RealGM

I'm the one getting Pena.

The cats - R, K, HR, SB, AVE, RBI, OPS

My team:
Magglio Ord

1. Which Pena: Carlos or Tony?
2. No

Ill assume this is Carlos Pena. so i say no since u have Adri

Keep Hart. You already have two first basemen and Pena has a high chance of regressing simply based upon his previous history. He exploded out of no where last season and while he has made improvements in his game, I would be a little weary trading for him. Not to mention that Hart will give you a fine OPS as well as SBs from the OF. Your OF is going to net you a lot of SBs and each hit like 20 HRs a piece. I'd personally start Magglio as your UTL with Gonzo at 1st. The trade-off may net you something in return but you would have two aging/collapse risks in your line-up with Magglio and Pena. If you get their 2007 seasons, you could be on easy street. But if they don't, you better pray your pitching staff is phenomenal. mahalo
~Chach~

Yea its Carlos Pena sorry. The only reason why I am considering it is because from what I have seen C. Pena is ranked really high. It makes no sense to have 3 1st basemen, but I figured I could always move Justin.

I'll probably just pass.


Thanks.

Unless u can get a top tier SS for Justin i def would pass on this deal

I wouldn't do it because Pena won't hit another 46 HRs. At most he will hit 30. Hart should do the same (around) but also get you SBs and a nice average.

You do have Granderson and Sizemore who are already very similar to Hart so that's one reason to do the trade. But Pena only has one good year under his belt and you have solid first basemen already. Plus 1B is always a deep position.

I'd pass.