Idiosyncratic wrote:pepe1991 wrote:Idiosyncratic wrote:
Not sure how you watched all possessions and came out thinking Camara was primarily on White. That was Simons. Also all the times Jaylen Brown took Simons off of switches to the basket for a bucket or easy assist off of help. Possession he fell asleep on Horford fast break three. He was horrid defensively. I don’t really wait for guards to go off on him and post though, I was mainly pointing out what I thought was a historic performance with a little hint of anti-Simons bias![]()
BTW Blazers shot as good as Celtics this game. Rebounding was huge difference here. Simons grabbed 1 board in 38 minutes. My point is every contribution from every player matters. How efficiently you score, how well you rebound, how well you defend, how many extra possessions you create by taking care of ball or getting steals. People hyperfocus mostly on scoring, everything matters out of everyone .
Of course in our spot we could probably sacrifice some defense for someone more scoring oriented. Of course I would take him over the slop we have. But just trying to be realistic about what he does or doesn’t do and it isn’t worth anywhere close to his salary IMO. There is a price I would take him, but I don’t get too excited about trading assets for 28 mil Simons.
By watching all possessions where White & Prichard actually scored while Simons was on them. 5 times out of 28 made FGA.
If you want to make case for Simons sucking on defense, there is plenty of evidence for it , but this game wasn't it
What's the point about talking about rebounds in context of Simons ? Blazers were without Robert Williams and Ayton, only center they had was a rookie. ( who only played 20 min)
Wanna flip a tables:
Simons 30 points on 12-21 FG and 6 assists
- tricks White off the dribble ,gets uncotested mid range
- beats White off the dribble for uncotested shot
-stepback over Walsh
- cooks Horford off the switch for corner 3 assists
- cooks Horford off switch for layup
- Horford late switch results in open 3 ( Simons assist)
-Horford late switch again results in open 3 ( Simons assists)
- White beaten off the dribble again
- Horford chasing ghosts, lost in switches, results in Simons dunk (on/near) Brown
- beats Queta off dribble for layup
. beats Hauser for layup
-shoots over Prichard who doesn't even contest shot
- makes 3 in Horfrod's face
by watching this game, Simons cooked White and Horford too many times to count. And would you call them trash defenders?
Guy beat more people off the dribble in this game than Magic guards combined for whole season.
It's nba, guards are hard to guard. People are hyperfocused on defense. Magic have bad offensive rating. By 2012 standards. And 1 nba level guard ( Suggs) and he is not returning any time soon and God knows how he will recover.
Because rebounds do matter. It’s not only the center’s job. Guy can’t contest shots, can’t rebound, won’t get you any steals. Offense needs to be terrific to make up for it. Every aspect matters. Dude was getting rebounded over which led to open 3s. He’s supposed to just tell his centers to grab long 3 rebounds ? No need to box out?
Argument isn’t if Simons is better than Joseph. Everyone is taking Simons there. Simons is a solid player. Is he worth trade assets and committing 20+ million to? Debatable right? Maybe not for you, I’ve seen you suggest multiple 1sts for Kispert and Josh freakin Green. I want to win a title, not end up with an OK roster devoid of young talent to sustain or left with no 1sts to trade for a meaningful true plus contributor.
All of Pritchard, White and Simons were taken in the late 20s BTW for the people parroting how the Denver pick is worthless.
Pepe's analysis here is thorough and dead-on...all of the other skills matter, sure...but points are what go on the scoreboard. It means nothing that, for example, Cole is a "good rebounder for a guard", etc if there's no one else in the backcourt that can do, I don't know, guard things like pass, shoot, and score. WCJ gets crappy grades because he doesn't average enough rebounds...either 1)he's boxing out his man, leaving easy boards for teammates, or 2)his own guys are grabbing them from an unusual position, PG. WCJ should be averaging 10+ rebounds (he's done it before) and I'm certainly not his biggest fan, but I'd rather see one of our guards actually contribute meaningfully beyond something like rebounding...point is that team construction is everything and offense is absolutely more substantial than defense. Obviously, you need both, but scorers are going to score on anybody, to some degree. We would fall all over Suggs if he "held" Donovan Mitchell to only 18 (which would, on a locked-down night for DM, be above our best guard's scoring avg-by a lot ), but they'd still beat the crap out of us. You can only stop X% of an opponent's scoring...it's not like the best defenses in the league routinely hold teams to 80 or 90 points. The way all of the trade ideas are discounted because of defense is nuts...there are no "bad boys" terrorizing in 2025.

















