Who wins in this deal?

[pugilistfan]

David Ortiz
Jason Bay
Erik Bedard
Joe Blanton

OR

Bobby Abreu
Troy Glaus
Matt Cain
Dustin McGowan
CJ Wilson

How serious is Bedards injury? And is this slump Ortiz in worrisome or just a minor setback?

[wigglestrue]

David Ortiz
Jason Bay
Erik Bedard
Joe Blanton

OR

Bobby Abreu
Troy Glaus
Matt Cain
Dustin McGowan
CJ Wilson

How serious is Bedards injury? And is this slump Ortiz in worrisome or just a minor setback?

Tough call.

Cain and CJ Wilson are deceptively valuable. If it's Bedard who has a degenerative hip condition (as opposed to Adam Jones as it was rumored) then I'd have to say the second group is better.