RealGM

If you had to rank the best Celtics seasons since 1989-90, and you cannot use the same player twice, who would you put in? Please rank those seasons in order.

Candidates:
Tatum 23' or 22'
Garnett 08'
Pierce 08' or 09'
Allen 08'
Brown 23' or 22'
Bird 90'
McHale 90'
Horford 18'
Rondo 12'

Am I missing someone?

durantbird wrote:Am I missing someone?

Maybe Reggie Lewis or Antoine Walker. Haven't looked at the numbers though.

durantbird wrote:If you had to rank the best Celtics seasons since 1989-90, and you cannot use the same player twice, who would you put in? Please rank those seasons in order.

Candidates:
Tatum 23' or 22'
Garnett 08'
Pierce 08' or 09'
Allen 08'
Brown 23' or 22'
Bird 90'
McHale 90'
Horford 18'
Rondo 12'

Am I missing someone?

If we’re going deep in a list, you’d have to consider putting 2017 Isaiah Thomas on the list who while being a highly negative defender (most players at that size are, though he was especially bad), probably had one of the greatest seasons ever offensively for a Celtic pound for pound.

2019 Kyrie would probably be on the list as well.

homecourtloss wrote:

durantbird wrote:If you had to rank the best Celtics seasons since 1989-90, and you cannot use the same player twice, who would you put in? Please rank those seasons in order.

Candidates:
Tatum 23' or 22'
Garnett 08'
Pierce 08' or 09'
Allen 08'
Brown 23' or 22'
Bird 90'
McHale 90'
Horford 18'
Rondo 12'

Am I missing someone?

If we’re going deep in a list, you’d have to consider putting 2017 Isaiah Thomas on the list who while being a highly negative defender (most players at that size are, though he was especially bad), probably had one of the greatest seasons ever offensively for a Celtic pound for pound.

2019 Kyrie would probably be on the list as well.

So who are your top 5?

My first 4 came to me pretty quickly, but I can't decide on #5. So top 4 here.

1. '08 KG
2. '23 Tatum
3. '02 Pierce
4. '90 Bird

1. 2008 Kevin Garnett
2. 2023 Jayson Tatum
3. 2002 Paul Pierce
4. 1990 Larry Bird
5. 2018 Al Horford

HM: 1990 Kevin McHale, 2017 Isaiah Thomas

1. 2008 Garnett
_____________
2. 1990 Bird
3. 2023 Tatum
______________
4. 2018 Irving (pre injury)
5. 2002 Pierce