Dat2U wrote:Chaos Revenant wrote:You go ahead and show me where any of those guys were productive as McGee. And while you can question McGee's intelligence & whether he's spoiled I wouldn't jump to conclude he's unmotivated. I haven't seen signs that he doesn't really care. Maybe he doesn't 'get it', but I think the motivation is there.
Swift's career progression parallels McGee at least PER-wise. Way worse as a rookie, but was a 17 PER guy year 2, 18 PER year 3, 19.2 year 4, and he started on a playoff team. McGee absolutely cannot start on a playoff team. Tyrus Thomas doesn't quite have the stats, but they're comparable rebounders until this year, and similar ages to boot. Charlie Villanueva had an 18.6 PER his 4th year. Keep in mind that McGee's PER is pushed upwards by his empty block numbers. They're all in that mold of low-IQ, poor basketball fundamentals, big men.
Look at guys like Haywood and Perkins - they may not stuff the stat sheet or make highlight plays, but you cannot tell me with a straight face that Dallas or Oklahoma, all things being equal would trade them for Javale.
As for his motivation, he plays hard on the court, but where is the dedication to improvement? He knows he's a bad defender and makes stupid plays on the court, why hasn't he improved it in 4 years? Guys like Wall and Arenas are/were obsessed with basketball and it made the latter a transcendent player (and make no mistake, Gilbert Arenas was a transcendent player, in the Kobe/Wade/LeBron mold) and Wall seems to be on his way there. Does he care about being a good defensive center as long as he gets his highlights? Does he care about being a winner? The evidence is in and seems like the verdict is a resounding NO.
That is why Javale McGee will never be anything resembling an All-Star in this league. He may have the talent and the athleticism, but he doesn't have the brain or the drive. He will make spectacular highlight plays, and have games that make you go "wow he's a stud" but he cannot be counted on as a starting playoff center who you ask to do starting playoff center things.
And what is laughable is the excuses. "He'll be better if he plays with a tougher PF". "He'll be better if you play him such and such a way". History will remember such statements alongside "Jason Campbell is a franchise quarterback he just needs weapons!" and "THIS time Andray has turned the corner!" If you constantly, constantly need to make excuses for someone, then they're not the guy.























