azee2890 wrote:sam_I_am wrote:Jaqua92 wrote:Against an 11-19 team. Simmons is an all star already and Embiid was an MVP candidate.
Tatum and Brown aren't yet ready to be the foundation pieces of a contender. Kemba and Hayward are still our best two players. Until these two guys surpass both of them, I'm not ready to say they are the foundation of this team's success yet.
Sent from my SM-G975U using Tapatalk
Those guys are both on max deals and are older and they made their bones beating up weaker teams too. Baby steps...it’s all I’m saying. Jaylen and Jayson were featured players that beat Simmons and Embiid in 5 games 2 years ago when it mattered most and Tatum was highest scorer .....let’s not forget that.
Also keep in mind that the Celtics FO never invested their future plans into JT and JB nearly as much as the Sixers did with BS and Embiid. If they were given this type of autonomy to develop during year 1 and year 2, they could be much further along in their career paths. Instead, they brought in Hayward and Irving and immediately stifled their development. That's the problem with star chasing instead of "trusting the process". Ainge always saw JT and JB as AD bait. He's only recently been forced to trust them to be the foundation and they have shown huge promise.
Kind of difficult to compare career trajectories directly like that. Embiid and Simmons were more polished and highly touted products than Tatum and Brown coming into their drafts, and they were sidelined for their first 1-2 years while given the opportunity to practice with their team before they got to take the reins. It's true that we had too many cooks in the kitchen last year and didn't give Tatum and Brown enough opportunities to stand out. It's also true that they came into the league very young and unpolished, they got a lot of opportunities to play basketball on playoff teams from the get go, the FO never gave up on them and traded them even when they had the opportunity to rent MVP-level talent and make a run at a championship, and they are both coming along nicely and playing well right now. I'm not saying there isn't a counterfactual where they're both playing better right now, especially considering last season when we didn't necessarily see all the immediate progress we were hoping for, but overall I mainly just feel like Embiid and Simmons were more ready for NBA basketball right out of the gate.
And even then, I'm not sure Simmons is a great example of a player being lifted to greatness by early experience, considering he seems to be stalling in development this season similar to how Jaylen stalled last season. I think he will eventually address those weaknesses and become a great player, but he still needs some time too.
Sent from my Pixel 3 using
RealGM mobile app