Page 1 of 2
Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Tue Oct 31, 2017 5:58 pm
by Jamaaliver
A question I've been pondering since the start of the season:
Mike Cunningham wrote:Is center really the best fit for Hawks rookie John Collins?
As it stands now Collins will play “small ball” center for the Hawks. If he can develop his jump shot he can be a center in the mold of Al Horford, who has been one of the best mid-range shooting big men in the league over his career. As Collins gets stronger, he will be better able to handle bigger opponents as a defender and rebounder.
“I love his pressure on the rim as a big guy, rolling,” Budenholzer said. “I think his rebounding, his athleticism as a five (are assets). The way the game is played, his speed, I think, can really be something that can be really good for him and really good for us.”
The Hawks hope that John Collins eventually will develop his perimeter game but coach Mike Budenholzer already has the rookie playing as a (relatively) undersized center.
“A lot of our offense, really, they are the same,” Budenholzer said. “Our bigs are kind of interchangeable in what they do in their reads and reactions. For us, it’s not a huge deal. I think he puts a lot of pressure on the rim as a rolling big and the things he does that way. And defensively he can guard either spot. We’ll kind of mix-and-match depending on what’s best for him and whoever he’s playing with.
Mike Cunningham wrote:Already, Collins is a dangerous pick-and-roll man, a good help defender and a productive rebounder.
There are good reasons why Budenholzer wants to get Collins in a lot of one-five, pick-and-roll actions. He’s a “springy” leaper who gets to the rim quickly and has soft hands and nice touch. At Wake Forest, Collins was a fantastic roll man: his 1.609 points per possession ranked in the 99th percentile, according to Synergy Sports Technology.
However, Collins could overwhelm collegiate opponents with his athleticism and size. Finishing as the roll man is something different in the NBA, where everyone is big and athletic.
In the NBA, Collins has scored 0.89 PPP as the roll man on 26 possessions to rank in the 29th percentile among qualifying players, according to Synergy.
AJC
Re: Is Center the best position for the JC Kid?
Posted: Tue Oct 31, 2017 6:02 pm
by Jamaaliver
The position question is one we've faced with all of our drafted bigs over the years: Horford, Smoove.
With an upcoming draft filled with Center/PF prospects, is this a question we need solved now?
Or should we simply let things play out, acquiring as much talent as possible regardless of fit/positional need?
Defensively there have been moments where bigger opponents overpower Collins around the rim. But aside from the game against Dwight Howard, who can overpower most anybody, it hasn’t been a huge issue. Collins still gets his share of rebounds because of his quick-leaping ability but there, too, bigger opponents sometimes muscle him away from the basket.
Will this always be an issue with him at Center?
Re: Is Center really the best position for the John Collins?
Posted: Tue Oct 31, 2017 6:37 pm
by tbhawksfan1
He needs to play the position that puts him in the best position to contribute to the team. He also need to play the position that allows him to max his skills.
I get the impreeion that the Hawks always want to run out the NEW nba. Like, since BK and his all 6'8" interchangeable thing. Like Horf never playing with a C here and now skinney ass Collins is a C?
He's a PF for me and likely for him too. A minute at C maybe, but he's a PF
Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Tue Oct 31, 2017 7:31 pm
by macd-gm
Horford has played for something like 5 coaches and he's been used at PF for about half a season. I think the experts have been proven right on that one.
Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Tue Oct 31, 2017 7:33 pm
by graymule
Can we have another big man and JC on the floor together and, whether they are on offense or defense,
swap positions? If not, why not? Let JC be the center on offense and the PF on defense. In my sometimes
crazy mind, this would work nicely.
In this example, Moose plays center on defense and JC plays center on offense. After all, Moose can knock
down the three ball. It's not like he can't play away from the goal.
I know. I know. The entire idea is crazy. But, remember, sometimes crazy ideas actually work !!
Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Tue Oct 31, 2017 7:59 pm
by ATL Boy
It's driving me crazy that Collins is being played almost exclusively as a C this season, mostly because it's keeping him off the floor.
We're obviously not winning this season, the most important thing for the year is developing the young guys, the most effective way to do that is to give them playing time. It's not like Collins doesn't know how to play PF, that was his main position in college.
Sent from my iPhone using RealGM Forums
Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Wed Nov 1, 2017 4:51 am
by MaceCase
I'll just quote myself from elsewheres:
Bud is matching skillsets, something he's not alone in given that 99.99999% of the NBA is matching their frontcourts with at least one shooting big next to one paint big whether they be at PF or C. Even Rudy Gobert spends a third of his minutes with either Thabo or Joe at PF whilst the rest of the time Favors is attempting more and more 3s. Either Dedmon increases his volume of 3s or either the Uzbeki or Musky bulk up, till then Collins will play at Center because that's where his skillset is best suited and more importantly, where he is most comfortable within the context of the rest of roster. It's either that or you hope he transforms his game to current Blake Griffin or post knee injury Amar'e over night.
Really the nuts and bolts of it. Collins is adjusting to the NBA, it's best to allow him to do so in a manner that he's most comfortable with rather than having him make widespread adjustments to his game playing outside of his current strengths. He can work on that in the summer after he's gotten a sense of the speed and physicality of the league or the Hawks can acquire a C than can spread both for him and the rest of the team. Till then he's going to see a majority of his time at C given the roster construction and his current skillset.
Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Wed Nov 1, 2017 5:11 pm
by jayu70
Don't care where he plays for now - just want him playing more minutes and with the starters/best players on the team.
Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Wed Nov 1, 2017 6:45 pm
by macd-gm
jayu70 wrote:Don't care where he plays for now - just want him playing more minutes and with the starters/best players on the team.
No doubt. I'm good with him as the backup PG.
Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Mon Nov 27, 2017 4:42 pm
by Jamaaliver
An updated look at Collins’ development
In his last 13 games, Collins has spent more time on the floor against opposing first units, is now on the floor with Dewayne Dedmon at times, and his trips to the free throw line have been cut in half. Playing with Dedmon gives him the opportunity to build a more diverse skill-set on offense.
Early in the season, Collins exclusively played the center position. Recently, we have seen Coach Mike Budenholzer use Collins and Dedmon on the floor together, especially now that Collins has started the past three games.
Though Collins generally takes the center match-up on the defensive end, Dedmon and Collins become more interchangeable on the offensive end. This development gets Collins into more roles/actions on the offensive end in addition to screen-setting such as dribble-hand-off actions, working as a spacer or working in the weak-side dunker role.
Peachtree HoopsThoughts on Collins starting in the 4 spot after playing almost exclusively as a Center off the bench?
Is this a portent of things to come?
Is the JC Kid being prepped to potentially play alongside Ayton next year?
Does it even matter as the 4/5 spots are so interchangeable?
Does Collins emergence make Dedmon dispensable moving forward?
Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Mon Nov 27, 2017 5:14 pm
by macd-gm
Just seems like Collins will be an NBA PF once his game develops a little more. I know he's listed as the same height as Horford but Horford was never as quick or fluid as Collins so it made more sense for Al to be a Center. Plus Al was much stronger coming in and could handle centers on D. I think PF would maximize Collins impact on both sides of the floor.
Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Fri Dec 15, 2017 1:03 pm
by Jamaaliver
After the Hawks-Pistons matchup:
Mike Cunningham wrote:Collins faced the prospect of tangling with Pistons center Andre Drummond, who pushed him around during the first meeting in Detroit. Collins pregame: “Big body. Strong. Likes to bang around. It will be a real good test to see how my shoulder is doing. . . . It’s got to be a point of emphasis to keep him off the glass and limit his ability to control the game.” Drummond not only dominated the glass again (19 rebounds) but also recorded a career-high nine assists, including four in the decisive second quarter. (Collins wasn’t matched up with him much, though).
Collins postgame: “The system he’s in and the way he’s playing, it’s been pretty incredible. . . . He’s been on a tear. He’s playing really well right now. Can’t say much more than that.”
myAJCWill Collins ever be able to guard big 5s in this league? He has the height and athleticism, but lacks the girth and strength to tangle with a number of young pure Centers.
We saw him get a handful of starts at PF after playing almost exclusively as a backup Center previously. Have you guys seen anything to change your mind on the best position for him?
Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Fri Dec 15, 2017 3:18 pm
by macd-gm
I think long term he has to be a PF and small ball center. Horford had the strength to defend centers but also lacked the quickness and offensive explosiveness to be a PF. Collins has those things. Just needs to develop his jumper.
Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Fri Dec 15, 2017 5:21 pm
by Spud2nique
macd-gm wrote:I think long term he has to be a PF and small ball center. Horford had the strength to defend centers but also lacked the quickness and offensive explosiveness to be a PF. Collins has those things. Just needs to develop his jumper.
Agreed but his jumper looks fluid to me..great rotation on the ball and a timely high point release...just a matter of off season reps to build more confidence.
Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Fri Dec 15, 2017 5:44 pm
by jayu70
He has to get his man strength on - all in time. But there will be just centers who will be bigger and stronger just because they are.
Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Fri Dec 15, 2017 5:47 pm
by Spud2nique
Also think it's based on the draft...we get Ayton and Collins has to be the 4...we get Doncic, possibly the 5. Moving pieces into places the fit the puzzle.
Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Fri Dec 15, 2017 6:02 pm
by Jamaaliver
Spud2nique wrote:Also think it's based on the draft...we get Ayton and Collins has to be the 4...we get Doncic, possibly the 5. Moving pieces into places the fit the puzzle.
And if we get Bagley?

Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Fri Dec 15, 2017 6:37 pm
by Spud2nique
Jamaaliver wrote:Spud2nique wrote:Also think it's based on the draft...we get Ayton and Collins has to be the 4...we get Doncic, possibly the 5. Moving pieces into places the fit the puzzle.
And if we get Bagley?

Twin powers (forwards)?
I dunno, personally I would love a frontcourt of Prince/Bagley/Collins...specially with small ball in play.
Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Fri Dec 15, 2017 7:41 pm
by tbhawksfan1
Spud2nique wrote:Jamaaliver wrote:Spud2nique wrote:Also think it's based on the draft...we get Ayton and Collins has to be the 4...we get Doncic, possibly the 5. Moving pieces into places the fit the puzzle.
And if we get Bagley?

Twin powers (forwards)?
I dunno, personally I would love a frontcourt of Prince/Bagley/Collins...specially with small ball in play.
That looks fun and will get some wins, but when youget to the better teams and the intensity goes up, those guys would get dominated in the post. Need a starting CENTER to make sure teams can't take over the basket zone. Bring in the small ball at key moments, but got to have a big guy.
Since Dedmon went down, games have been getting close to blow-out level.
We saw the same thing with Sap / Horf, looked good until it got shut down at the end of every season.
Re: Is Center really the best position for John Collins?
Posted: Tue Dec 19, 2017 1:59 pm
by Jamaaliver
Michael Cunningham wrote:Miles Plumlee started at center in place of Dwayne Dedmon, as he has every game except one (at Cleveland).
Budenholzer said Plumlee would be the default starter until Dedmon returns, certain matchups notwithstanding. Plumlee played 23 productive and efficient minutes against the Heat: six points on five shots, four rebounds, two assists, one block, two turnovers. Two of Plumlee’ three field goals came on lob dunks.
myAJCDoes this mean that Collins is no longer being forced to play all his minutes at Center?
Or that Budenholzer is still trying to keep Collins out of the starting lineup at all costs?
Or just another part of the tank?