2005-’07: Dirk vs KG vs Nash

[Matt15]

Overall how would you rank these three players each year from 2005-’07?

[Texas Chuck]

05 is the really tough year. I honestly have no idea. Nash feels like he should be last, but then he was the MVP. KG/Dirk/Nash? Don't feel great about it.
06 is Dirk, Nash, KG
07 is Dirk, Nash, KG

[Dutchball97]

KG had by far the best regular season in 05 and was arguably the best in 06 as well but has no case for 07. Dirk is a lock for 06 but disappointing play-off performances in 05 and 07 hurt him. I think Nash is overall the worst player of the bunch but he is definitely the most consistent in this period.

05: KG, Nash, Dirk
06: Dirk, Nash, KG
07: Nash, Dirk, KG

Ranking KG and Nash in 05 and 06 is the most difficult part. I could see KG or Nash being ahead both years. I do think KG regressed enough, while Nash upped his game a bit compared to 05 to have the opposite order in 06.

[No-more-rings]

Overall how would you rank these three players each year from 2005-’07?

2005:
1. KG
2. Nash
3. Dirk

2006:
1. Dirk
2. Nash
3. KG

2007:
1. Nash
2. Dirk
3. KG

[Narigo]

2005:
KG
Nowitzki
Nash

2006:
Nowitzki
KG
Nash

2007:
Nowitzki
Nash
KG

[feyki]

05:
KG
DN
SN,

06:
DN
KG/SN,

07:
DN/SN
KG

.