RealGM

Let's assume the Celtics go to training camp with TA, Giddens and Walker. TA may get the seniority nod but Walker was solid in limited minutes last year and JR played well in the summer league. It's definitely a close call so, in punting away logical basketball theory, the only way to choose is by making them fight, who wins? I'm going with TA...

Discuss.

TA wins the fight, but I don't know who makes the team.

T.A. Walker Giddens, in that order.

Edit: Unless Tony accidentally punches himself unconscious in the face after the bell rings...

Young Bill Walker likes to scrap, give him my vote.

Unless there are weapons involved, then it's TA all day.

T.A wins the fight easily, but hopefully JR makes the team.

Bill Walker wins the fight.. and i hope, the active spot

he has the most potential, and the best garbage minute dunking potential lol

Walker. He's a tough SOB.

Well TA calls his posse in and then Walker and Giddons have no chance.

TA wins the fight but loses the war... he'll get showcased and then traded.

Bill Walker would **** TA's **** up! J.R got that long reach, and he is quick hell..but Walker would beat him too..lol

Scalamental wrote:T.A. Walker Giddens, in that order.

Edit: Unless Tony accidentally punches himself unconscious in the face after the bell rings...

Given Tony's mental abilities, this is entirely possible...in fact, I'd say it's likely!

I'm with Mahoney on this one, TA gets showcased and moved at the trade deadline (if he can stay healthy enough to get a return on).

andy582 wrote:TA wins the fight, but I don't know who makes the team.

This.

I prefer Walker out of them three.

Why do majority have TA winning the fight?