RealGM

Who would you rather have on your team right now?

Rasheed. Better defender, more mobile, more durable, and has the ability to stretch the defense (though can get in love with the 3).

Sheed easily. Shaq has a negative impact out there a lot of times.

Rasheed can still consistantly contribute in a winning effort, Shaq cannot.

Right now it's Sheed. Although I'm optimistic that Shaq will come back strong next year and surprise all the haters.

I think Shaq gets hated too much, he still draws a double when he gets it in the post BUT in this case, I'd take Rasheed just because he's the better defender and the mis-matches he creates on the offensive end is too much to pass up.

risktaker91 wrote:Right now it's Sheed. Although I'm optimistic that Shaq will come back strong next year and surprise all the haters.

Just like what he was supposed to do this year right? Face it, Shaq's a year older next year and even crappier. He's done. Give me Rasheed right now and until both retire. Sheed's a threat on both sides of the floor.

I find Rasheed to be overrated..it's hard to take Disel though..he fouls too much and he's out of shape..I'd rather be able to take their contracts and use the $ on other players..

rasheed easily

rasheed

shaq is close to done

Rasheed no question

Sheed by FAR since last year... but don't tell Shaq I said so.