Wilson Chandler or Marvin Williams?

[HarpStarkOakEw]

Who will have the better career?

Wilson Chandler



2008-09

Min. 33.4

Pts 14.4

Rebs 5.4

Asts 2.1

FG% 43.2

3pt% 32.8%

almost a stl and block per game



Marvin Williams



2007-08 since last year he was banged up the entire year

Min 34:36

Pts 14.8

Rebs 5.7

Asts 1.7

FG% 46.2

3pt% 10% but up to 35.5% last season

A stl a game

[Brooklyn718]

I will go with Wilson Chandler. Their offensive efficiency is comparable but I'll give the edge to Wil for his defense.

[WesWesley]

I dunno. I'd probably go with Williams. Chandler has been alright in D'Antoni's system, but I'm not really sure he's as good as Williams.

[LebronsCavs]

Marvin, he is better now and has more upside.

[KM44]

Marvin is a better defender/athlete and he has the potential to do some great thing on offense as well. I dont think Chandler will ever get THAT much better than he is now.

[Rendezvous]

lol at the pics

[Nicky Nix Nook]

pretty good comparison.

I went with Williams because of his IQ. Reminds me of a Battier type.

[Roger Murdock]

Marvin Williams, theres a reason he was drafted ahead of scrubs like Chris Paul and Deron Williams.

[BrooklynBulls]

Marvin is a decent amount better.

[NYKnick87]

It's close right now, but WC will end up being the better player, if not already.

WC is stronger, more athletic, and a better defender than Marvin.

[NetsForce]

Right now give me Marvin Chilliams.

[dockingsched]

marvin williams is markedly better than wilson chandler. wilson chandler is in the al thornton category, below average starter.

[LoboGuerrero]

Marvin Williams pretty easily IMO.

[CousinOfDeath]

I'll take Williams solely because of his picture.

[Canomad]

this is actually one of the closest comparisons i have seen on this board in a while. its a toss up for me.