RealGM

Who ya got?

And if it's Roy, then doesn't that make him a top tier shooting guard since T-Mac isn't so far off from being top tier?

roy

because he is younger and isn't made of glass

Here's the thing I would take Roy because he's healthier even if he himself is not the picture of perfect health, but that doesn't mean he's better than T-Mac. I mean when you stop and realize that Roy is on his rookie contract you basically have to take him over T-Mac, T-Mac is the better player than Roy the problem is that he's almost never healthy anymore.

Roy, because there is no future for Tracy McGrady

I'd take TMac now no doubt.

Roy will never be as good as TMac but if you consider the future/injuries then you gotta take Roy because he's younger and more durable.

Roy

kind of a funny poll, I don't see how would couldn't take Roy give injuries, contract and age.

now: tmac
future: roy