RealGM

reyes/kent 4 magg/young/utley???

deal or no deal

I would get the three...

it would help if you posted your team, but going off of this info, i personally would not pull the trigger. Granted, Utley is great and at a position where getting good production from is hard, but reyes will only get better. He single-handedly wins you stolen bases, scores alot of runs, and has above average power, which leads to a good source of rbi's as well. Im not too high on Kent however, and i think you should trade him, but again, without knowing your team, it's hard to say what i would go for. Also, im going to assume that the Young in question, is Michael Young. He would be a nice replacement if you were to pull the trigger. I think this trade is fair, but personally, i would reject cause i never trade for more players than i give up, and also, in trading reyes, i expect to get back a first and second rounder while i give up a scrub.

Yes, do it. That trade gives you more power and average as well. You will be losing SB but gain an advantage in HR, RBIs, Runs and Average.


Btw, lol Rocketfan

Guys, how about this trade?


Johnson/Young/Jones for Ramirez/Ortiz/Smith


Who wins?

yanksknicks101 wrote:it would help if you posted your team, but going off of this info, i personally would not pull the trigger. Granted, Utley is great and at a position where getting good production from is hard, but reyes will only get better. He single-handedly wins you stolen bases, scores alot of runs, and has above average power, which leads to a good source of rbi's as well. Im not too high on Kent however, and i think you should trade him, but again, without knowing your team, it's hard to say what i would go for. Also, im going to assume that the Young in question, is Michael Young. He would be a nice replacement if you were to pull the trigger. I think this trade is fair, but personally, i would reject cause i never trade for more players than i give up, and also, in trading reyes, i expect to get back a first and second rounder while i give up a scrub.

loduca
helton
kent
A. ramirez
reyes
c. lee
pierre
rowand
jeter
d. de jesus
L. gonzo
p. feliz
ty
c. ruis
piazza


thanks for the input yanks

Basketball Jesus wrote:Guys, how about this trade?


Johnson/Young/Jones for Ramirez/Ortiz/Smith


Who wins?

Which Young are you referring to, TC?