RealGM

Offense only, who you got?

They are in clear separate offensive tiers; Barkley

SHAQ32 wrote:They are in clear separate offensive tiers; Barkley

they are in different tiers as scorers, but so are they as creators

barkley edge with his offensive rebounding may tilt me over barkley but i am unsure

i really like wade and think he was better thsn charles

falcolombardi wrote:

SHAQ32 wrote:They are in clear separate offensive tiers; Barkley

they are in different tiers as scorers, but so are they as creators

barkley edge with his offensive rebounding may tilt me over barkley but i am unsure

i really like wade and think he was better thsn charles

Chuck's a better shooter, especially for his position and era.

SHAQ32 wrote:

falcolombardi wrote:

SHAQ32 wrote:They are in clear separate offensive tiers; Barkley

they are in different tiers as scorers, but so are they as creators

barkley edge with his offensive rebounding may tilt me over barkley but i am unsure

i really like wade and think he was better thsn charles

Chuck's a better shooter, especially for his position and era.

i already agreed with that

barkley was a all time great scorer, better than wade clearly with histórical efficiency at volune

but wade coukd rise his volume and creation in a all time level, barkley was a strong creator but nowhere near wade

barkley has a offensive advantage in his offensive rebounding thst wade doesnt (to the same degree, he is still a incredible rebounder for a guard)

i like creators more than isolation scorers, but barkley had more off ball value with his offensive rebounding (wade was great but not the same level)

so i see it as very close overall in offense, wade defense clearly being better imo

For overall prime and career, it’s Barkley since he put up more high quality seasons. Narrowing it down to just peak it’s more interesting, i don’t see clear seperation either way 09 Wade in the regular season and 06 playoff Wade takes a backseat to very few offensively.