JohnnyKILLroy wrote:I was and will always be anti-Fields.
Not mentioned really Fields used to scramble to pick up 1st downs and more - he was looking to run because he got tunnel vision and can’t find guys open. Fields made our rushing attack look better than it was.
Caleb scrambles to find guys open which long term will be better for him as a QB but that’s going to come with a lot of growing pains apparently.
I will always be pro-Fields.
While I agree with your assessment at a high level, I think it ignores a lot of the details that lead up the discussion in the first place.
*I think we've all seen enough this season to agree that poor pass protection leads to poor results. CW scrambles to throw, but has still been sacked 29 times in 8 games. At a certain point, you get shell shocked.
*It has not really been talked about enough here, but Getsy getting fired after only 9 games in Vegas is a HUGE indictment on just how bad of an OC he was. And that was they guy leading Fields. Say what you want about Waldron, but it is now confirmed that Luke is a certified bum.
*If CW had the same skill position players at Fields had last year, the talk would be about how Chicago blew it because CW is the next Bryce Young while JD is the next Stroud. I like Mooney, but if CW had Mooney, Foreman and Clayfool instead of Odunze, Allen and Swift, he would look like hot garbage.
If Fields had the skill position players last year that CW has today, do they win 2 more games? Does Odunze come down with the deep ball against the Detroit that Scott stutter stepped on and missed by his finger tips? Does Allen come down with the hail mary against Baltimore instead of it hitting him in the gut and kicking it to the defender? Hell, does Everett catch the deep ball that landed perfectly in Tonyan paws?
Fields flaws are still his flaws, but with better coaching and talent (both were subpar while he was here) his growth may not have been stunted as much.
I think CW has a higher ceiling, but it is clear that stuff does not matter right now with bad playcalling and a poor O-line. CW is finding it harder to do what he did in college right now.
Jealousy is a sickness.......get well soon....