RealGM

Who is over rated? Who is under rated? These are my personal rankings and I try to be as unbiased as possible but what do you guys think of my rankings?

PGs:
1. Steve Nash 96
2. Chris Paul 94
3. Allen Iverson 93
4. Baron Davis 92
5. Gil Arenas 92
6. Jason Kidd 91
7. Deron Williams 90
8. Tony Parker 89
9. Chauncey Billups 89
10. T.J. Ford 84
11. Jason Terry 84
12. Mike Bibby 84
13. Andre Miller 83
14. Mo Williams 83
15. Devin Harris 82
16. Jamaal Tinsley 82
17. Jose Calderon 81
18. Ray Felton 81
19. Kirk Hinrich 81
20. Stephon Marbury 80


SGs:
1. Kobe Bryant 98
2. Dwayne Wade 96
3. Tracy McGrady 92
4. Ray Allen 90
5. Vince Carter 90
6. Michael Redd 90
7. Manu Ginobili 89
8. Joe Johnson 88
9. Rip Hamilton 87
10. Kevin Martin 86
11. Brandon Roy 85
12. Jason Richardson 85
13. Ben Gordon 84
14. Andre Iguoudala 84
15. Mike Miller 84
16. Leandro Barbosa 84
17. Mike Dunleavey 83
18. Monta Ellis 82
19. Jamal Crawford 82
20. John Salmons 81


SFs:
1. LeBron James 98
2. Carmelo Anthony 93
3. Paul Pierce 92
4. Shawn Marion 90
5. Ron Artest 89
6. Caron Butler 89
7. Josh Howard 88
8. Richard Jefferson 88
9. Gerald Wallace 86
10. Rashard Lewis 86
11. Luol Deng 86
12. Josh Smith 85
13. Corey Maggette 85
14. Stephen Jackson 84
15. Andrei Kirilenko 84
16. Tayshaun Prince 84
17. Hedo Turkoglu 84
18. Rudy Gay 84
19. Danny Granger 83
20. Kevin Durant 83


PFs:
1. Tim Duncan 98
2. Kevin Garnett 97
3. Dirk Nowitzki 94
4. Elton Brand 92
5. Carlos Boozer 92
6. Chris Bosh 90
7. Pau Gasol 89
8. Al Jefferson 88
9. Jermaine O

Looks pretty good to me. Some minor changes maybe I would make, but nothing significant. I think KG should be a 98, and maybe bump Billups/Manu up to the 90 range (or bump some of their equal peers down).

Its so hard because its an ever-changing process.. and you dont wanna leave anyone behind

I've simulated to 2014-2015, and Greg Oden is the best player in the NBA(99), with Dwight Howard being second(99 also)....

I would make Redd and Josh Smith an 87... Randolph and Aldridge an 82 and Ray Allen an 89. The ratings are pretty solid though. Good job

The ratings are good.

I'd probably raise Rasheed to above Randolph. He doesn't get as good stats, but he's defintely more valuable than him.

I like your ratings much better. As a Blazer fan, seeing 2k8's ratings kind of make me sick. Roy and 82 with an 84 portential, Aldridge a 77 with a 79 potential?!

Nice ratings. The homer inside told me that Deng should be higher than Jefferson. But with the season Richard is having, I told homer to shut up.

Isn't baron a 93 in the game?
why would you decrease him, he's having the best season of his life.
MVP like.
tsk tsk.

I like the rest of the ratings.

MVP like means he could actually win MVP. He's not even close to MVP like.

brownwarriors wrote:Isn't baron a 93 in the game?
why would you decrease him, he's having the best season of his life.
MVP like.
tsk tsk.

I like the rest of the ratings.

Because leaving him at 93 would mean that he is as good as Allen Iverson

Iverson:
27ppg, 6.8 asts, 2.2 stl, 46.6%, Nuggets 21-13

Davis:
22 ppg, 8.2 asts, 2.4 stl, 41.8%, GSW 20-15


imo, Iverson is a step ahead

baron>>>

with that said

paul pierce is better than a 92 i go 94

Datruth345 wrote:baron>>>

with that said

paul pierce is better than a 92 i go 94

I don't think so. 92 is fair for Pierce.

Pretty good rankings. I should note that Rashard is a PF, now that he's playing the position.