jalengreen wrote:Obviously Nico completely tanked his rep as GM in one clean swoop, but any conversion on his rise and fall shouldn't miss the fact that about one year ago, he had a great reputation! He was 2nd on this board's Executive of the Year voting. The relevant snippets from the four posters who had him on their ballot:
Massive turnaround with smart drafting and some unheralded midseason acquisitions that several would-be contenders could have obtained for themselves. Interested to see how the Mavericks build on this incredible chemistry next year.
Nico Harrison making the right moves, drafting Lively to the deadline deals to the Kyrie Re-Signing is huge.
Harrison did something remarkable, which is taking a solid but flawed team and adding two players mid-season to elevate them to contender status (not just the playoff run; also the end of the RS was brilliant for Dallas). Adding Washington and Gafford in the middle of the season, drafting Lively, and signing Exum and Jones Jr. as contributors – that worked out perfectly and warrants a ton of credit.
2nd spot to the other finalist. Approaching the award as I do does tend to make me focus on the teams who had elite success in the past year, and that’s an approach with some flaws, but it also makes it so that when a team really breaks through and I didn’t see it coming, I have a chance to give a mea culpa. Harrison’s plan, much to my surprise, really seems like it’s working both in terms of how to make the team fit, and how to make the players buy in.
And of course these weren't fringe opinions. I imagine most any sample of posters would have settled on Nico at #2 for such a vote.
That is to say, this story is more interesting than "weird, unorthodox hire unsurprisingly crashes and burns in epic fashion." It's more like "weird, unorthodox hire is surprisingly successful.. before promptly crashing and burning in epic fashion."
Great post.
Part of why I get so frustrated with people doing the conspiracy stuff is that I think they're actively missing a great case study in how modest success can beget catastrophic failure, or "pride comes before the fall".
Nico made a series of moves - Kyrie/Lively/Gafford/Washington - that built better around Luka than Dallas had ever been able to do before, and seemed to display not only those Nike connections but an unexpectedly sharp sense of team fit - with that specific all-in on 48 minutes of rim runners. The latter wasn't really part of, what I'll call, the Cuban theory of Nico, and it made us stand up and take notice that Nico was apparently more than we expected.
And then, the thing.
Reflecting back on this now, I'll say:
1. My assessment of the likelihood of Nico having a grand vision of a team build has gone down considerably. Not directly because of the Luka trade, but because of the fact Nico clearly didn't see the issue with adding AD to said rim runners while diminishing the team's floor general bullpen something fierce. If he at all understood how a team worked, he'd have been looking to sell high on one (or both) Gafford & Lively, and get some serious guard play. This was true before they won the lottery, but then got Cooper, and it made it all the more so.
I think the most you could credit him with, then, is being able to execute moves to address specific issues with the current roster with some talent in the eye department (despite my criticisms of him of him in that department).
2. I think Nico's pretty clearly a case of someone who let his success go to his head in a spectacularly self-defeating way. He seemed to come to treat these trades like pieces of art, with the AD-for-Luka trade being an aspirational magnum opus for this stepping stone in his legendary journey.
3. The things Nico did & did not seem to consider - what he could see and what was in his blind spots - are really worth studying. I haven't done any kind of exhaustive study, but the way he didn't seem to even think all that hard about age when moving from Luka (age 25) to 31-32 (Kyrie; AD) was so strange. If you're going to re-build your roster around guys that age, you better do it ASAP, not saunter around as if the job is done. WTF? Did he think the team didn't need to re-tool at all?