big-shot-ROB wrote:Homerclease wrote:big-shot-ROB wrote:
I'd say we need cheap, veteran cost controlled assets. If we lose Semi, Kanter, Wannamaker and replace them with 3 langfords or more raw prospects, the season is going to be rough.
Getting cheap veterans won't be easy as we've seen this season, with all choosing to go to the likes of the LA teams, Bucks, etc. So I wouldn't mind using a couple of first rounders on sophomores and juniors ready to contribute despite having a potential lower ceiling than other prospects.
If our title hopes rest on guys like Semi, Kanter and Wanamaker then we aren’t anywhere close to a title. Semi was barely in the rotation as is, Wanamaker is extremely replaceable and they can use the MLE to replace Kanter along with internal growth from Williams x2 and even Fall. I was ready to move on from Wanamaker to Waters last year. Absolutely no problem doing it this year.
I don’t mind the picks and prospects because I view this teams window as still a year or two away when Tatum and Brown reach their primes. Hopefully come that time, Hayward and Kemba still have some left in the tank and the youth that the Celtics have develop into productive players or develop enough trade value to add a missing piece.
I'm not going to talk about Fall because I think I have quite a bad opinion of him in terms of ever contributing anything in a playoff atmosphere.
Water falls in the rookie phenomenon: meaning it was amazing when he did good but its flaws were ignored or at least softened by the fact he was a rookie. It happened the same with Tatum and basically all new players in the league.
I just feel like Wannamaker, Kanter, Semi + two veterans are enough for playoff runs. Specially Semi. This will be his 4th year on the league and he knows the system. There's plenty of worse guys that could take the 10th spot.
You're telling me that something like Wannamaker + Reddick + Semi + Marvin Williams + Baynes/Kanter is not a playoff bench? The Warriors basically won 3 chips with no players better than this ones on their bench. I just don't understand what'd you want out of our bench? Lou Will?
We have plenty of powerhouse in our starting unit, we don't need and can't afford anymore than suggested.
Personally, I just don't think there aren't any prospects worth spending a 1st rounder that are going to be high contributors in 2 years time when our players hit their ceiling as a unit. That's why I am embracing to at least trade 2 out of the 3 to get veteran help.
That’s fine with your take on Fall, he’s a long shot absolutely but the coaching staff and front office have seemed to deem it worthy to take a flier on him. I think he can handle the Poirier towel waver emergency big role just fine.
Waters should get better in years two, three and four which is why I want him to stick around. Personally I think he’s equal to, if not better than Wanamaker as it stands right now, Nevermind 2-3 years down the line which is what the team should be building toward IMO.
They have enough for playoff runs now, but likely second round or ECF exits. I’m not anywhere near as high on our current vets as you. Kanter showed well for himself in the postseason with Portland, would like to see if that’s a fluke or not. He’s a lesser Greg Monroe to me, who was pretty damn good here in his first stint and totally unplayable in the postseason. Semi is barely worthy of holding a spot on an NBA roster much less being in a playoff rotation. The sooner he’s gone the better. I suppose they have the MLE to sign a vet, any other one is coming at the vet minimum and I’m not sure there’s someone out there that caliber that I’d want over the young guys they currently have.
Reddick and Marvin Williams would be nice, they are short term answers though for a team that’s not quite ready to compete at the highest level. The other guys shouldn’t be in playoff rotation at all IMO. The difference between this team and a team like the Warriors is their top end talent was far superior at this juncture than the Celtics. Tatums Star is on the rise, but to compare him to Curry at this point is a disservice. Throw in Klay, Green, Iggy and at the time Barnes and you see where I’m going. The team needs Tatum and Brown to keep getting better while Kemba and Hayward maintain their current level for at least another 3 years.
Agreed we are fine with the starting 5. I’m looking for role players and raw guys with super high ceilings. A few examples would be a 3 point specialist like a Vassell or an athletic freak like Patrick Williams.
I think trading picks for vets is premature at this point, we aren’t quite in a position to go all in for a short term move like that yet. Keep building the roster as a whole and hope to strike gold with a guy who can either help push you over the top or shows enough promise to trade for someone to push you over the top.
Right now, without signing anyone my bench next year would be Robert Williams, Grant Williams, Romeo Langford, Marcus Smart and Tremont Waters. I’m all for throwing the MLE at Harry Giles and if the team comes out of the draft with Vassell, Patrick Williams and another PG to round out the roster I’d be quite pleased