RealGM

Who's better.

Gasol is not only the better player but also the better post up player.

Gasol is a better rebounder & passer, while McHale has more post moves & is a better defender. Give me McHale.

McHale with the Lakers or Gasol with the Celtics?

sweet jesus Mchale was efficient

after some consideration gimme Mchale

Yep, that sweet up and under oh so awkward but efficient shot of McHale's. He had a good working relationship with Bird, Parish, Joshnson, Ainge. I'm not sure Pau has that with Kobe, yet.

kyphi wrote:Yep, that sweet up and under oh so awkward but efficient shot of McHale's. He had a good working relationship with Bird, Parish, Joshnson, Ainge. I'm not sure Pau has that with Kobe, yet.

I've seen a couple of the C's games from back in the day and I remember Mchale was the guy on Magic most of the time is that right?

Gasol pretty easily.

McHell would have elbowed Gasol out of the key...

LebronsCavs wrote:Gasol pretty easily.

Did you see McHale play even a second of live basketball?

Mean_Streets wrote:Gasol is a better rebounder & passer, while McHale has more post moves & is a better defender. Give me McHale.

This is about dead-on accurate. Gasol is excellent, McHale was better.

Jimmy76 wrote:

kyphi wrote:Yep, that sweet up and under oh so awkward but efficient shot of McHale's. He had a good working relationship with Bird, Parish, Joshnson, Ainge. I'm not sure Pau has that with Kobe, yet.

I've seen a couple of the C's games from back in the day and I remember Mchale was the guy on Magic most of the time is that right?

No, DJ was. Mchale was usually on Worthy, meanwhile Bird was under the basket fighting for rebounds.

McHale was on Magic because Magic had already broken down DJ a few secs before.

I cant think of anything Gasol does better than McHale but he does remind me of McHale alot. I will say that Mc Hale wouldnt be as effective in the triangle because McHale wasnt a passer but a finisher.

Gasol has ethics

McHale is McHale

McHale trying to cover for Fisher would be like Odom trying to cover for him. You have to switch a lot, and he'd still get burned.

Lakers05 wrote:McHale trying to cover for Fisher would be like Odom trying to cover for him. You have to switch a lot, and he'd still get burned.

what?

Mchale was quicker than Gasol and theres a reason he has 3 all nba first team D and 3 all nba second team D and Gasol has nothing

on defense theres no contest

Jimmy76 wrote:

Lakers05 wrote:McHale trying to cover for Fisher would be like Odom trying to cover for him. You have to switch a lot, and he'd still get burned.

what?

Mchale was quicker than Gasol and theres a reason he has 3 all nba first team D and 3 all nba second team D and Gasol has nothing

on defense theres no contest

That's because he didn't have to go up against Duncan and KG. You say, well, he'd still get 2nd Team, no, he still has to contend against guys like Bowen, Artest, Battier, Lebron etc. The forward position is much stronger defensively today than in his era.

McHale was the better player

Gasol will be the better GM

McHale were Gasol were both comparable offensively, both in terms of scoring and passing (well really, Gasol is the superior passer but it's not enough to make a large difference). Rebounding is generally a wash career-wise (maybe not peak though, Gasol looks like a new man this year). Overall, it's the defense that separates them and McHale was just a flat-out better defender. It's not a ridiculously large gap or anything but it's there. McHale was also the more aggressive, more explosive scorer generally, that has to be mentioned even though Gasol is clearly a 20 ppg threat every night.

LebronsCavs wrote:Gasol pretty easily.

lmao. It's like you want people to laugh at your posts.

Sedale Threatt wrote:

LebronsCavs wrote:Gasol pretty easily.

Did you see McHale play even a second of live basketball?

Mean_Streets wrote:Gasol is a better rebounder & passer, while McHale has more post moves & is a better defender. Give me McHale.

This is about dead-on accurate. Gasol is excellent, McHale was better.

I agree with Mean Streets and Sedale about their analysis of these two players. I would prefer Gasol for his passing skills and better rebounding but I understand why some would prefer McHale for his post play and defense.

Lakerfan17 wrote:Who's better.

The guy who is considered top 25-30 all time.


Lakers fans always trying to make it where there stars are better. We will seeing some Andrew Bynum vs Hakeem Olajuwon comparisons in another year.