Sugarless wrote:Killboard wrote:sky4it wrote:McCollum is a much better athlete. Read the Draft express stuff on him, they have Murray down perfectly. By the way Taking bacon, shut the hell up, I wasnt talking to you, you must be a Klomp pal. You got that Klomp boy?
Draft express said this at the combine:
-C.J. McCollum didn't run the best times in the speed drills, but he didn't lag behind the rest of the field either, finishing right around
average. His 38.5 inch maximum vertical jump was quite good and, more than anything else, he looked like the same athlete he was prior to injuring his foot and missing the latter portion of the season.
Draft express say this about Murray:
-He has an
average combination of height, length, frame and athleticism for a guard prospect, not being particularly impressive in terms of his quickness or vertical explosiveness either.
And before you ask, Im not a Klomp fan, I just post what I think without read too much where is coming from. Helps to stay on topic.
Not that I'm very interested in this discussion, because neither McCollum nor Murray projected to be real NBA PGs during their college days and neither is going to be, IMO, but I think this debate needs some light: the biggest difference between McCollum and Murray is not athleticism, it's ballhandling. McCollum has some tight and crafty handles, he was much better with the ball than Murray throughout his college career and he's gotten better since he entered the league. That ballhandling is what allows him not only to be such a good shooter off the dribble, but also to turn the corner with the ball despite not being very athletic. Murray would have to improve quite a bit to get there (again, he may or may not, I just don't see it right now and even then I don't think that'll make him a real PG, just like McCollum isn't one).
Thank you. For putting down the details, without the empty rhetoric. Now you could have went on and on, about how I was wrong about athletic comparisons, but you didnt because you got class. Appreciated. I think you nailed it too, what you wrote is exactly what I saw on the court when McCollum plays.
Yeah, McCollum, for whatever the case or reason is, is an exceptional shooting guard. I thought he just demolished Zach Lavine, and demolished the Timberwolves defense last year.
I thought the Wolves last year, despite the woeful defensive stats, where ok defending the paint, except when they ran into really solid PG and SG tandems from other teams. Zach Lavine is a horrible defender. Buddy Hield, despite not being a good defender, might actually be an upgrade defensively, which is saying a mouthful.