Trading into the 1st round
Moderators: dms269, HMFFL, Jamaaliver
Trading into the 1st round
- ATLfan
- Junior
- Posts: 488
- And1: 0
- Joined: Jun 12, 2007
- Location: Shocking the World!!!
Trading into the 1st round
What players should we try and get with a late first round pick?
- evildallas
- General Manager
- Posts: 9,412
- And1: 1
- Joined: Aug 11, 2005
- Location: in the land of weak ownership
- Contact:
I think Bill Walker is going to be a 2nd round steal for whomever drafts him. Also, I expect Joey Dorsey and DJ White to be this year's 2nd round PF instant contributors at the next level.
If you have confidence in your evaluation and opening on your team that means playing time then I don't mind it being a late 1st to make sure you get the player. The price isn't that bad. A late first is only bad is your are in luxury tax area or you have no PT available in the first 10 slots on your roster.
The Hawks have enough room for a good rookie to contribute, but I not sure about the evaluation skills. If BK was still in control it would be a waste to acquire a lower pick for him to squander. Since a replacement isn't in place yet, who knows if it has gotten better.
If you have confidence in your evaluation and opening on your team that means playing time then I don't mind it being a late 1st to make sure you get the player. The price isn't that bad. A late first is only bad is your are in luxury tax area or you have no PT available in the first 10 slots on your roster.
The Hawks have enough room for a good rookie to contribute, but I not sure about the evaluation skills. If BK was still in control it would be a waste to acquire a lower pick for him to squander. Since a replacement isn't in place yet, who knows if it has gotten better.
Going to donkey punch a leprechaun!
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 9,321
- And1: 3
- Joined: Apr 18, 2006
Good call on Bill Walker. He is a freak athlete who was productive in his first full year of college basketball. I have no idea why he's projected to go in the second round but I'm guessing his stock will go up after his workouts.
It's amazing how players who were 5 star highschool recruits(Ellis,Blatche,etc)can go later in the draft than players you just know are going to be non-factors like a Wayne Simeon or a Mark Madsen. Even a player like Jackie Butler(who is out of the league)is a smarter pick than players like Donta Smith,Salim,or Solo(any many people wanted Milsap over Solo at the time). I don't want to nitpick over a 2nd rounder(because BK bricked all 3 second rounders AND the AJ trade) but why the hell would you pick Salim over top 5 HS players who are much younger and much more athletic like Lou Williams or Monta Ellis? There is no risk in picking the player with the highest upside when you get past the 20th pick or so. I'd like to trade our 2nd rounder next year to Minny(if the reports are true)for the chance to draft Walker or Lawson.
It's amazing how players who were 5 star highschool recruits(Ellis,Blatche,etc)can go later in the draft than players you just know are going to be non-factors like a Wayne Simeon or a Mark Madsen. Even a player like Jackie Butler(who is out of the league)is a smarter pick than players like Donta Smith,Salim,or Solo(any many people wanted Milsap over Solo at the time). I don't want to nitpick over a 2nd rounder(because BK bricked all 3 second rounders AND the AJ trade) but why the hell would you pick Salim over top 5 HS players who are much younger and much more athletic like Lou Williams or Monta Ellis? There is no risk in picking the player with the highest upside when you get past the 20th pick or so. I'd like to trade our 2nd rounder next year to Minny(if the reports are true)for the chance to draft Walker or Lawson.
- Jamaaliver
- Forum Mod - Hawks
- Posts: 45,098
- And1: 17,123
- Joined: Sep 22, 2005
- Location: Officially a citizen of the World...
- Contact:
-
No more rookies!!!!!!
We have youth at EVERY position.
We are the youngest team in the league....AGAIN!!!!!
We'll be adding two more rooks next year. (Most likely).
Let's focus on adding experienced vets to our bench.
Acquiring big men who'll protect the paint against easy layups.
And getting shooters with a proven track record of hitting big shots.
We have youth at EVERY position.
We are the youngest team in the league....AGAIN!!!!!
We'll be adding two more rooks next year. (Most likely).
Let's focus on adding experienced vets to our bench.
Acquiring big men who'll protect the paint against easy layups.
And getting shooters with a proven track record of hitting big shots.
- LL Cool Scott
- Starter
- Posts: 2,454
- And1: 0
- Joined: Aug 11, 2006
Jamaaliver wrote:No more rookies!!!!!!
We have youth at EVERY position.
We are the youngest team in the league....AGAIN!!!!!
We'll be adding two more rooks next year. (Most likely).
Let's focus on adding experienced vets to our bench.
Acquiring big men who'll protect the paint against easy layups.
And getting shooters with a proven track record of hitting big shots.
I hear you, but good franchises build through the draft, not through free agency. When's the last time you saw the Spurs or Pistons add a big-time free agent? Plus, rookies are a lot cheaper than vets and we all know that our owners will never spend big bucks. Big men who can anchor the middle and clutch shooters don't come cheap.
- Jamaaliver
- Forum Mod - Hawks
- Posts: 45,098
- And1: 17,123
- Joined: Sep 22, 2005
- Location: Officially a citizen of the World...
- Contact:
-
I hear you, but good franchises build through the draft, not through free agency. When's the last time you saw the Spurs or Pistons add a big-time free agent? Plus, rookies are a lot cheaper than vets and we all know that our owners will never spend big bucks. Big men who can anchor the middle and clutch shooters don't come cheap.
The Spurs and Pistons are two of the oldest teams in the league. They consistntly replace role players through free agency and trades.
McDyess, Kurt Thomas, Michael Finley, Rasheed wallace, Ben wallace, Rasho Nesterovic, Bruce Bowen. the infrastructure of each Championship caliber ball club is based on vets with definite skill sets. Stuckey has provided an usually consistent amount of help this postseason. But the past 5 years have been the Detroit 5 and vets on the bench. SA has had the same core for 5+ years with older players rotated in as necessary.
Young teams, like ours NEVER win anything in the NBA. EVER.
As long as we focus on youth and potential instead of vets and experienced winners, we will never win. We have 10 players 25 and under.
TEN!!!!!! Please, no more youth. let's get some guys with actual NBA experience in our locker room.
-
- Junior
- Posts: 429
- And1: 0
- Joined: Apr 07, 2005
you got to spend money to acquire vet's and last i checked our owners are pretty tight on spending. So our best chances are building thru the draft due to the rookie contracts , it seems to be getting us out of this hole that we have been in for the past 9 years.
and if we got a shot at getting into this year's draft i'm all for it , just as long as the price isn't too steep.
and if we got a shot at getting into this year's draft i'm all for it , just as long as the price isn't too steep.