Grubie024 wrote:Duffman100 wrote:Grubie024 wrote:
I think we view the definition of freedom of speech a little differently, that's the disconnect. Yours aligns with the dictionary definition. You're saying he's able to say what he wants - yes his tongue wasn't plucked out and he wasn't imprisoned before he could say another word.
I'm saying he's not really that free because the price he's paying (future money and opportunities are greatly diminished and he's being publicly destroyed).
It really just boils down to the fact that I don't agree with him being destroyed for sharing a documentary. The contents of it seem pretty bad but this is highly subjective stuff. I think people need to chill out and be more forgiving.
So you're saying that people should have the freedom to say whatever they want but suffer no potential societal consequences for what they say?
I basically addressed that with the final paragraph of my post. No, I don't think it should be a free for all but I think the threshold for outrage and wanting to destroy someone's life is a little low. I believe in freedom of speech more than most I guess. I'm not anti-semitic and I don't promote the documentary.
Kyrie is an adult. He's thirty years old. We have a rising tide of antiSemitic behavior in this country, the world, which includes violence (as well as a rising violence against other marginalized groups). Kyrie chose to promote, because yes linking to something that is hateful without condemning it as hateful is promotion, an antiSemitic book and film to millions of people. No one forced him to do this at all. He chose to do it himself. He made a conscious decision to post hateful content out there, giving antiSemites in the world fire to use to back their beliefs and justifications. He made that choice to risk his own money with that decision.
If you are worried about his life 'being destroyed' because he made that decision, maybe also worry about the Jewish people who are going to get hurt - whether harassed or physically hurt - by his promotion. And how that impacts their lives.