RealGM

If you had to pick between these two only for a First Option Scorer who would you take?

Jefferson

I personally like to play through a great low post scorer

Jefferson, its hard to find a good low post scorer and hes a franchise one.

i think antawn jamison is better as a 2nd option , tho he can score not a knock on him hes just not the post player you'd want.

Jamison is a better scorer than Al, and it's pretty obvious to me. Al averaged 21 as the lone option on a bad team, yet Jamison manages to get 18-21 (Averaged 21 this season but excluding cause Arenas was hurt) as the 2nd or 3rd option on a playoff team.

Re-read the thread title, it asks who the better scorer is, and that's clearly Jamison to me even though most people including me would take Al as a 1st option simply because he's a post player.

Yeah, big Al might not be able to drop 40-50 like Jamison, but he's consistent, can get his points on anyone, and makes life easier for shooters, and is a good option to build an offense around.