RealGM

Which SP would you rather have?

Wow nobody answered that one...

I came in but couldn't choose between the two because I've seen Billingsley pitch only one time. But after watching Cain again the other day I'm still convinced that he's one hell of a pitcher with great stuff and size.

So, I'd go with Cain.

.
Cain, He has "no hitter" type stuff and potential, A strong inning eating dependable arm, and at 22 yrs old, surprising pitching moxie. Too bad the Giants have not done well when he's pitched. He deserves much better.