ImageImageImage

NBA Reform Ideas (Sept. 2019) -- What Ideas do you have going forward?

Moderators: Froob, ParticleMan, sully00, The Comedian, Parliament10, canman1971, djFan71

User avatar
Parliament10
Forum Mod - Celtics
Forum Mod - Celtics
Posts: 23,849
And1: 22,452
Joined: Jul 24, 2009
       

NBA Reform Ideas (Sept. 2019) -- What Ideas do you have going forward? 

Post#1 » by Parliament10 » Tue Sep 10, 2019 8:54 pm

NBA Reform
* Expand the NBA Preseason to 1 month.
* Extend the NBA Regular Season to End in July.
* Push Summer League to early August.
* Eliminate Back-to-Backs.
* Have 15 All-Stars per Conference. 3 Defensive players, specifically.
* Increase the ratio of out of Conference Games.

* NBA Playoffs – Top 16 Teams compete, irregardless of Conference.
* NBA Playoffs – Re-seeding each Round.
* Coach's Challenge: Call a Timeout. If upheld, team keeps said Challenge(s). (2 initially/game. Expandable to 4.)
* NBA Draft Age: Change back to Age: 18. Allow G-League to Start at Age: 16.
* Expand the League to at least 32 teams.
* Shorten the number of Regular Season Games Players to between 70-76.
* Create a best-of-1 Tournament, to be held during All-Star Break.
* Clamp down on Flopping by issuing Techs, for Excessive Offenders.


Referees
* 90 sec (on-court) Referee Replay Review.
* Allow up to 6 Referees. With at least one specifically on the Replay. And one In-Training, up from the G-League.
* Allow Rules to be Reviewed by a NBPA Committee. (Like Shooter initiated Fouls.)


G-League Reform
* Add a 3rd Round (and poss. 4th) to the NBA Draft, specifically for Drafting Two-Players.
* Allow up to (5) Two-Way Players, and increase time to 60-NBA days.
* As Injury Replacements, allow Two-Players to play in the NBA Playoffs.
* Let the 5 Affiliates Practice with the NBA Team, throughout the season. (Like in the NFL.)
* Allow 15 Players on a D-League team.
* Increase G-League pay to be Commensurate with Overseas, and a Percentage of NBA Salaries.
* Increase & Allow Affiliate Pay. Ie.: If you're partially paid a $300,000, then you can still be a G-League Affiliate.
* Extend the NBA Players Union and Benefits, to include G-League members.


Continue to Review:
* Tanking
* Hack-A-Player
* Draft & Draft Lottery
* Make Replay more efficient.
* Widen the NBA Court, to at least 3-6 ft, in width and length.
* Find a mechanism to Fix the NBA Disparity between East & West.
* Redefine Offensive Fouls -- ie. Jumping into Defender on a shot (to get the foul) is an offensive foul.
* The NBAPA should be determining which rules are fair or not.
_____________________________________________________


I revised some Ideas from other people, going back 5 years.
Though, here are some quotes of really Novel Ideas.

King Of The 4th wrote:From a pure entertainment perspective, I'd love to see a single-elimination tournament of the bottom 14 teams to determine who gets the #1 pick in the draft. Maybe even #2 goes to the runner-up? Don't think it would help tanking but at the very least it would give bottom teams a reason to stay somewhat competitive.

jcappy wrote:72 game season: Play west teams twice and conference opponents three times. No back-to-backs. And yes a longer pre-season.

widen the court by 3 feet and push back the 3 point line by a foot.

4 refs. and clarify at least a bit charging/blocking.

threrf23 wrote:Reformulate the supermax. Better yet scrap the super max, and replace it with super bird rights. The contract of any player signed with super bird rights does not count, or maybe half counts, towards the cap. This way, retaining players long term does not prevent a team from signing free agents.

LondonCeltics wrote:Clamp down on flopping by issuing techs for it like in soccer where obvious ‘simulation’ gets you a yellow card.

Revisit the interpretation surrounding what a foul is to allow the game to be a contact sport like it once was.

LuckyLeprechaun wrote:* Flex scheduling for national games starting in January of the season (the way the NFL does with Sunday night football). This will allow the NBA to not have to broadcast teams that are no longer interesting do to trades or injuries that have occurred and will also allow the NBA to:

* Remove the fines for resting healthy players....

* Any time a team has a back to back, their opponent must also have a back to back and both teams must be traveling during this exchange. This will eliminate "schedule losses" without having to completely eliminate back to backs outright.

* Dial back the league rules about what players are and aren't allowed to say. These bad leaks and unsubstantiated rumors are direct result of players getting fined for speaking their minds. There can still be some rules, but players saying there are certain teams they would like to play for does not warrant a fine IMO.

* Allow the public to see a record of the league office's after-the-fact reviews of all referee calls made so that fans and the media can see clearly what the league thinks is and isn't a call. Pretending like referees are not human and don't make mistakes is a worse look than simply admitting that they are IMO.

Curmudgeon wrote:IMHO the new WNBA idea to determine draft order based on the results of the last two seasons has merit. Maybe that should be extended to three seasons.

It would certainly eliminate the one season tank to pick up a dominant player (think 1996-97 Spurs). It's not perfect, but IMHO it's a step in the right direction.
“We’re building a culture of accountability, trust, and togetherness. Entitlement will not be tolerated”
– Brad Stevens
User avatar
OldCeltics
Starter
Posts: 2,236
And1: 2,100
Joined: Jul 05, 2012
   

Re: NBA Reform Ideas (Sept. 2019) -- What Ideas do you have going forward? 

Post#2 » by OldCeltics » Tue Sep 10, 2019 9:48 pm

Stop super teams, and return parity to league. Only 1 or 2 stars per team.

Right now players and their agents decide who they want to play with and what team. Teams have no control of their futures.

1. Demanding trades and demanding where they have to be traded to, otherwise they wont resign.

2. Forming of super teams like Lebron planning to form a super team with Wade/Bosh during Olympics. Miami got lucky, but it could have been Knicks or Chicago.

3. Only 3-4 teams have any chance to win the finals.

Celtics have been lucky to get some talent, but most teams are permanently in the dump. If those teams didn't exist in the NBA it would make no difference.
Fencer reregistered
RealGM
Posts: 19,094
And1: 6,820
Joined: Oct 25, 2006

Re: NBA Reform Ideas (Sept. 2019) -- What Ideas do you have going forward? 

Post#3 » by Fencer reregistered » Tue Sep 10, 2019 10:40 pm

I have two thoughts that unfortunately conflict with each other:

1. Put the whole league in the playoffs, and make the playoffs be double-elimination. That means the champion has to win 5 rounds if they sweep or 6 rounds if they took a loss, vs. the current 4, and minus one if they got a tip-top seeding and had a bye. Accommodate the extra games by shortening some of the series, shortening the season (58 games is an obvious target), or both.

2. Make seedings more valuable by letting teams choose their opponents each round, highest-seeded teams choosing first.


The conflict between these ideas is that if you have #1 and DON'T have #2, then everybody has at least some disincentive to tank. But if you have both ideas in place, tanking once again has no postseason downside.
100proof
Ballboy
Posts: 39
And1: 18
Joined: Jul 25, 2019
 

Re: NBA Reform Ideas (Sept. 2019) -- What Ideas do you have going forward? 

Post#4 » by 100proof » Wed Sep 11, 2019 4:29 pm

Parliament10 wrote:NBA Reform
* Expand the NBA Preseason to 1 month. - Too long, already have alot of rest games. Would rather see a shorter season with gleague season not at the same time. so no overlap yet more basketball.
* Extend the NBA Regular Season to End in July. - see above
* Push Summer League to early August. - see above
* Eliminate Back-to-Backs. ok with back to back, just eliminate home and home back to backs.
* Have 15 All-Stars per Conference. 3 Defensive players, specifically. - cool, would add that winning conference gets home court advantage in finals.
* Increase the ratio of out of Conference Games. like

* NBA Playoffs – Top 16 Teams compete, irregardless of Conference. perfect
* NBA Playoffs – Re-seeding each Round. naw, seems like that could get complicated
* Coach's Challenge: Call a Timeout. If upheld, team keeps said Challenge(s). (2 initially/game. Expandable to 4.)
* NBA Draft Age: Change back to Age: 18. Allow G-League to Start at Age: 16.
* Expand the League to at least 32 teams.
* Shorten the number of Regular Season Games Players to between 70-76.
* Create a best-of-1 Tournament, to be held during All-Star Break.
* Clamp down on Flopping by issuing Techs, for Excessive Offenders. poor marcus would never get to play


Referees
* 90 sec (on-court) Referee Replay Review. - yes
* Allow up to 6 Referees. With at least one specifically on the Replay. And one In-Training, up from the G-League. - yes
* Allow Rules to be Reviewed by a NBPA Committee. (Like Shooter initiated Fouls.) - yes


G-League Reform
* Add a 3rd Round (and poss. 4th) to the NBA Draft, specifically for Drafting Two-Players.
* Allow up to (5) Two-Way Players, and increase time to 60-NBA days.
* As Injury Replacements, allow Two-Players to play in the NBA Playoffs.
* Let the 5 Affiliates Practice with the NBA Team, throughout the season. (Like in the NFL.)
* Allow 15 Players on a D-League team.
* Increase G-League pay to be Commensurate with Overseas, and a Percentage of NBA Salaries.
* Increase & Allow Affiliate Pay. Ie.: If you're partially paid a $300,000, then you can still be a G-League Affiliate.
* Extend the NBA Players Union and Benefits, to include G-League members.


Continue to Review:
* Tanking
* Hack-A-Player
* Draft & Draft Lottery
* Make Replay more efficient.
* Widen the NBA Court, to at least 3-6 ft, in width and length.
* Find a mechanism to Fix the NBA Disparity between East & West.
* Redefine Offensive Fouls -- ie. Jumping into Defender on a shot (to get the foul) is an offensive foul.
* The NBAPA should be determining which rules are fair or not.
_____________________________________________________


I revised some Ideas from other people, going back 5 years.
Though, here are some quotes of really Novel Ideas.

King Of The 4th wrote:From a pure entertainment perspective, I'd love to see a single-elimination tournament of the bottom 14 teams to determine who gets the #1 pick in the draft. Maybe even #2 goes to the runner-up? Don't think it would help tanking but at the very least it would give bottom teams a reason to stay somewhat competitive.

jcappy wrote:72 game season: Play west teams twice and conference opponents three times. No back-to-backs. And yes a longer pre-season.

widen the court by 3 feet and push back the 3 point line by a foot.

4 refs. and clarify at least a bit charging/blocking.

threrf23 wrote:Reformulate the supermax. Better yet scrap the super max, and replace it with super bird rights. The contract of any player signed with super bird rights does not count, or maybe half counts, towards the cap. This way, retaining players long term does not prevent a team from signing free agents.

LondonCeltics wrote:Clamp down on flopping by issuing techs for it like in soccer where obvious ‘simulation’ gets you a yellow card.

Revisit the interpretation surrounding what a foul is to allow the game to be a contact sport like it once was.

LuckyLeprechaun wrote:* Flex scheduling for national games starting in January of the season (the way the NFL does with Sunday night football). This will allow the NBA to not have to broadcast teams that are no longer interesting do to trades or injuries that have occurred and will also allow the NBA to:

* Remove the fines for resting healthy players....

* Any time a team has a back to back, their opponent must also have a back to back and both teams must be traveling during this exchange. This will eliminate "schedule losses" without having to completely eliminate back to backs outright.

* Dial back the league rules about what players are and aren't allowed to say. These bad leaks and unsubstantiated rumors are direct result of players getting fined for speaking their minds. There can still be some rules, but players saying there are certain teams they would like to play for does not warrant a fine IMO.

* Allow the public to see a record of the league office's after-the-fact reviews of all referee calls made so that fans and the media can see clearly what the league thinks is and isn't a call. Pretending like referees are not human and don't make mistakes is a worse look than simply admitting that they are IMO.

Curmudgeon wrote:IMHO the new WNBA idea to determine draft order based on the results of the last two seasons has merit. Maybe that should be extended to three seasons.

It would certainly eliminate the one season tank to pick up a dominant player (think 1996-97 Spurs). It's not perfect, but IMHO it's a step in the right direction.



I added a few of notes in your post, I would like to see some serious reviewing of travelling rules and I would like to see some physicality brought back into the game.

I miss postups, I miss hard boxouts, I miss handchecks - well sometimes.
captain green
Veteran
Posts: 2,599
And1: 1,022
Joined: Mar 04, 2009
Contact:
         

Re: NBA Reform Ideas (Sept. 2019) -- What Ideas do you have going forward? 

Post#5 » by captain green » Wed Sep 11, 2019 9:10 pm

Interesting ideas but one I'm not for is the top16 teams make playoffs. I like conference's and other wise banners would mean nothing. The east vs the west forever. One I liked best was expanding teams to 32. And another one was heavier review of flopping. I'll add my idea that I haven't read.(or missed possibly ) fine agent's heavily for leaks and manipulation.fining a team and player does nothing but fine those agents and watch that **** clean up real quick.
We always talk about there’s A-to-Z… really, there’s A-to-G or -E,’” Ainge told Celtics.com of a team’s typical offseason agenda. “This year, there’s definitely A-to-Z.” : danny ainge
Banks2Pierce
RealGM
Posts: 15,651
And1: 5,107
Joined: Feb 23, 2004
   

Re: NBA Reform Ideas (Sept. 2019) -- What Ideas do you have going forward? 

Post#6 » by Banks2Pierce » Fri Sep 13, 2019 2:15 pm

Get rid of divisions and just play the teams in your conference 3 times. Other conference twice for 72 games. No more b2bs. 16 teams seeded by record.

32 team tournament with an invitation to 2 European teams, depending on their enthusiasm. Their qualification criteria are up to them(winning Euroleague, eurocup, etc.) If you are drawn with them, you play at MSG. Every tournament game is aired on television. Can make a big deal out of the draw as well. Re-draw every round. Clear a full week in January to do the first 2 rounds and then do the rest over Feb-April on random weeks.

Stop fast break fouling with an actual rule against intentional fouling. It is not that hard to read intent on this.

Guys that foul out get another foul if a game goes to OT and another foul per OT.

Return to Boston Celtics