Which Wing Player do you take?

[JordansBulls]

Gilbert Arenas vs Vince Carter vs Paul Pierce vs Melo vs T-mac vs Iverson vs Manu Ginobili, who you got?

[big123]

This is pretty easy. T-mac or Iverson. They are a step above the rest.

[Baller 24]

McGrady over them all.

[J~Rush]

Ginobili due to potential health problems w/ t-mac.

[kooldude]

Tmac, he's just better.

[celticfan42487]

probuly Iverson

McGrady has winning and injury promblems.

I don't know if Gino's act will be effective if he's the number 1,2, and 3 option on a team like I may need.

Carter has given up before and probuly would again.

I doubt how much of Melo's game translates into a team

And Pierce just isn't talented enough.


Iverson because he's the only guy who can score enough to be that selfish and I know he's not going to get injured as well as he's taken a team to the Finals [if only once]

[Teddy KGB]

Gilbert Arenas

[Patterns]

TMac
Melo
Arenas
Manu
Pierce
AI
Vince

[PDXKnight]

Ginobili. The guy is flat out amazing and has been crucial to SA's last 2 championships. While he's no Kobe Bryant, I could see him being a go to option on offense on almost any team in the league. Manu has a very balanced game and definitely has a very strong will to win. He won't put up 30 PPG but he can step up when needed and carry a team in just about any situation.

[big123]

Ha Ha Ha. Iverson is 32 years old and still having a better season that all of them. Rank players, not teams. Ginobili has been great, but he's no AI.

[Illuminati]

T-mac and Vince last.

[BROWN]

Arenas or Ginobili

[Idunkon1stdates]

Manu or Pierce, easily. They can shoot, they can slash, they can hit clutch shots, they can pass. Pierce has quietly compiled a very impressive career, and Manu is Manu.

AI & Melo: turn the ball over way too much, volume scorers, lousy defense, Melo's been a poor rebounder for most of his career. Nice players, not great.

TMac: not who he once was, probably never will return to form. Definitely not a superstar anymore. Hopefully he can elevate his play.

Arenas: let's see what he's like when he comes back.

Vince: I dislike him and he's on the downswing.

[candy for lunch]

One of those players is not like the others!

(That's the one I'm picking )

[big123]

Manu or Pierce, easily. They can shoot, they can slash, they can hit clutch shots, they can pass. Pierce has quietly compiled a very impressive career, and Manu is Manu.

AI & Melo: turn the ball over way too much, volume scorers, lousy defense, Melo's been a poor rebounder for most of his career. Nice players, not great.

TMac: not who he once was, probably never will return to form. Definitely not a superstar anymore. Hopefully he can elevate his play.

Arenas: let's see what he's like when he comes back.

Vince: I dislike him and he's on the downswing.

That's your opinion and that's great, but to say that "Pierce has quietly compiled a very impressive career" and then follow it up by saying AI just turns the ball over too much is outrageous.

[big123]

AI shouldn't even be grouped with any of these 2nd tier players except maybe T-Mac. It's cool for people to select someone else because of it.

[VintaGe36]

Arenas > Iverson

at this point in their respective careers.

[Teddy KGB]

yeah seriously

people forget that Arenas put up 28/5/6 (!!!) last season which is the last dose of a healthy Gil we've gotten

[big123]

Arenas > Iverson

at this point in their respective careers.

How so? Iverson is having one of his best seasons to date and still a top 5 2 guard in the league, while Arenas is hurt and has been out. How do you come to that conclusion?

The only 2 guards that are better than AI at this present time are Kobe and possibly D-Wade. T-Mac has been making a case lately as well as Ginobili, but certainly not "better".

[big123]

yeah seriously

people forget that Arenas put up 28/5/6 (!!!) last season which is the last dose of a healthy Gil we've gotten

What's your point? AI put up 32 and 7 last year before he sat for 20 games.