 2021 3:43 pm
by uberhikari
Statlanta wrote:Curry Pippen Russell


Why Pippen over LeBron?

Re: fit and overlap considered, what is the absolutely best big 3 that could exist?

Posted: Fri Nov 12, 2021 3:51 pm
by Texas Chuck
Duncan
Bird
Mike