ImageImageImage

Trade Ideas Thread

Moderators: bisme37, Parliament10, canman1971, shackles10, snowman, Froob, Darthlukey, Shak_Celts

User avatar
GreenMachine
Head Coach
Posts: 6,416
And1: 998
Joined: Jun 05, 2003

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#261 » by GreenMachine » Thu Jul 31, 2014 7:54 am

KJandHondo35 wrote:^^^ Could also include any of the non-guaranteed contracts to get up to the max if necessary in Babb, Johnson, and Pressy.


But then we would be stuck paying a marginal player the max!

No no no no... The problem with all these Monroe ideas is... he simply isn't that good. He's not bad, but he's not an elite player, not even close. Paying him the max is something Dumars would do... and we have been making fun of him for years for paying marginal players way too much. There is a reason Monroe hasn't gotten that max offer from ANY team... he simply isn't worth it.
User avatar
GreenMachine
Head Coach
Posts: 6,416
And1: 998
Joined: Jun 05, 2003

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#262 » by GreenMachine » Thu Jul 31, 2014 7:56 am

kbrow20 wrote:What would you guys think of a three team trade?
Detroit get Bledsoe + Green
Boston get Dragic
Suns get Monroe + Jennings + 1st + 2nd of Boston

Detroit get their starting PG and fill a piece at SF they need
Drummond / Smith / Green / Meeks / Bledsoe

Boston get to move Green and get a great player back to play next to Rondo since Rondo can't shoot.
KO / Sullinger / Wallace / Dragic / Rondo

Suns get a legit C and get a Dragic Replacement
Monroe / Morris / Tucker / Jennings / Thomas


The only problem with this is that the Suns aren't idiots.
kbrow20
Pro Prospect
Posts: 818
And1: 40
Joined: Jul 12, 2014
       

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#263 » by kbrow20 » Thu Jul 31, 2014 9:42 am

GreenMachine wrote:
kbrow20 wrote:What would you guys think of a three team trade?
Detroit get Bledsoe + Green
Boston get Dragic
Suns get Monroe + Jennings + 1st + 2nd of Boston

Detroit get their starting PG and fill a piece at SF they need
Drummond / Smith / Green / Meeks / Bledsoe

Boston get to move Green and get a great player back to play next to Rondo since Rondo can't shoot.
KO / Sullinger / Wallace / Dragic / Rondo

Suns get a legit C and get a Dragic Replacement
Monroe / Morris / Tucker / Jennings / Thomas


The only problem with this is that the Suns aren't idiots.

Yeah you might have to add a young talent like Young or so
RightToCensor wrote:Rubio is just too damn inefficient to be a team's primary option for offense. He needs to play in a system offense for you to get the best out of him. Trade him to New York, Dallas, or any other team that could use a poor-man's Rajon Rondo.
Really LOL
KGboss
RealGM
Posts: 21,217
And1: 10,097
Joined: Mar 03, 2011
Location: Boston Garden
       

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#264 » by KGboss » Thu Jul 31, 2014 12:43 pm

Or anything other than just green and a pick.....

Sent from my SCH-I545 using RealGM Forums mobile app
TruthBucket
Junior
Posts: 282
And1: 289
Joined: Jun 25, 2014
         

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#265 » by TruthBucket » Thu Jul 31, 2014 12:51 pm

I really like Goran Dragic...I really do. In fact Phoenix has 2 PGs I covet more than Rondo. Sorry, but its true. But if we are looking to pluck a PG from Phoenix I think we would be better suited to go after Bledsoe.

There is a rift between Bledsoe and Phoenix right now so it may be doable. Also he is younger. As much as I really like Dragic and think he is still underrated. He is not as young as some might think. He will already be 29 by the time next season is over. For a rebuilding team like Boston, I just dont see Dragic as the answer. Maybe if we pulled off some more moves quickly to become relevant during his prime.
User avatar
KJandHondo35
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,829
And1: 1,259
Joined: Dec 18, 2013
     

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#266 » by KJandHondo35 » Thu Jul 31, 2014 1:12 pm

GreenMachine wrote:
KJandHondo35 wrote:^^^ Could also include any of the non-guaranteed contracts to get up to the max if necessary in Babb, Johnson, and Pressy.


But then we would be stuck paying a marginal player the max!

No no no no... The problem with all these Monroe ideas is... he simply isn't that good. He's not bad, but he's not an elite player, not even close. Paying him the max is something Dumars would do... and we have been making fun of him for years for paying marginal players way too much. There is a reason Monroe hasn't gotten that max offer from ANY team... he simply isn't worth it.

I guess we'll just agree to disagree…

Monroe can provide average post defense (many statistics have echoed this and I’ve posted them), and exceptional offensive production from the center position. So exceptional that in a down year last season (due to poor coaching and a crowded front court) Monroe still had the 5th best offensive/rebounding numbers in the NBA out of the 5 spot.

You compare his 16-10-3 to Gortat’s 13-10 or Bosh’s 16-6, he’s incredibly comparable if not better and he is 24 while those others are 30. He’s not a blocks guy (could improve however if playing the 5) but he’s very good in the Stls category and when you take stls + blocks he’s right there with those 2 “Max” or near “Max” centers. Gortat has 2.0 blks+Stls, Bosh has 2.1 and Monroe has 1.7 but the 2 previous seasons he had 2.0 blks+Stls…

He’s also one of the best post passers in the NBA, probably floating close to Marc Gasol level passing ability (Gasol Career average Ast/g is 2.9, Monroe is 2.3 with a 3.5ast/g in 2012-13). Is he your best player on a championship team? Not sure yet, but he’s trending developmentally similar to Big Al (FG%, RB%, Ast% all very close to Al when he was 24) difference being touches (USG%), and FGA.

I think he would be a great 2nd best player on a contending team, and his FG% has hovered between 52%-48% which is squarely in Jefferson’s career FG%s, so give him Jeff Green or Avery’s level of shots and that’s an efficient 20pts with 5 or so FTs (FT% being another category he’s very good at as a big).

So yeah, when the alternative for any other passible Center, all with giant flaws in many offensive categories and maybe a jump from average defense to above average defense but their price tags are also in the 10+M dollar range? I take the 4M increase and have a reliable 2nd (possibly 1st) option for offense and try to turn 1 of our 5 PFs on the roster into a more athletic defensive shot blocker. And when you consider HOU basically gave away a player like Thomas Robinson for nothing at age 20 who was a lottery pick and would fill that role, it seems they are available and way cheaper than filling the 5.

Also, I'm not gonna call any player marginial who has a punchers chance at an All-NBA team honors. And Monroe full time at the center position with say 2-3 or more shots would be smack in that conversation… and he’s 24. Not forgetting that Bigs, particularly centers, historically take the longest time to reach full potential and develop, it would be crazy to not think he will improve further over the next 4 seasons.
Image
CelticFaninLBC
RealGM
Posts: 10,159
And1: 3,257
Joined: Aug 16, 2004

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#267 » by CelticFaninLBC » Thu Jul 31, 2014 3:29 pm

I wouldn't compare Monroe to Bosh. His numbers were kinda depressed playing with LeBron & Wade.. Gortat's a pretty good comparison...
User avatar
GreenMachine
Head Coach
Posts: 6,416
And1: 998
Joined: Jun 05, 2003

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#268 » by GreenMachine » Thu Jul 31, 2014 5:59 pm

KJandHondo35 wrote:
GreenMachine wrote:
KJandHondo35 wrote:^^^ Could also include any of the non-guaranteed contracts to get up to the max if necessary in Babb, Johnson, and Pressy.


But then we would be stuck paying a marginal player the max!

No no no no... The problem with all these Monroe ideas is... he simply isn't that good. He's not bad, but he's not an elite player, not even close. Paying him the max is something Dumars would do... and we have been making fun of him for years for paying marginal players way too much. There is a reason Monroe hasn't gotten that max offer from ANY team... he simply isn't worth it.

I guess we'll just agree to disagree…

Monroe can provide average post defense (many statistics have echoed this and I’ve posted them), and exceptional offensive production from the center position. So exceptional that in a down year last season (due to poor coaching and a crowded front court) Monroe still had the 5th best offensive/rebounding numbers in the NBA out of the 5 spot.

You compare his 16-10-3 to Gortat’s 13-10 or Bosh’s 16-6, he’s incredibly comparable if not better and he is 24 while those others are 30. He’s not a blocks guy (could improve however if playing the 5) but he’s very good in the Stls category and when you take stls + blocks he’s right there with those 2 “Max” or near “Max” centers. Gortat has 2.0 blks+Stls, Bosh has 2.1 and Monroe has 1.7 but the 2 previous seasons he had 2.0 blks+Stls…

He’s also one of the best post passers in the NBA, probably floating close to Marc Gasol level passing ability (Gasol Career average Ast/g is 2.9, Monroe is 2.3 with a 3.5ast/g in 2012-13). Is he your best player on a championship team? Not sure yet, but he’s trending developmentally similar to Big Al (FG%, RB%, Ast% all very close to Al when he was 24) difference being touches (USG%), and FGA.

I think he would be a great 2nd best player on a contending team, and his FG% has hovered between 52%-48% which is squarely in Jefferson’s career FG%s, so give him Jeff Green or Avery’s level of shots and that’s an efficient 20pts with 5 or so FTs (FT% being another category he’s very good at as a big).

So yeah, when the alternative for any other passible Center, all with giant flaws in many offensive categories and maybe a jump from average defense to above average defense but their price tags are also in the 10+M dollar range? I take the 4M increase and have a reliable 2nd (possibly 1st) option for offense and try to turn 1 of our 5 PFs on the roster into a more athletic defensive shot blocker. And when you consider HOU basically gave away a player like Thomas Robinson for nothing at age 20 who was a lottery pick and would fill that role, it seems they are available and way cheaper than filling the 5.

Also, I'm not gonna call any player marginial who has a punchers chance at an All-NBA team honors. And Monroe full time at the center position with say 2-3 or more shots would be smack in that conversation… and he’s 24. Not forgetting that Bigs, particularly centers, historically take the longest time to reach full potential and develop, it would be crazy to not think he will improve further over the next 4 seasons.


So please explain to me why Detroit... nor ANY other team is willing to give him the Mini-Max? Do you know something that EVERY GM in the game does not?
User avatar
KJandHondo35
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,829
And1: 1,259
Joined: Dec 18, 2013
     

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#269 » by KJandHondo35 » Thu Jul 31, 2014 6:11 pm

Prolly because DET already has a center that will demand a Max in like 2 seasons. As for other teams, I'm not 100% sure. OKC if they weren't the cheapest NBA team would be a great fit, but they only care about getting rookies to accept minimum wage to save them like 700K. And I also think teams are waiting for him to possibly just accept the QO and then take him when he's unrestricted next season, which could be an option for Boston, but that means he'll be more costly and BOS doesn't have the best history in luring FA so it’s a bit of a risk. Also, pretty sure this Love-Limbo is playing a role with any team thinking about pushing for a S&T for a restricted guy. They wanna see what everything looks like when the dust settles, there isn’t a rush.
Image
kbrow20
Pro Prospect
Posts: 818
And1: 40
Joined: Jul 12, 2014
       

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#270 » by kbrow20 » Thu Jul 31, 2014 7:02 pm

TruthBucket wrote:I really like Goran Dragic...I really do. In fact Phoenix has 2 PGs I covet more than Rondo. Sorry, but its true. But if we are looking to pluck a PG from Phoenix I think we would be better suited to go after Bledsoe.

There is a rift between Bledsoe and Phoenix right now so it may be doable. Also he is younger. As much as I really like Dragic and think he is still underrated. He is not as young as some might think. He will already be 29 by the time next season is over. For a rebuilding team like Boston, I just dont see Dragic as the answer. Maybe if we pulled off some more moves quickly to become relevant during his prime.

Then would it be solid start to do
Detroit get Rondo + Green
Suns get Monroe + Jennings
Boston get Bledsoe
RightToCensor wrote:Rubio is just too damn inefficient to be a team's primary option for offense. He needs to play in a system offense for you to get the best out of him. Trade him to New York, Dallas, or any other team that could use a poor-man's Rajon Rondo.
Really LOL
TruthBucket
Junior
Posts: 282
And1: 289
Joined: Jun 25, 2014
         

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#271 » by TruthBucket » Thu Jul 31, 2014 8:08 pm

kbrow20 wrote:
TruthBucket wrote:I really like Goran Dragic...I really do. In fact Phoenix has 2 PGs I covet more than Rondo. Sorry, but its true. But if we are looking to pluck a PG from Phoenix I think we would be better suited to go after Bledsoe.

There is a rift between Bledsoe and Phoenix right now so it may be doable. Also he is younger. As much as I really like Dragic and think he is still underrated. He is not as young as some might think. He will already be 29 by the time next season is over. For a rebuilding team like Boston, I just dont see Dragic as the answer. Maybe if we pulled off some more moves quickly to become relevant during his prime.

Then would it be solid start to do
Detroit get Rondo + Green
Suns get Monroe + Jennings
Boston get Bledsoe


I don't know. Thats such a clean trade and theres tons more minutia to work out in a trade. I'm higher on Green and lower on Rondo than most people. Not by a ton though. I don't think Rondo is infallible and I don't think Green is Hot Garbage. Player values are not as black and white as some people try to make it. Players need to compliment other players and it affects their value to that particular team.

I would swap Bledsoe for Rondo considering age and contract situations. I dont want to pay Rondo Max next year. But the 3 team deal complicates it. Some people would think of getting rid of green as a bonus for us in the trade and I dont exactly see it like that.

In summary - Im not a GM. I dont know.

Just curious. why are you worried about brokering a potential deal for 3 teams that are not your favorite team? Not picking on you or anything. Just wondering
User avatar
DK-All Day
General Manager
Posts: 9,746
And1: 8,458
Joined: Oct 12, 2013
     

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#272 » by DK-All Day » Thu Jul 31, 2014 8:25 pm

Noel for Smart?
Handsome.
kbrow20
Pro Prospect
Posts: 818
And1: 40
Joined: Jul 12, 2014
       

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#273 » by kbrow20 » Fri Aug 1, 2014 2:54 am

TruthBucket wrote:
kbrow20 wrote:
TruthBucket wrote:I really like Goran Dragic...I really do. In fact Phoenix has 2 PGs I covet more than Rondo. Sorry, but its true. But if we are looking to pluck a PG from Phoenix I think we would be better suited to go after Bledsoe.

There is a rift between Bledsoe and Phoenix right now so it may be doable. Also he is younger. As much as I really like Dragic and think he is still underrated. He is not as young as some might think. He will already be 29 by the time next season is over. For a rebuilding team like Boston, I just dont see Dragic as the answer. Maybe if we pulled off some more moves quickly to become relevant during his prime.

Then would it be solid start to do
Detroit get Rondo + Green
Suns get Monroe + Jennings
Boston get Bledsoe


I don't know. Thats such a clean trade and theres tons more minutia to work out in a trade. I'm higher on Green and lower on Rondo than most people. Not by a ton though. I don't think Rondo is infallible and I don't think Green is Hot Garbage. Player values are not as black and white as some people try to make it. Players need to compliment other players and it affects their value to that particular team.

I would swap Bledsoe for Rondo considering age and contract situations. I dont want to pay Rondo Max next year. But the 3 team deal complicates it. Some people would think of getting rid of green as a bonus for us in the trade and I dont exactly see it like that.

In summary - Im not a GM. I dont know.

Just curious. why are you worried about brokering a potential deal for 3 teams that are not your favorite team? Not picking on you or anything. Just wondering

Honestly I don't think Green is garbage either. I think he is the missing piece for Detroit. I also want these Bledsoe and Monroe things along with Love thing to finally be put to rest. I also want to make it hard for those Cav fans to make it out of the East and I think that Detroit would do that. You guys are the ones I wanted to land Love personally. I think this trade also benefits everyone's needs but I am sure you would receive a pick from Detroit for giving up two solid players. Bledsoe + Smart can work together as a PG SG combo. Based on what you guys said you would want Bledsoe but you have to much talent in your PG area. I think Smart and Bledsoe can play on the same court together but Rondo and Smart can't. So I think Bledsoe would allow Smart to get more minutes and allow him to grow more. Yes I am a passionate Mav fan but I also like to watch good basketball and I kinda want to see SVG to show some redemption for his Magic days and taking all the blame for Dwight Howard. Dwight basically made it sound like SVG is a bad coach. Like I said Detroit main needs are PG and SF, they have Drummond so why pay max for another Center. Suns have Dragic and Thomas at the back court, so they don't need a max PG but Jennings 8 Million might be reasonable for a shooting PG to back up Thomas. Monroe is a player they could use personally at a starting Center.
RightToCensor wrote:Rubio is just too damn inefficient to be a team's primary option for offense. He needs to play in a system offense for you to get the best out of him. Trade him to New York, Dallas, or any other team that could use a poor-man's Rajon Rondo.
Really LOL
User avatar
LarryBirdsFingr
RealGM
Posts: 12,377
And1: 18,684
Joined: Jan 27, 2012
     

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#274 » by LarryBirdsFingr » Fri Aug 1, 2014 3:00 am

You guys are literally smoking crack. Bledso is an injury prone player, and rondo for noel? Spare me. When does pre season start? Not soon enough apparently
I don't believe in statistics. There are too many factors that can't be measured. You can't measure a ballplayer's heart. -Red Auerbach

Marcus Smart is an underrated shooter
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
User avatar
GreenMachine
Head Coach
Posts: 6,416
And1: 998
Joined: Jun 05, 2003

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#275 » by GreenMachine » Fri Aug 1, 2014 4:58 am

LarryBirdsFingr wrote:You guys are literally smoking crack. Bledso is an injury prone player, and rondo for noel? Spare me. When does pre season start? Not soon enough apparently


Thank you! Smoking crack. All of them. Not just in this thread... all over the broad. CRACK IS WHACK KIDS! Stay off it.

According to this board Monroe is a future HOFer (but we could get him for Zeller and Young). Young has more value then Sully, Kelly or Smart (True story... I saw this posted today). I could go on and on... the stuff people post... makes me think I'm smoking crack! :banghead:
TruthBucket
Junior
Posts: 282
And1: 289
Joined: Jun 25, 2014
         

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#276 » by TruthBucket » Fri Aug 1, 2014 11:54 am

LarryBirdsFingr wrote:You guys are literally smoking crack. Bledso is an injury prone player, and rondo for noel? Spare me. When does pre season start? Not soon enough apparently


I cant find anyone saying Rondo for Noel. And if interest in Bledsoe means someone is literally smoking crack...then most league execs are probably LITERALLY smoking crack. So am I.
User avatar
KJandHondo35
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,829
And1: 1,259
Joined: Dec 18, 2013
     

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#277 » by KJandHondo35 » Fri Aug 1, 2014 12:19 pm

Image

Monroe's not in the HOF... yet. But 3rd team All NBA? :nod:
Image
KGboss
RealGM
Posts: 21,217
And1: 10,097
Joined: Mar 03, 2011
Location: Boston Garden
       

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#278 » by KGboss » Fri Aug 1, 2014 3:04 pm

TruthBucket wrote:
LarryBirdsFingr wrote:You guys are literally smoking crack. Bledso is an injury prone player, and rondo for noel? Spare me. When does pre season start? Not soon enough apparently


I cant find anyone saying Rondo for Noel. And if interest in Bledsoe means someone is literally smoking crack. Then most league execs are probably LITERALLY smoking crack. So am I.


WELL....

Now that it's brought up.

You trade Rondo for Noel, you get a significant big man who will be a force in the league, give Smart minutes from the jump and allow him to take over. Smart/Bradley/Green/Sullinger/Noel is a good starting line up.

But of course this isnt a video game and Philly I dont think makes that trade with MCW just coming off a ROY nod - however flawed that was.
CelticFaninLBC
RealGM
Posts: 10,159
And1: 3,257
Joined: Aug 16, 2004

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#279 » by CelticFaninLBC » Fri Aug 1, 2014 4:37 pm

TruthBucket wrote:
LarryBirdsFingr wrote:You guys are literally smoking crack. Bledso is an injury prone player, and rondo for noel? Spare me. When does pre season start? Not soon enough apparently


I cant find anyone saying Rondo for Noel. And if interest in Bledsoe means someone is literally smoking crack. Then most league execs are probably LITERALLY smoking crack. So am I.


Yeah, I don't see any proposed Rondo for Noel trades, which would make no sense for a tanking Philly team anyways. I did see someone mention Noel for Smart. I'd like to see Noel actually play first, and also Philly already has MWC..
User avatar
Bohemian
Analyst
Posts: 3,503
And1: 3,364
Joined: Jul 24, 2012
         

Re: Trade Ideas Thread 

Post#280 » by Bohemian » Fri Aug 1, 2014 6:40 pm

[tweet]https://twitter.com/MichaelVPina/status/494538315521986560[/tweet]

Return to Boston Celtics