Kaline or Clemente?

[countryboy667]

For anyone, but especially those old enough to have seen them, objectively speaking who do you think was better?

[john4psu]

Kaline had more power, Clemente hit for a higher average, was better defensively and had a better arm (and Kaline had a very good arm) but it wasn't Clemente's. Clemente had 266 assists in 18 seasons, Kaline 170 in 22 seasons.