Fair trade in keeper or no?
Posted: Mon Mar 28, 2011 8:47 pm
10 man h2h keeper league (first year), normal cats but OBP and complete games are included.
I get Troy Tulo
I give up Rollins and Bumgarner
I feel that in a one year league, the trade obviously favors myself getting Tulo. I feel that this trade is extremely fair in a keeper league, especially since i got rollins in the 5th round, costing only a 3rd rounder to keep if he does well and i got bum at around 14 i believe, costing an 11th rounder next year to keep.
The league has vetoed it which has myself and my trading partner very upset. I normally do not complain about vetoed trades, but i wholeheartedly believe this trade to be fair in a KEEPER league (which they seem to not understand). I've even been asked to give up kyle drabek, who i got in the
21st round or Wainwright who i got in the 19th round in addition to bum and rollins.
This veto really does not sit well with me, again, cause i believe the deal to be fair. Would like some opinions on the deal from non-biased fantasy baseball fans. Thank you
EDIT: Would ANYONE like to view AND comment?
I get Troy Tulo
I give up Rollins and Bumgarner
I feel that in a one year league, the trade obviously favors myself getting Tulo. I feel that this trade is extremely fair in a keeper league, especially since i got rollins in the 5th round, costing only a 3rd rounder to keep if he does well and i got bum at around 14 i believe, costing an 11th rounder next year to keep.
The league has vetoed it which has myself and my trading partner very upset. I normally do not complain about vetoed trades, but i wholeheartedly believe this trade to be fair in a KEEPER league (which they seem to not understand). I've even been asked to give up kyle drabek, who i got in the
21st round or Wainwright who i got in the 19th round in addition to bum and rollins.
This veto really does not sit well with me, again, cause i believe the deal to be fair. Would like some opinions on the deal from non-biased fantasy baseball fans. Thank you
EDIT: Would ANYONE like to view AND comment?