Page 1 of 1

how much for josh smith

Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2011 10:27 am
by twxnsnckrs
i am daryl morey and i offer the following

aaron brooks
luis scola
yao ming

for

josh smith
jeff teague
marvin williams

deal?

what about

brooks
scola
hill
budinger

for

josh smith

any suggestions?

I think josh smith could be the next chris webber..but only under our coach. not drew

Re: how much for josh smith

Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2011 11:21 am
by Harry10
twxnsnckrs wrote:i am daryl morey and i offer the following

aaron brooks
luis scola
yao ming

for

josh smith
jeff teague
marvin williams

deal?

I think josh smith could be the next chris webber..but only under our coach. not drew


financially, the trade above doesn't work, Zaza would also have to be included

Brooks, Scola, and Yao for Josh, Teague, Marvin, and Zaza

............... it is a "maybe"

Re: how much for josh smith

Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2011 12:25 pm
by BrazilianHawk
LOL a "maybe" my a$$. :evil: I
'd do that in a heartbeat. I'd do Scola for Smoove straight up at this point. We need to break this rotten "core".

Re: how much for josh smith

Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2011 2:25 pm
by Geaux_Hawks
I would do deal 2 hands down...We can do better than deal one with other teams and deal 2 even is much better

Re: how much for josh smith

Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2011 4:28 pm
by evildallas
The problem is that Scola probably isn't available.

Re: how much for josh smith

Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2011 5:00 pm
by evildallas
To NJ
Josh Smith
For
Brook Lopez
Troy Murphy
1st round pick

use the pick with our own to acquire PG help.

Or make it a 3 way with Cleveland by sending Murphy, Bibby, and Evans for Sessions and Antwan Jamison.

Sessions/Teague
Johnson/Crawford/Crawford
Williams/Wilkins
Horford/Jamison/Powell
Lopez/Collins/Pachulia/Thomas

Re: how much for josh smith

Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2011 5:02 pm
by parson
evildallas wrote:To NJ
Josh Smith
For
Brook Lopez
Troy Murphy
1st round pick

use the pick with our own to acquire PG help.

Too late.

Re: how much for josh smith

Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2011 5:13 pm
by evildallas
Why? I hadn't heard the Murphy deal was official with Golden St. I think they might want to pair Josh with Deron.

EDIT - I've seen one report that Murphy is going to Golden St. so I guess it is too late to make the move. Oh well. Just get me a PG who can penetrate and I'll make do for now.

Re: how much for josh smith

Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2011 5:21 pm
by ATL DirtyBird
Im for whatever at this point. Trade any piece of this team outside of Horf.

Re: how much for josh smith

Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2011 11:52 pm
by Jamaaliver
Agreed. Aaron Brooks, Luis Scola fill big time needs on our team.

And we improve just by getting rid of Josh Smith.

Also, Smoove probably would thrive under a veteran coach like Adelman.

Re: how much for josh smith

Posted: Thu Feb 24, 2011 2:39 am
by #1 pick
evildallas wrote:Why? I hadn't heard the Murphy deal was official with Golden St. I think they might want to pair Josh with Deron.

EDIT - I've seen one report that Murphy is going to Golden St. so I guess it is too late to make the move. Oh well. Just get me a PG who can penetrate and I'll make do for now.

This deal is the only decent one I see.

Re: how much for josh smith

Posted: Thu Feb 24, 2011 5:10 pm
by re49gb_2gho32fp
hi guys, is ATL really shopping Smith?? I figure ATL needs a C in return in that case. What about this, working under CBA:

Batum + Oden + Babbitt + Johnson for Josh Smith + Sy

?
Problem is, POR loses 3pt shooting with this deal, with Smith at the 3.

Re: how much for josh smith

Posted: Thu Feb 24, 2011 5:51 pm
by theatlfan
shaolin wrote:hi guys, is ATL really shopping Smith?? I figure ATL needs a C in return in that case. What about this, working under CBA:

Batum + Oden + Babbitt + Johnson for Josh Smith + Sy

?
Problem is, POR loses 3pt shooting with this deal, with Smith at the 3.
No. It was an overreaction by a fan to a bad game. We aren't shopping Smith, but anyone on the roster is available if the package is good enough.

Still, the deal you propose has some merit. I could care less about Babbitt (you can keep him if you think it'd help with your 3 PT shooting), and at this point, we'd be more likely to view Oden as nothing more than an expiring, but Batum would be a nice upgrade on Marvin and Johnson is a decent prospect @ a position of need. It's not quite enough, but it'd be enough to start a conversation. If you kept Babbitt and Oden, would Camby be available?