Post#4 » by Jammer » Sat Oct 4, 2008 1:16 am
Posey had a phenomenal year shooting the 3, and could somewhat defend LeBron.
In terms of NET PER, Tony was better last year.
Let's look at 3 categories,
defensive PER (what the man you are guarding is doing),
offensive PER (what you're doing),
NET PER (the difference between the two).
The results from last season may surprise:
2008 Celtic Defensive PER (what the man they were guarding was doing over season)
Note (the lower the number, the better a DEFENDER you are)
11.2 Tony Allen (arguably team's best defender)
12.1 Paul Pierce
12.1 Gabe Pruitt
12.7 Kevin Garnett
12.7 Ray Allen
13.3 Eddie House
13.8 Brian Scalabrine
15.8 Glen Davis
16.3 Rajon Rondo
16.5 Kendrick Perkins
16.8 James Posey
17.6 PJ Brown
19.0 Sam Cassell
19.6 Leon Powe
22.6 Scot Pollard (worst defender)
Now, let's look at offensive PER's from last year, where the higher the number the better:
28.7 Kevin Garnett (9.2 rpg explains why his PER is highest)
23.6 Leon Powe
22.4 Paul Pierce
18.5 Ray Allen
17.7 Rajon Rondo (surprise, but the kid took 9.3 shots per game, I wish he took 7)
14.9 Kendrick Perkins (another surprise)
14.9 Eddie House
13.9 James Posey
12.9 Sam Cassell
12.8 Glen Davis
11.6 PJ Brown
09.9 Gabe Pruitt
09.8 Scot Pollard
06.0 Brian Scalabrine (how'd he get a 5 year, $15 million contract??? - One Good playoff series)
Now, the most important, NET PER, the difference between the above numbers,
where Tony Allen will comfortably be higher than James Posey.
(note higher numbers are better)
16.0 Kevin Garnett
10.2 Paul Pierce
05.9 Ray Allen
04.0 Leon Powe
01.6 Eddie House (surprise, he's only on the floor when he can succeed)
01.5 Tony Allen
01.4 Rajon Rondo
-1.6 Kendrick Perkins
-2.2 Gabe Pruitt (surprise)
-3.0 James Posey
-3.0 Glen Davis
-6.0 PJ Brown
-6.1 Sam Cassell
-7.8 Brian Scalabrine
-12.8 Scot Pollard
So, if you go by NET PER, the top 8 players on last year's team were:
Kevin, Paul, Ray, Rajon, Kendrick, Tony, Eddie and Leon.
Obviously James filled an important role as a mobile power forward,
just as PJ served as the low post defender late in the season.
But when Kendrick is healthy, he can perform that function.
So, I kind of agree that Tony is better, but Tony is more suited to defending guards,
we still have to see how he handles the larger SF's
(unless Ray moves over,
or Darius ends up being the 5th man on the floor late in games when the team wants to go mobile).
Who the 5th man will be, Darius or Tony, is still to be determined (on nights they don't want a banger like Kendrick).