ImageImageImage

Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24

Moderators: bisme37, Parliament10, canman1971, shackles10, snowman, Froob, Darthlukey, Shak_Celts

User avatar
zoyathedestroya
RealGM
Posts: 41,125
And1: 98,277
Joined: Nov 05, 2017

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1521 » by zoyathedestroya » Thu Jul 20, 2023 2:52 am

165bows wrote:
ddb wrote:
zoyathedestroya wrote:Tbf, I haven’t seen anyone who’s said he’s unwilling or isn’t going to sign the supermax (which according to some has been offered already in some form). It is unusual though that it’s taken this long. My best guess is Stevens has other things in the pipeline (maybe Brogdon trade) that would affect the $$ this season and next couple so maybe he’s asked JB to hold off or has presented him different options.

If it’s the full supermax (not incentive-based), then I don’t know what else there is to negotiate other than the player option on the 5th year. Trade kicker won’t matter cos he’s already at the max.


I'd like to comment on the Brogdon piece of this. I went through every single team in the league and had a really difficult time finding Brogdon trades that would be good for the Celtics. 6th Man of the year. Solid veteran. If our second unit starts with Brogdon & Al that's a heck of a start to the bench unit.
Out of all the teams, the Clippers & Bulls were the teams that I kept going back to.

Because of the 2nd apron, the Clippers would have to send out Mann, Covington OR Batum AND Preston to make the $$ work for Brogdon. Would they do that? And would Boston do that? For Boston you HAVE to get Mann back. Otherwise, it's a no.

Chicago has guards. But none as good as Brogdon. To make the money work it would have to be something along the lines of Brogdon/Hauser for Caruso/PWilliams. Would the Bulls deal Patrick Williams this early in his career? He's still only 21 and shot it 41% from 3 last season. And Caruso is a topflight perimeter defender. Chicago probably doesn't do this deal unless Boston got creative and added the Golden State 1st they just acquired. Maybe multiple 1st rd picks. Brogdon/Hauser/two 1st for Caruso and Williams I would seriously consider. But then Boston is giving up assets they may want to hang on to for a "seismic" trade down the line. Tough call.
Bulls could be interesting with a Brogdon-Lavine-DDR-Craig-Vuc lineup. Boston would go White-JB-JT-KP-Timelord with Caruso-Pritchard-Brissett-Williams-Horford bench. Pretty interesting lineups for both teams, but I have a feeling both teams would shy away from this idea.

Other than that, any ideas? There's not much out there. The Spurs could put something together around Tre Jones & McDermott for Brogdon. Although, I'm not sure if Brogdon makes sense for them unless they want a veteran PG to help mentor their young talent.

So, with all that said it may just make more sense to keep Brogdon for now.

Nah, I’ve done the same exercise a few times over but it’s extremely slim pickings. At first it felt like Brogdon was inevitably out the door since the injury and well they practically traded him once. But there just isn’t a good fit. And imo he does fit well here he’s just injury prone.

I also settled on Chicago as a top option and had a complicated deal with Brogdon and other pieces for DDR/Caruso. Pretty much too tough to pull off though because of the restrictive salary rules so it’s just not realistic at this point.

I did like the White/Brown/Tatum/Al/Zinger starters with DDR/Caruso/Rob on the bench with a few other guys behind them. Really tough and deep team but wondering if maybe they just make some minors moves instead.

Of all the suggested trade ideas, I like hugepatsfans' Bogdanovic/Wright return the best. I feel that makes us better depending on your confidence in Wright and PP as playoff rotation guys. I don't think we're going after a 4th high-salaried guy unless there's already a plan in place to ship off JB next offseason.
Hal14
RealGM
Posts: 22,261
And1: 21,128
Joined: Apr 05, 2019

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1522 » by Hal14 » Thu Jul 20, 2023 2:57 am

ddb wrote:
Hal14 wrote:
Spoiler:
Diallo in the lab, working on his shooting:
Read on Twitter
?s=20

The shot looks good!

How about we look at some film?

Impressive. Love the hustle, energy and defense
Steals, blocks, hustling for loose balls, deflections
Wreaking havoc on D. Bringing energy on both ends of the floor

Speaking of defense and hustling for loose balls:
Read on Twitter
?s=20

Read on Twitter
?s=20

Wouldn't hate it if we signed him to the minimum



Diallo is a solid defensive wing. Great athlete. 6'5. More of a SG, but he can't shoot. He's essentially Javonte Green with a green light, which on the Celtics wouldn't be a good thing due the fact that there wouldn't be consistent minutes for him.

I'd rather bring back Javonte because of his familiarity to the team & city, and his friendship with Tatum. Plus, Javonte has turned himself into a respectable 3pt shooter, 37% last season. The other big reason why I'd prefer Javonte is because he's proven already that he can come in cold and find ways to contribute such as diving for loose balls, grabbing weak side offensive rebounds, and the occasional momentum turning dunk.

I'd really like Javonte back the more I think about it.

Yes, there's certainly a few similarities between Javonte and Diallo. And like you said, Javonte has been here before, is Tatum's buddy and has improved his shooting since he left Boston. Keep in mind though, the 37% from 3 last season is a little bit misleading, since it was only on 1.1 attempts per game and he only played in 37 games.

My main concerns with Javonte are:
1) He just had arthroscopic knee surgery in January. A scary thing for a guy who's about to turn 30 and relies on his athleticism quite a bit to be effective. You would think that hopefully by October, he'll be good to go, ready to play. But you never know..Diallo meanwhile also had a season ending injury, but it was just an ankle injury, he didn't need surgery for it and he didn't miss as many games as Javonte missed with his knee injury. And it looks like Diallo is fully healthy now - this was posted on May 26:
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/fhPsCm_hNVg

2) A little concerning that for a guy who's about to turn 30, Javonte has had just *one* season ever, where he played in over 41 games and 12+ MPG. By comparison, Diallo has already had *four* seasons with more than 41 games played and 12+ MPG (he's done it each of the past 4 seasons) - and Diallo is only 24 yrs old, so still getting better. Javonte has likely peaked at this point, especially coming off the knee surgery.

I think Diallo could have some untapped potential. Not only is he still pretty young, but he's been on a bad pistons team that has been tanking each of these past 2 years. And they fired their coach as soon as the season ended, so he probably wasn't getting great coaching. He could come here and really turn the corner.

My top choice though at this point for a free agent wing pickup is probably Danny Green..
Nothing wrong with having a different opinion - as long as it's done respectfully. It'd be lame if we all agreed on everything :)
User avatar
Celts17Pride
RealGM
Posts: 68,533
And1: 70,379
Joined: Nov 27, 2005

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1523 » by Celts17Pride » Thu Jul 20, 2023 3:14 am

ddb wrote:
zoyathedestroya wrote:
sam_I_am wrote:
If JB doesn’t sign ….. I’d be concerned about JB. He is the one who loses. Even as an expiring, Celtics can get some value for him in a trade and then they lose less to CBA. Better for Cs if he extends but he has a lot more to lose.

Tbf, I haven’t seen anyone who’s said he’s unwilling or isn’t going to sign the supermax (which according to some has been offered already in some form). It is unusual though that it’s taken this long. My best guess is Stevens has other things in the pipeline (maybe Brogdon trade) that would affect the $$ this season and next couple so maybe he’s asked JB to hold off or has presented him different options.

If it’s the full supermax (not incentive-based), then I don’t know what else there is to negotiate other than the player option on the 5th year. Trade kicker won’t matter cos he’s already at the max.


I'd like to comment on the Brogdon piece of this. I went through every single team in the league and had a really difficult time finding Brogdon trades that would be good for the Celtics. 6th Man of the year. Solid veteran. If our second unit starts with Brogdon & Al that's a heck of a start to the bench unit.
Out of all the teams, the Clippers & Bulls were the teams that I kept going back to.

Because of the 2nd apron, the Clippers would have to send out Mann, Covington OR Batum AND Preston to make the $$ work for Brogdon. Would they do that? And would Boston do that? For Boston you HAVE to get Mann back. Otherwise, it's a no.

Chicago has guards. But none as good as Brogdon. To make the money work it would have to be something along the lines of Brogdon/Hauser for Caruso/PWilliams. Would the Bulls deal Patrick Williams this early in his career? He's still only 21 and shot it 41% from 3 last season. And Caruso is a topflight perimeter defender. Chicago probably doesn't do this deal unless Boston got creative and added the Golden State 1st they just acquired. Maybe multiple 1st rd picks. Brogdon/Hauser/two 1st for Caruso and Williams I would seriously consider. But then Boston is giving up assets they may want to hang on to for a "seismic" trade down the line. Tough call.
Bulls could be interesting with a Brogdon-Lavine-DDR-Craig-Vuc lineup. Boston would go White-JB-JT-KP-Timelord with Caruso-Pritchard-Brissett-Williams-Horford bench. Pretty interesting lineups for both teams, but I have a feeling both teams would shy away from this idea.

Other than that, any ideas? There's not much out there. The Spurs could put something together around Tre Jones & McDermott for Brogdon. Although, I'm not sure if Brogdon makes sense for them unless they want a veteran PG to help mentor their young talent.

So, with all that said it may just make more sense to keep Brogdon for now.

Celtics likely to keep Brogdon because there is no market for Brogdon not because the Celtics are not willing to move him. I’m sure Stevens would love to move off his contract and his turnstile defense
Fencer reregistered
RealGM
Posts: 41,070
And1: 27,934
Joined: Oct 25, 2006

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1524 » by Fencer reregistered » Thu Jul 20, 2023 3:20 am

Rudy Gay is being bought out.

::gdr::
Banned temporarily for, among other sins, being "Extremely Deviant".
ddb
RealGM
Posts: 11,573
And1: 11,900
Joined: May 10, 2007

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1525 » by ddb » Thu Jul 20, 2023 3:24 am

165bows wrote:
ddb wrote:
zoyathedestroya wrote:Tbf, I haven’t seen anyone who’s said he’s unwilling or isn’t going to sign the supermax (which according to some has been offered already in some form). It is unusual though that it’s taken this long. My best guess is Stevens has other things in the pipeline (maybe Brogdon trade) that would affect the $$ this season and next couple so maybe he’s asked JB to hold off or has presented him different options.

If it’s the full supermax (not incentive-based), then I don’t know what else there is to negotiate other than the player option on the 5th year. Trade kicker won’t matter cos he’s already at the max.


I'd like to comment on the Brogdon piece of this. I went through every single team in the league and had a really difficult time finding Brogdon trades that would be good for the Celtics. 6th Man of the year. Solid veteran. If our second unit starts with Brogdon & Al that's a heck of a start to the bench unit.
Out of all the teams, the Clippers & Bulls were the teams that I kept going back to.

Because of the 2nd apron, the Clippers would have to send out Mann, Covington OR Batum AND Preston to make the $$ work for Brogdon. Would they do that? And would Boston do that? For Boston you HAVE to get Mann back. Otherwise, it's a no.

Chicago has guards. But none as good as Brogdon. To make the money work it would have to be something along the lines of Brogdon/Hauser for Caruso/PWilliams. Would the Bulls deal Patrick Williams this early in his career? He's still only 21 and shot it 41% from 3 last season. And Caruso is a topflight perimeter defender. Chicago probably doesn't do this deal unless Boston got creative and added the Golden State 1st they just acquired. Maybe multiple 1st rd picks. Brogdon/Hauser/two 1st for Caruso and Williams I would seriously consider. But then Boston is giving up assets they may want to hang on to for a "seismic" trade down the line. Tough call.
Bulls could be interesting with a Brogdon-Lavine-DDR-Craig-Vuc lineup. Boston would go White-JB-JT-KP-Timelord with Caruso-Pritchard-Brissett-Williams-Horford bench. Pretty interesting lineups for both teams, but I have a feeling both teams would shy away from this idea.

Other than that, any ideas? There's not much out there. The Spurs could put something together around Tre Jones & McDermott for Brogdon. Although, I'm not sure if Brogdon makes sense for them unless they want a veteran PG to help mentor their young talent.

So, with all that said it may just make more sense to keep Brogdon for now.

Nah, I’ve done the same exercise a few times over but it’s extremely slim pickings. At first it felt like Brogdon was inevitably out the door since the injury and well they practically traded him once. But there just isn’t a good fit. And imo he does fit well here he’s just injury prone.

I also settled on Chicago as a top option and had a complicated deal with Brogdon and other pieces for DDR/Caruso. Pretty much too tough to pull off though because of the restrictive salary rules so it’s just not realistic at this point.

I did like the White/Brown/Tatum/Al/Zinger starters with DDR/Caruso/Rob on the bench with a few other guys behind them. Really tough and deep team but wondering if maybe they just make some minors moves instead.


What was your trade package for DDR & Caruso? I'm not sure DDR is at the point in his career where he'd be cool coming off the bench.
ddb
RealGM
Posts: 11,573
And1: 11,900
Joined: May 10, 2007

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1526 » by ddb » Thu Jul 20, 2023 3:28 am

Hal14 wrote:
ddb wrote:
Hal14 wrote:
Spoiler:
Diallo in the lab, working on his shooting:
Read on Twitter
?s=20

The shot looks good!

How about we look at some film?

Impressive. Love the hustle, energy and defense
Steals, blocks, hustling for loose balls, deflections
Wreaking havoc on D. Bringing energy on both ends of the floor

Speaking of defense and hustling for loose balls:
Read on Twitter
?s=20

Read on Twitter
?s=20

Wouldn't hate it if we signed him to the minimum



Diallo is a solid defensive wing. Great athlete. 6'5. More of a SG, but he can't shoot. He's essentially Javonte Green with a green light, which on the Celtics wouldn't be a good thing due the fact that there wouldn't be consistent minutes for him.

I'd rather bring back Javonte because of his familiarity to the team & city, and his friendship with Tatum. Plus, Javonte has turned himself into a respectable 3pt shooter, 37% last season. The other big reason why I'd prefer Javonte is because he's proven already that he can come in cold and find ways to contribute such as diving for loose balls, grabbing weak side offensive rebounds, and the occasional momentum turning dunk.

I'd really like Javonte back the more I think about it.

Yes, there's certainly a few similarities between Javonte and Diallo. And like you said, Javonte has been here before, is Tatum's buddy and has improved his shooting since he left Boston. Keep in mind though, the 37% from 3 last season is a little bit misleading, since it was only on 1.1 attempts per game and he only played in 37 games.

My main concerns with Javonte are:
1) He just had arthroscopic knee surgery in January. A scary thing for a guy who's about to turn 30 and relies on his athleticism quite a bit to be effective. You would think that hopefully by October, he'll be good to go, ready to play. But you never know..Diallo meanwhile also had a season ending injury, but it was just an ankle injury, he didn't need surgery for it and he didn't miss as many games as Javonte missed with his knee injury. And it looks like Diallo is fully healthy now - this was posted on May 26:
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/fhPsCm_hNVg

2) A little concerning that for a guy who's about to turn 30, Javonte has had just *one* season ever, where he played in over 41 games and 12+ MPG. By comparison, Diallo has already had *four* seasons with more than 41 games played and 12+ MPG (he's done it each of the past 4 seasons) - and Diallo is only 24 yrs old, so still getting better. Javonte has likely peaked at this point, especially coming off the knee surgery.

I think Diallo could have some untapped potential. Not only is he still pretty young, but he's been on a bad pistons team that has been tanking each of these past 2 years. And they fired their coach as soon as the season ended, so he probably wasn't getting great coaching. He could come here and really turn the corner.

My top choice though at this point for a free agent wing pickup is probably Danny Green..


What about bringing Reggie Miller out of retirement?
User avatar
Fierce1
RealGM
Posts: 19,501
And1: 16,881
Joined: Jan 31, 2021
   

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1527 » by Fierce1 » Thu Jul 20, 2023 5:38 am

ddb wrote:
Hal14 wrote:
ddb wrote:
Diallo is a solid defensive wing. Great athlete. 6'5. More of a SG, but he can't shoot. He's essentially Javonte Green with a green light, which on the Celtics wouldn't be a good thing due the fact that there wouldn't be consistent minutes for him.

I'd rather bring back Javonte because of his familiarity to the team & city, and his friendship with Tatum. Plus, Javonte has turned himself into a respectable 3pt shooter, 37% last season. The other big reason why I'd prefer Javonte is because he's proven already that he can come in cold and find ways to contribute such as diving for loose balls, grabbing weak side offensive rebounds, and the occasional momentum turning dunk.

I'd really like Javonte back the more I think about it.

Yes, there's certainly a few similarities between Javonte and Diallo. And like you said, Javonte has been here before, is Tatum's buddy and has improved his shooting since he left Boston. Keep in mind though, the 37% from 3 last season is a little bit misleading, since it was only on 1.1 attempts per game and he only played in 37 games.

My main concerns with Javonte are:
1) He just had arthroscopic knee surgery in January. A scary thing for a guy who's about to turn 30 and relies on his athleticism quite a bit to be effective. You would think that hopefully by October, he'll be good to go, ready to play. But you never know..Diallo meanwhile also had a season ending injury, but it was just an ankle injury, he didn't need surgery for it and he didn't miss as many games as Javonte missed with his knee injury. And it looks like Diallo is fully healthy now - this was posted on May 26:
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/fhPsCm_hNVg

2) A little concerning that for a guy who's about to turn 30, Javonte has had just *one* season ever, where he played in over 41 games and 12+ MPG. By comparison, Diallo has already had *four* seasons with more than 41 games played and 12+ MPG (he's done it each of the past 4 seasons) - and Diallo is only 24 yrs old, so still getting better. Javonte has likely peaked at this point, especially coming off the knee surgery.

I think Diallo could have some untapped potential. Not only is he still pretty young, but he's been on a bad pistons team that has been tanking each of these past 2 years. And they fired their coach as soon as the season ended, so he probably wasn't getting great coaching. He could come here and really turn the corner.

My top choice though at this point for a free agent wing pickup is probably Danny Green..


What about bringing Reggie Miller out of retirement?

Ray Allen is younger.
:lol:
User avatar
zoyathedestroya
RealGM
Posts: 41,125
And1: 98,277
Joined: Nov 05, 2017

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1528 » by zoyathedestroya » Thu Jul 20, 2023 6:24 am

Image
User avatar
31to6
RealGM
Posts: 20,620
And1: 31,059
Joined: Nov 20, 2004
Location: Tatum train

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1529 » by 31to6 » Thu Jul 20, 2023 11:31 am

zoyathedestroya wrote:Image


That’s some quality company! And women’s pants.
Paul Pierce appreciation society.
User avatar
steefP2
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,843
And1: 9,750
Joined: Apr 25, 2011
 

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1530 » by steefP2 » Thu Jul 20, 2023 12:19 pm

Larry_Russell wrote:
bisme37 wrote:I've been thinking we need a legit pass-first playmaking point guard. But I have no idea who it is.

There are very few of them left in the league these days and most teams don't have one, including most of the recent champions. And then when I start thinking of names, most of them aren't better players than the guards we have and therefore would probably not even get minutes.

So now I'm wondering why I've been so obsessed with getting a pass-first playmaking point guard when it's not really a thing that most Championship teams have or need.



Championship teams have a lead "playmaker" though.
Assist %s

Jokic 46.6
Warriors - 2 above 30
Bucks - 3 above 23
Lakers - Lebron at 49
Raptors - Lowry at 35
Warriors - 2 at 25 - 1 at 30
Warriors 1 at 27 and 1 at 31
Cavs LEbron 36 Kyrie 26
etc
etc
etc

All the championship teams have at least 1 guy at or above 30 with the exception of the bucks who had 3 guys over 23.


Based on last year numbers our top guys were
Smart at 26.5 ------Gone
Brogdon at 21.5
Tatum at 20.9
White at 19.5
Brown at 16.5


KP last year was 12.9

I am not sure where to find Whites assist% in games without Smart last year but his APG was just a smidge over 5. Shiort of Smarts average of 6.3

So that means our best passer will be at around 25% assist rate. Well short of needing at least one over 30.




Just as additional info; white played roughly 21% of his minutes at the 1 and in those minutes he had had a usage of 22 and assist % of 26.8. So he seems fine taking over the smart role at the very least
Hal14
RealGM
Posts: 22,261
And1: 21,128
Joined: Apr 05, 2019

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1531 » by Hal14 » Thu Jul 20, 2023 12:20 pm

ddb wrote:
Hal14 wrote:
ddb wrote:
Diallo is a solid defensive wing. Great athlete. 6'5. More of a SG, but he can't shoot. He's essentially Javonte Green with a green light, which on the Celtics wouldn't be a good thing due the fact that there wouldn't be consistent minutes for him.

I'd rather bring back Javonte because of his familiarity to the team & city, and his friendship with Tatum. Plus, Javonte has turned himself into a respectable 3pt shooter, 37% last season. The other big reason why I'd prefer Javonte is because he's proven already that he can come in cold and find ways to contribute such as diving for loose balls, grabbing weak side offensive rebounds, and the occasional momentum turning dunk.

I'd really like Javonte back the more I think about it.

Yes, there's certainly a few similarities between Javonte and Diallo. And like you said, Javonte has been here before, is Tatum's buddy and has improved his shooting since he left Boston. Keep in mind though, the 37% from 3 last season is a little bit misleading, since it was only on 1.1 attempts per game and he only played in 37 games.

My main concerns with Javonte are:
1) He just had arthroscopic knee surgery in January. A scary thing for a guy who's about to turn 30 and relies on his athleticism quite a bit to be effective. You would think that hopefully by October, he'll be good to go, ready to play. But you never know..Diallo meanwhile also had a season ending injury, but it was just an ankle injury, he didn't need surgery for it and he didn't miss as many games as Javonte missed with his knee injury. And it looks like Diallo is fully healthy now - this was posted on May 26:
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/fhPsCm_hNVg

2) A little concerning that for a guy who's about to turn 30, Javonte has had just *one* season ever, where he played in over 41 games and 12+ MPG. By comparison, Diallo has already had *four* seasons with more than 41 games played and 12+ MPG (he's done it each of the past 4 seasons) - and Diallo is only 24 yrs old, so still getting better. Javonte has likely peaked at this point, especially coming off the knee surgery.

I think Diallo could have some untapped potential. Not only is he still pretty young, but he's been on a bad pistons team that has been tanking each of these past 2 years. And they fired their coach as soon as the season ended, so he probably wasn't getting great coaching. He could come here and really turn the corner.

My top choice though at this point for a free agent wing pickup is probably Danny Green..


What about bringing Reggie Miller out of retirement?

Is this supposed to be a joke or something?

Danny Green is still a quality NBA player. He just turned 36. He's 2 yrs younger than LeBron, 2 yrs younger than PJ Tucker, a year younger than Horford, 2 yrs younger than CP3. Green was getting playoff minutes for the Cavs just 2 months ago, despite the fact that he returned to the lineup only 8 months after surgery for a torn ACL (which typically takes at least 12 months to recover from). He was 5th on the sixers in minutes and 5th on the sixers in points in the 2022 playoff series vs Toronto, the last playoff series before tearing his ACL .

Reggie MIller is 57 yrs old.
Nothing wrong with having a different opinion - as long as it's done respectfully. It'd be lame if we all agreed on everything :)
User avatar
steefP2
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,843
And1: 9,750
Joined: Apr 25, 2011
 

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1532 » by steefP2 » Thu Jul 20, 2023 12:22 pm

But ultimately they’re kinda forcing Tatum to make the Great Playmaking Leap. Let’s hope it works
robdog_5
Veteran
Posts: 2,872
And1: 2,319
Joined: Feb 03, 2017
   

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1533 » by robdog_5 » Thu Jul 20, 2023 12:46 pm

Feels like there is some decent end of rotation/bench players to choose from. Depends on your thought process. Younger guys who can maybe make impact via energy in moments. Older vets who can come in a give you pro mins despite not having regular time (like Blake did last year).

Maybe waiting out a trade if some teams have to shed $ or roster spot like OKC or maybe Blazers if they have to take back a lot of players to make Dame trade work.
Spotter
Ballboy
Posts: 35
And1: 45
Joined: Jun 12, 2022
 

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1534 » by Spotter » Thu Jul 20, 2023 1:42 pm

ddb wrote:
zoyathedestroya wrote:
sam_I_am wrote:
If JB doesn’t sign ….. I’d be concerned about JB. He is the one who loses. Even as an expiring, Celtics can get some value for him in a trade and then they lose less to CBA. Better for Cs if he extends but he has a lot more to lose.

Tbf, I haven’t seen anyone who’s said he’s unwilling or isn’t going to sign the supermax (which according to some has been offered already in some form). It is unusual though that it’s taken this long. My best guess is Stevens has other things in the pipeline (maybe Brogdon trade) that would affect the $$ this season and next couple so maybe he’s asked JB to hold off or has presented him different options.

If it’s the full supermax (not incentive-based), then I don’t know what else there is to negotiate other than the player option on the 5th year. Trade kicker won’t matter cos he’s already at the max.


I'd like to comment on the Brogdon piece of this. I went through every single team in the league and had a really difficult time finding Brogdon trades that would be good for the Celtics. 6th Man of the year. Solid veteran. If our second unit starts with Brogdon & Al that's a heck of a start to the bench unit.
Out of all the teams, the Clippers & Bulls were the teams that I kept going back to.

Because of the 2nd apron, the Clippers would have to send out Mann, Covington OR Batum AND Preston to make the $$ work for Brogdon. Would they do that? And would Boston do that? For Boston you HAVE to get Mann back. Otherwise, it's a no.

Chicago has guards. But none as good as Brogdon. To make the money work it would have to be something along the lines of Brogdon/Hauser for Caruso/PWilliams. Would the Bulls deal Patrick Williams this early in his career? He's still only 21 and shot it 41% from 3 last season. And Caruso is a topflight perimeter defender. Chicago probably doesn't do this deal unless Boston got creative and added the Golden State 1st they just acquired. Maybe multiple 1st rd picks. Brogdon/Hauser/two 1st for Caruso and Williams I would seriously consider. But then Boston is giving up assets they may want to hang on to for a "seismic" trade down the line. Tough call.
Bulls could be interesting with a Brogdon-Lavine-DDR-Craig-Vuc lineup. Boston would go White-JB-JT-KP-Timelord with Caruso-Pritchard-Brissett-Williams-Horford bench. Pretty interesting lineups for both teams, but I have a feeling both teams would shy away from this idea.

Other than that, any ideas? There's not much out there. The Spurs could put something together around Tre Jones & McDermott for Brogdon. Although, I'm not sure if Brogdon makes sense for them unless they want a veteran PG to help mentor their young talent.

So, with all that said it may just make more sense to keep Brogdon for now.


I agree that keeping Brogdon is most likely to happen. White, Brogdon and PP is similar to the three guard lineup the Celtics had in the 2022 finals run. Finding a trade right now is difficult plus Brogdon is not a salary dump. So the acquiring team is looking at him as an upgraded piece to their rotation. Certainly the Clippers come to mind but it seems that ship has sailed. I think the Celtics intend to stay under that second apron and they are right there. I know the media keeps believing there is another move to make with this top seven player rotation but I’m thinking this is it. White, JB, JT, KP. RW, AH and Brogdon.
User avatar
zoyathedestroya
RealGM
Posts: 41,125
And1: 98,277
Joined: Nov 05, 2017

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1535 » by zoyathedestroya » Thu Jul 20, 2023 1:42 pm

Read on Twitter

Read on Twitter
User avatar
165bows
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 22,176
And1: 15,040
Joined: Jan 03, 2013
Location: The land of incremental improvement.

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1536 » by 165bows » Thu Jul 20, 2023 2:06 pm

ddb wrote:
165bows wrote:
ddb wrote:
I'd like to comment on the Brogdon piece of this. I went through every single team in the league and had a really difficult time finding Brogdon trades that would be good for the Celtics. 6th Man of the year. Solid veteran. If our second unit starts with Brogdon & Al that's a heck of a start to the bench unit.
Out of all the teams, the Clippers & Bulls were the teams that I kept going back to.

Because of the 2nd apron, the Clippers would have to send out Mann, Covington OR Batum AND Preston to make the $$ work for Brogdon. Would they do that? And would Boston do that? For Boston you HAVE to get Mann back. Otherwise, it's a no.

Chicago has guards. But none as good as Brogdon. To make the money work it would have to be something along the lines of Brogdon/Hauser for Caruso/PWilliams. Would the Bulls deal Patrick Williams this early in his career? He's still only 21 and shot it 41% from 3 last season. And Caruso is a topflight perimeter defender. Chicago probably doesn't do this deal unless Boston got creative and added the Golden State 1st they just acquired. Maybe multiple 1st rd picks. Brogdon/Hauser/two 1st for Caruso and Williams I would seriously consider. But then Boston is giving up assets they may want to hang on to for a "seismic" trade down the line. Tough call.
Bulls could be interesting with a Brogdon-Lavine-DDR-Craig-Vuc lineup. Boston would go White-JB-JT-KP-Timelord with Caruso-Pritchard-Brissett-Williams-Horford bench. Pretty interesting lineups for both teams, but I have a feeling both teams would shy away from this idea.

Other than that, any ideas? There's not much out there. The Spurs could put something together around Tre Jones & McDermott for Brogdon. Although, I'm not sure if Brogdon makes sense for them unless they want a veteran PG to help mentor their young talent.

So, with all that said it may just make more sense to keep Brogdon for now.

Nah, I’ve done the same exercise a few times over but it’s extremely slim pickings. At first it felt like Brogdon was inevitably out the door since the injury and well they practically traded him once. But there just isn’t a good fit. And imo he does fit well here he’s just injury prone.

I also settled on Chicago as a top option and had a complicated deal with Brogdon and other pieces for DDR/Caruso. Pretty much too tough to pull off though because of the restrictive salary rules so it’s just not realistic at this point.

I did like the White/Brown/Tatum/Al/Zinger starters with DDR/Caruso/Rob on the bench with a few other guys behind them. Really tough and deep team but wondering if maybe they just make some minors moves instead.


What was your trade package for DDR & Caruso? I'm not sure DDR is at the point in his career where he'd be cool coming off the bench.

Well like I mentioned, complicated to get both guys and replace Brogs scoring and then also his spot in the back court. So it was MB and PP for DDR, and then using their TPE to get a guy like Gay who could then eventually be aggregated with Champs for Caruso. Plus add the 2 '24 picks from Boston and GS and second rounders.

So tl;dr Brogdon, PP, the TPE, Champagnie, 2 firsts and multiple seconds.

Too complicated though with the new rules (I think they would touch over the second apron which might trigger some salary aggregating restrictions, but not clear yet when those come into play).
User avatar
165bows
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 22,176
And1: 15,040
Joined: Jan 03, 2013
Location: The land of incremental improvement.

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1537 » by 165bows » Thu Jul 20, 2023 2:13 pm

zoyathedestroya wrote:
165bows wrote:
ddb wrote:
I'd like to comment on the Brogdon piece of this. I went through every single team in the league and had a really difficult time finding Brogdon trades that would be good for the Celtics. 6th Man of the year. Solid veteran. If our second unit starts with Brogdon & Al that's a heck of a start to the bench unit.
Out of all the teams, the Clippers & Bulls were the teams that I kept going back to.

Because of the 2nd apron, the Clippers would have to send out Mann, Covington OR Batum AND Preston to make the $$ work for Brogdon. Would they do that? And would Boston do that? For Boston you HAVE to get Mann back. Otherwise, it's a no.

Chicago has guards. But none as good as Brogdon. To make the money work it would have to be something along the lines of Brogdon/Hauser for Caruso/PWilliams. Would the Bulls deal Patrick Williams this early in his career? He's still only 21 and shot it 41% from 3 last season. And Caruso is a topflight perimeter defender. Chicago probably doesn't do this deal unless Boston got creative and added the Golden State 1st they just acquired. Maybe multiple 1st rd picks. Brogdon/Hauser/two 1st for Caruso and Williams I would seriously consider. But then Boston is giving up assets they may want to hang on to for a "seismic" trade down the line. Tough call.
Bulls could be interesting with a Brogdon-Lavine-DDR-Craig-Vuc lineup. Boston would go White-JB-JT-KP-Timelord with Caruso-Pritchard-Brissett-Williams-Horford bench. Pretty interesting lineups for both teams, but I have a feeling both teams would shy away from this idea.

Other than that, any ideas? There's not much out there. The Spurs could put something together around Tre Jones & McDermott for Brogdon. Although, I'm not sure if Brogdon makes sense for them unless they want a veteran PG to help mentor their young talent.

So, with all that said it may just make more sense to keep Brogdon for now.

Nah, I’ve done the same exercise a few times over but it’s extremely slim pickings. At first it felt like Brogdon was inevitably out the door since the injury and well they practically traded him once. But there just isn’t a good fit. And imo he does fit well here he’s just injury prone.

I also settled on Chicago as a top option and had a complicated deal with Brogdon and other pieces for DDR/Caruso. Pretty much too tough to pull off though because of the restrictive salary rules so it’s just not realistic at this point.

I did like the White/Brown/Tatum/Al/Zinger starters with DDR/Caruso/Rob on the bench with a few other guys behind them. Really tough and deep team but wondering if maybe they just make some minors moves instead.

Of all the suggested trade ideas, I like hugepatsfans' Bogdanovic/Wright return the best. I feel that makes us better depending on your confidence in Wright and PP as playoff rotation guys. I don't think we're going after a 4th high-salaried guy unless there's already a plan in place to ship off JB next offseason.

Yeah that's a solid option. Not convinced they are better that way but it is one of the small number of good options out there I've seen proposed.

Only other thing that really jumps out is getting someone younger that they think can either fill in for that role longer term and/or break out a bit. Guys that are in log jams that could be given extensions like Quickley, or one of Suggs/Cole Anthony. Then couple that with a backup 3/4 type.

But if they are going to dump some draft capital, would be nice to see it last and not just wash out within a couple seasons due to age so there's that direction as well. Really depends what the younger player is going to turn into though (eg compare Cole Anthony's numbers at the same age to Brunson - bigger and better all around at the same age, but idk what that ultimately becomes).

Feeling more like they prob stand pat on that end based on what Brad has said lately but we will see. I will say that if you look back on Brad's deals, he's really nabbed a lot of good players in a place of value - Brogdon, Horford, Zinger eg - all very good players that weren't at their high point (to put it mildly) of value. Derrick White as well - so he's leveraged good players that want to come here and gotten them relatively affordably when they weren't seen as valuable as they prob are.
User avatar
steefP2
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,843
And1: 9,750
Joined: Apr 25, 2011
 

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1538 » by steefP2 » Thu Jul 20, 2023 2:15 pm

Image


Just going further on the assist rates for players in the playoffs, this is the top 18 in raw assist % of these last playoffs. Smart is next on the board at spot 19.Tatum at 21.


Edit: minimum 200 minutes played
ddb
RealGM
Posts: 11,573
And1: 11,900
Joined: May 10, 2007

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1539 » by ddb » Thu Jul 20, 2023 2:19 pm

Hal14 wrote:
ddb wrote:
Hal14 wrote:Yes, there's certainly a few similarities between Javonte and Diallo. And like you said, Javonte has been here before, is Tatum's buddy and has improved his shooting since he left Boston. Keep in mind though, the 37% from 3 last season is a little bit misleading, since it was only on 1.1 attempts per game and he only played in 37 games.

My main concerns with Javonte are:
1) He just had arthroscopic knee surgery in January. A scary thing for a guy who's about to turn 30 and relies on his athleticism quite a bit to be effective. You would think that hopefully by October, he'll be good to go, ready to play. But you never know..Diallo meanwhile also had a season ending injury, but it was just an ankle injury, he didn't need surgery for it and he didn't miss as many games as Javonte missed with his knee injury. And it looks like Diallo is fully healthy now - this was posted on May 26:
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/fhPsCm_hNVg

2) A little concerning that for a guy who's about to turn 30, Javonte has had just *one* season ever, where he played in over 41 games and 12+ MPG. By comparison, Diallo has already had *four* seasons with more than 41 games played and 12+ MPG (he's done it each of the past 4 seasons) - and Diallo is only 24 yrs old, so still getting better. Javonte has likely peaked at this point, especially coming off the knee surgery.

I think Diallo could have some untapped potential. Not only is he still pretty young, but he's been on a bad pistons team that has been tanking each of these past 2 years. And they fired their coach as soon as the season ended, so he probably wasn't getting great coaching. He could come here and really turn the corner.

My top choice though at this point for a free agent wing pickup is probably Danny Green..


What about bringing Reggie Miller out of retirement?

Is this supposed to be a joke or something?

Danny Green is still a quality NBA player. He just turned 36. He's 2 yrs younger than LeBron, 2 yrs younger than PJ Tucker, a year younger than Horford, 2 yrs younger than CP3. Green was getting playoff minutes for the Cavs just 2 months ago, despite the fact that he returned to the lineup only 8 months after surgery for a torn ACL (which typically takes at least 12 months to recover from). He was 5th on the sixers in minutes and 5th on the sixers in points in the 2022 playoff series vs Toronto, the last playoff series before tearing his ACL .

Reggie MIller is 57 yrs old.


It's an obvious joke. Remember after C's acquired KG and formed the Big3, Ainge reached out to Reggie Miller about coming out of retirement? I guess not. I was joking.

Danny Green played 11 games last season. He's washed.
ddb
RealGM
Posts: 11,573
And1: 11,900
Joined: May 10, 2007

Re: Trade/Free Agency Thread, whose NINE is it anyways?? 2023-24 

Post#1540 » by ddb » Thu Jul 20, 2023 2:21 pm

Spotter wrote:
ddb wrote:
zoyathedestroya wrote:Tbf, I haven’t seen anyone who’s said he’s unwilling or isn’t going to sign the supermax (which according to some has been offered already in some form). It is unusual though that it’s taken this long. My best guess is Stevens has other things in the pipeline (maybe Brogdon trade) that would affect the $$ this season and next couple so maybe he’s asked JB to hold off or has presented him different options.

If it’s the full supermax (not incentive-based), then I don’t know what else there is to negotiate other than the player option on the 5th year. Trade kicker won’t matter cos he’s already at the max.


I'd like to comment on the Brogdon piece of this. I went through every single team in the league and had a really difficult time finding Brogdon trades that would be good for the Celtics. 6th Man of the year. Solid veteran. If our second unit starts with Brogdon & Al that's a heck of a start to the bench unit.
Out of all the teams, the Clippers & Bulls were the teams that I kept going back to.

Because of the 2nd apron, the Clippers would have to send out Mann, Covington OR Batum AND Preston to make the $$ work for Brogdon. Would they do that? And would Boston do that? For Boston you HAVE to get Mann back. Otherwise, it's a no.

Chicago has guards. But none as good as Brogdon. To make the money work it would have to be something along the lines of Brogdon/Hauser for Caruso/PWilliams. Would the Bulls deal Patrick Williams this early in his career? He's still only 21 and shot it 41% from 3 last season. And Caruso is a topflight perimeter defender. Chicago probably doesn't do this deal unless Boston got creative and added the Golden State 1st they just acquired. Maybe multiple 1st rd picks. Brogdon/Hauser/two 1st for Caruso and Williams I would seriously consider. But then Boston is giving up assets they may want to hang on to for a "seismic" trade down the line. Tough call.
Bulls could be interesting with a Brogdon-Lavine-DDR-Craig-Vuc lineup. Boston would go White-JB-JT-KP-Timelord with Caruso-Pritchard-Brissett-Williams-Horford bench. Pretty interesting lineups for both teams, but I have a feeling both teams would shy away from this idea.

Other than that, any ideas? There's not much out there. The Spurs could put something together around Tre Jones & McDermott for Brogdon. Although, I'm not sure if Brogdon makes sense for them unless they want a veteran PG to help mentor their young talent.

So, with all that said it may just make more sense to keep Brogdon for now.


I agree that keeping Brogdon is most likely to happen. White, Brogdon and PP is similar to the three guard lineup the Celtics had in the 2022 finals run. Finding a trade right now is difficult plus Brogdon is not a salary dump. So the acquiring team is looking at him as an upgraded piece to their rotation. Certainly the Clippers come to mind but it seems that ship has sailed. I think the Celtics intend to stay under that second apron and they are right there. I know the media keeps believing there is another move to make with this top seven player rotation but I’m thinking this is it. White, JB, JT, KP. RW, AH and Brogdon.


The Clippers ship has sailed, but I wouldn't be shocked to see that ship turn around and come back to port once they realize Morey isn't going to do a Harden deal.

Return to Boston Celtics