UcanUwill wrote:It is really strange how many of these players and fans truly think Kobe is GOAT. Maybe some are being cute, but some really believe that. And I get it, and while Kobe was all timer, he was bigger personality than player himself, but in my opinion, I am not even sure there was a single year where Kobe was best player in the world during his time, let alone all time. We can argue 05 07 those were Kobe years, but I do not think it is definite at all, he coexisted wish Shaq, Duncan and LeBron.
Kobe never led the NBA in any all-around statistic, such as PER, VORP, or Win Shares. (During the years that you mentioned LeBron, Dirk, and Garnett shared the leadership of those statistics.) Kobe-stans can say hey, those are stupid stats, but since Mike and LeBron dominated those stupid stats year after year after year, that's a pretty weak argument. If those statistics are so useless, why did Mike and LeBron crush them?
The argument for Kobe is based on ring counting, flash, and personality. I mean, of course he was a great player, but when ranking the all-time greats those are the factors that push him up.


























