theboomking wrote:This is an earnest question. What is the sentiment on the board now about Porter vs Noel. Are we now happier to have Porter? He does seem like an excellent long term piece with Wall and Beal, but the sample size is small.
lets wait until the playoff are over. We are about to gather some really important information.
I will still wait until then. Why predict when we are getting great intel right now.
And when the playoff are over and we can better evaluate him. It will only be what frog jumped last. Noel only had one year on a crap team.. It would be a unfair comparison.
But what we will know better is, was Otto a solid pick for this team. I think most felt he was on draft night and still feel that way.
Even if they had other ideas, Otto was never a bad pick. He was a solid safe pick that made sense.
My take. Not knowing what TA would do. Having the Ves pick not work out. They needed to hit on this one because they wouldn't be back that high for a while. You can miss on 1 of 4. You can't miss on 2 of 4 top picks. So most here weren't shocked they took him.
Anyone that gave up on Otto was just more of the same impatience from people that are inpatient. Nothing new.
Compare to Noel ? Now ? Makes little sense to do that. I mean, no better then doing it draft night really. Its a conversation better had in a couple years. Unless Otto goes super nova in these playoffs.
Its more likely to take a few more years to really know.



















