Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo

Moderators: Clyde Frazier, Doctor MJ, trex_8063, penbeast0, PaulieWal

Best Athlete

Kevin Durant
10
12%
Anthony Davis
23
27%
Giannis Antetokounmpo
53
62%
 
Total votes: 86

BasketballFan7
Analyst
Posts: 3,668
And1: 2,344
Joined: Mar 11, 2015
   

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#101 » by BasketballFan7 » Tue Aug 2, 2016 6:35 pm

Whirrun wrote:
BasketballFan7 wrote:Guys, why do you feed an argument that you have no chance of winning, even if you know you are right?


I don't know if you've noticed or not, but the Davis crowd is losing. Both in argumentation, and the poll.

By the logic in this thread:

Kyrie Irving must rate REALLY highly among point guards in athleticism. Because, despite being weaker / slower than many others, his handle, shot creativity and coordination allow him to get to and convert at the rim.


Yes, Kyrie is one of the better athletes at PG. This is news?

- Davis is leading the poll; Durant is last
- Your arguments are nonsensical
- Kyrie Irving is not special athletically from a physical standpoint (although, he is a special athlete); you have made my point for me
- You have Durant over LeBron as a player, so I don't know how you dragged me into this discussion to begin with
FGA Restricted All-Time Draft

In My Hood, The Bullies Get Bullied
PG: 2013 Mike Conley, 1998 Greg Anthony
SG: 2005 Manu Ginobili, 2015 Khris Middleton
SF: 1991 Scottie Pippen
PF: 1986 Larry Bird, 1996 Dennis Rodman
C: 1999 Alonzo Mourning
Whirrun
Sophomore
Posts: 249
And1: 73
Joined: Jul 05, 2016

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#102 » by Whirrun » Tue Aug 2, 2016 6:44 pm

BasketballFan7 wrote:- Davis is leading the poll; Durant is last


It was tied when I made the comment, and even with Davis leading with an advantage of two, more people agree this is an argument than otherwise.

- Your arguments are nonsensical


No, your arguments are nonsensical!

*yawn*

- Kyrie Irving is not special athletically from a physical standpoint (although, he is a special athlete); you have made my point for me


Prove he isn't. I'll wait.


- You have Durant over LeBron as a player, so I don't know how you dragged me into this discussion to begin with


Feel free to leave anytime.
User avatar
AussieBuck
RealGM
Posts: 42,367
And1: 20,885
Joined: May 10, 2006
Location: Bucks in 7?
 

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#103 » by AussieBuck » Tue Aug 2, 2016 9:07 pm

NO-KG-AI wrote:
AussieBuck wrote:Giannis is younger and less experienced. He'll be the better player soon enough on their current trajectories.


Ah, there it is. :lol:

Yeah you're still acting like a child, had you pegged from day one when the KG comps upset you.
emunney wrote:
We need a man shaped like a chicken nugget with the shot selection of a 21st birthday party.


GHOSTofSIKMA wrote:
if you combined jabari parker, royal ivey, a shrimp and a ball sack youd have javon carter
User avatar
AussieBuck
RealGM
Posts: 42,367
And1: 20,885
Joined: May 10, 2006
Location: Bucks in 7?
 

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#104 » by AussieBuck » Tue Aug 2, 2016 9:22 pm

pelifan wrote:
AussieBuck wrote:Giannis is younger and less experienced. He'll be the better player soon enough on their current trajectories.


Age 21 Davis vs age 21 Giannis on their 2nd season in the league there is no comparison. Davis 21 and 10. Davis had less experience being 6'10" as Giannis has had as well.

To the 2nd point, if you really feel 100% confident in that statement it's homerism to say the least.

If you want to play that game Davis is closer to a year older than the same age in their respective seasons. Davis has had great box score numbers from the start but the enormous impact is something we're still waiting on. As I've said if you're charting their respective progress Davis' graph starts out great but now is looking like a log curve. I had him as an sure thing ATG so I'm guessing he'll take off again at some point and the impact will catch up to the box score but it hasn't played out that way so far. Giannis has had year on year exponential improvement so yeah, trajectories. :)

As to the experience being 6'10 thing I have no idea what you're going with there. Giannis made it from 6'9 to 6'11 throughout his first year at the Bucks. I'm guessing he should be listed at 7 foot by regular NBA convention but like Garnett would prefer not to. From memory Davis finished growing before he hit the NBA ~9 months older than Giannis. Could be wrong there but I don't really see a lot of significance.
emunney wrote:
We need a man shaped like a chicken nugget with the shot selection of a 21st birthday party.


GHOSTofSIKMA wrote:
if you combined jabari parker, royal ivey, a shrimp and a ball sack youd have javon carter
User avatar
Magic Giannison
RealGM
Posts: 27,848
And1: 27,302
Joined: Aug 08, 2014
   

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#105 » by Magic Giannison » Tue Aug 2, 2016 9:35 pm

its funny, you guys scientifically proven that Giannis got the perfect body for an NBA athlete by pros and specialist yet you keep arguing his athleticism. :lol:







NO-KG-AI ,heres freshl;y Magic Randolf offensive/defensive showcase. :lol:
MyUniBroDavis
General Manager
Posts: 7,827
And1: 5,034
Joined: Jan 14, 2013

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#106 » by MyUniBroDavis » Tue Aug 2, 2016 9:35 pm

AussieBuck wrote:
pelifan wrote:
AussieBuck wrote:Giannis is younger and less experienced. He'll be the better player soon enough on their current trajectories.


Age 21 Davis vs age 21 Giannis on their 2nd season in the league there is no comparison. Davis 21 and 10. Davis had less experience being 6'10" as Giannis has had as well.

To the 2nd point, if you really feel 100% confident in that statement it's homerism to say the least.

If you want to play that game Davis is closer to a year older than the same age in their respective seasons. Davis has had great box score numbers from the start but the enormous impact is something we're still waiting on. As I've said if you're charting their respective progress Davis' graph starts out great but now is looking like a log curve. I had him as an sure thing ATG so I'm guessing he'll take off again at some point and the impact will catch up to the box score but it hasn't played out that way so far. Giannis has had year on year exponential improvement so yeah, trajectories. :)

As to the experience being 6'10 thing I have no idea what you're going with there. Giannis made it from 6'9 to 6'11 throughout his first year at the Bucks. I'm guessing he should be listed at 7 foot by regular NBA convention but like Garnett would prefer not to. From memory Davis finished growing before he hit the NBA ~9 months older than Giannis. Could be wrong there but I don't really see a lot of significance.



So far, 2015 Davis is far, far above anything we have seen from Gianni's.

https://www.reddit.com/r/nba/comments/2d8tmb/anthony_daviss_wingspan_has_possibly_grown_from/

Height allegedly is 7ft. I mean, look at pics of him and towns, they look around the same height now.

2015 Davis clearly had "enormous impact" despite conditions hurting him.
User avatar
AussieBuck
RealGM
Posts: 42,367
And1: 20,885
Joined: May 10, 2006
Location: Bucks in 7?
 

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#107 » by AussieBuck » Tue Aug 2, 2016 9:39 pm

I'm sure Davis is about that height, other than being a bit more built he looked pretty much the same as Giannis when they've played each other.

Edit to add, what enourmous impact though? I'd say that's the one part we are still waiting on unless you are referring to boxscore rubbish like PER?
emunney wrote:
We need a man shaped like a chicken nugget with the shot selection of a 21st birthday party.


GHOSTofSIKMA wrote:
if you combined jabari parker, royal ivey, a shrimp and a ball sack youd have javon carter
MyUniBroDavis
General Manager
Posts: 7,827
And1: 5,034
Joined: Jan 14, 2013

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#108 » by MyUniBroDavis » Tue Aug 2, 2016 9:40 pm

AussieBuck wrote:I'm sure Davis is about that height, other than being a bit more built he looked pretty much the same as Giannis when they've played each other.



Even if they are the same height, Davis has a large advantage in wingspan, and Davis is over 30 pounds heavier, while being arguably as fast and as explosive. Gianni's is more agile, but it's not night and day.
User avatar
AussieBuck
RealGM
Posts: 42,367
And1: 20,885
Joined: May 10, 2006
Location: Bucks in 7?
 

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#109 » by AussieBuck » Tue Aug 2, 2016 9:44 pm

MyUniBroDavis wrote:
AussieBuck wrote:I'm sure Davis is about that height, other than being a bit more built he looked pretty much the same as Giannis when they've played each other.



Even if they are the same height, Davis has a large advantage in wingspan, and Davis is over 30 pounds heavier, while being arguably as fast and as explosive. Gianni's is more agile, but it's not night and day.

Yeah will probably take Giannis another couple of years to get near Davis' bulk if he doesn't stop before then due to PG duties. He's probably got a little more wingspan maybe two inches, standing reach probably similar due to Giannis not having much neck. Similar physical dudes long term I'd guess. But yeah I'd agree Davis is more explosive initially, Giannis gets special from the second step.
emunney wrote:
We need a man shaped like a chicken nugget with the shot selection of a 21st birthday party.


GHOSTofSIKMA wrote:
if you combined jabari parker, royal ivey, a shrimp and a ball sack youd have javon carter
User avatar
Magic Giannison
RealGM
Posts: 27,848
And1: 27,302
Joined: Aug 08, 2014
   

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#110 » by Magic Giannison » Tue Aug 2, 2016 9:54 pm

MyUniBroDavis wrote:
AussieBuck wrote:I'm sure Davis is about that height, other than being a bit more built he looked pretty much the same as Giannis when they've played each other.



Even if they are the same height, Davis has a large advantage in wingspan, and Davis is over 30 pounds heavier, while being arguably as fast and as explosive. Gianni's is more agile, but it's not night and day.

I agree with Davis being stronger and explosive but no way he is faster than Giannis.
MyUniBroDavis
General Manager
Posts: 7,827
And1: 5,034
Joined: Jan 14, 2013

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#111 » by MyUniBroDavis » Tue Aug 2, 2016 9:54 pm

Magic Giannison wrote:its funny, you guys scientifically proven that Giannis got the perfect body for an NBA athlete by pros and specialist yet you keep arguing his athleticism. :lol:







NO-KG-AI ,heres freshl;y Magic Randolf offensive/defensive showcase. :lol:



Perfect body? No, the article said one of the best bodies. Looking at it overall, it doesn't really say much.

Wingspan: as large as his wingspan is, Davis's is almost 5 inches longer, so this isn't even close.

Lateral movement: Gianni's has the advantage, but to say Davis has ordinary lateral movement for a big man is absurd

Height: Davis is bit taller

Lean muscle: funny how they don't mention height being a factor in this. Anyway, Davis went from 220 to 242 and didn't look. A step slower. Only did after he went all the way up to 250, and it may have been due to injury.

Core: "The aerobatic ability to dribble the length of the floor, elevate for a rebound, fly laterally through the air for an alley-oop-all complex movements that originate from the core."

Davis is better at 2/3 of these things, and he scores more ppp in transition, by over 0.1ppp

Hands: big hands also mean you might suck at shooting. Example:Giannis

Launch power: it looks like they are saying something like how fast you can go from one jump into another jump? I guess how high ur jump is without a max vert or something. Honestly it's not really clear, but I think Davis clearly gets higher on average than Gianni's in game, so this doesn't really make sense

Achilles: I'll concede this one.

Let's not act as if Davis has an average joe body.


Also, you have to understand, anyone comparing the two, one player plays for the worst medical staff in the league, one irate coach and another who basically turned him into a post up player. To put it this way, what if instead of giannis being a pg like player, what if you ,add him a back to the basket scorer?

Yeah, that's what we are dealing with basically.
MyUniBroDavis
General Manager
Posts: 7,827
And1: 5,034
Joined: Jan 14, 2013

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#112 » by MyUniBroDavis » Tue Aug 2, 2016 9:55 pm

Magic Giannison wrote:
MyUniBroDavis wrote:
AussieBuck wrote:I'm sure Davis is about that height, other than being a bit more built he looked pretty much the same as Giannis when they've played each other.



Even if they are the same height, Davis has a large advantage in wingspan, and Davis is over 30 pounds heavier, while being arguably as fast and as explosive. Gianni's is more agile, but it's not night and day.

I agree with Davis being stronger and explosive but no way he is faster than Giannis.



There really isn't much proof since there aren't many clips of Davis going full speed, but a slightly slower Davis is said to Have tied with Tyreke in a foot race, who is ridiculously fast even with injuries.
User avatar
Magic Giannison
RealGM
Posts: 27,848
And1: 27,302
Joined: Aug 08, 2014
   

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#113 » by Magic Giannison » Tue Aug 2, 2016 10:14 pm

MyUniBroDavis wrote:

Perfect body? No, the article said one of the best bodies. Looking at it overall, it doesn't really say much.

The most exceptional NBA body they call it.

Wingspan: as large as his wingspan is, Davis's is almost 5 inches longer, so this isn't even close.

Bobam Marjanovic got the biggest wingspan if im not mistaken , that doesn't mean he is athletic just that he got freakish arms. You a combination of many things in order to convert into athleticism

Lateral movement: Gianni's has the advantage, but to say Davis has ordinary lateral movement for a big man is absurd



Height: Davis is bit taller

Huh? isnt Davis listed 6.10 ? While Giannis is 6.11 ?
http://www.basketball-reference.com/players/d/davisan02.html
Height: 6-10 ▪ Weight: 253 lbs.



Lean muscle: funny how they don't mention height being a factor in this. Anyway, Davis went from 220 to 242 and didn't look. A step slower. Only did after he went all the way up to 250, and it may have been due to injury.

Giannis went from 6.8 to 6.11 in offseason alone. Giannis was 2.10 lbs when he came and now is 222 lbs. Despite that he became more quick and more explosive as he put muscles and trained his body.

Core: "The aerobatic ability to dribble the length of the floor, elevate for a rebound, fly laterally through the air for an alley-oop-all complex movements that originate from the core."


Davis is better at 2/3 of these things, and he scores more ppp in transition, by over 0.1ppp

Ermm no, he is not, From all the top 8 in transitions corers Giannis was the second most efficient behind only Lebron James.

Hands: big hands also mean you might suck at shooting. Example:Giannis

Shooting is part of technique that can be learner anytime, A.K.A look at Kawhi.

Launch power: it looks like they are saying something like how fast you can go from one jump into another jump? I guess how high ur jump is without a max vert or something. Honestly it's not really clear, but I think Davis clearly gets higher on average than Gianni's in game, so this doesn't really make sense

His body is perfectly build so he wont consume much energy like the other do, because of how his hips and his body in general allow Giannis to do those ridiculous non stop Jumps and the eurostep Dunks.he doesnt need time to recover like others.
"One of the hallmarks of athleticism, transferring energy is what allows Antetokounmpo to bounce around the floor like he's on a pogo stick."
Pretty clear.

Achilles: I'll concede this one.

:nod:

Let's not act as if Davis has an average joe body.

He is not but he is compared to on e of the most freakish atheltes in the NBA, that doesnt make his body average its just makes Giannis more athletic, thats all.

Also, you have to understand, anyone comparing the two, one player plays for the worst medical staff in the league, one irate coach and another who basically turned him into a post up player. To put it this way, what if instead of Giannis being a pg like player, what if you ,add him a back to the basket scorer?

Giannis played and plays under bad coaches as well only post ASB he actually played his natural position and flourished.
The thing is with Giannis is how flexible he is with positions, last year he guarded ALL of them, From PG to C.
Giannis is not as good on posting ( but respectable) because he gets pushed by bigger C's, hence why he plays mostly PF on defense.
Whirrun
Sophomore
Posts: 249
And1: 73
Joined: Jul 05, 2016

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#114 » by Whirrun » Tue Aug 2, 2016 10:19 pm

Davis is 6'10 with a 7'5 wingspan. Don't know where that stuff about him being 7ft with a wing span 5 inches longer than Giannis came from. He also has an inferior standing reach to both KD & GA, and that was before their respective growth spurts.
User avatar
Magic Giannison
RealGM
Posts: 27,848
And1: 27,302
Joined: Aug 08, 2014
   

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#115 » by Magic Giannison » Tue Aug 2, 2016 10:20 pm

MyUniBroDavis wrote:
Magic Giannison wrote:
MyUniBroDavis wrote:

Even if they are the same height, Davis has a large advantage in wingspan, and Davis is over 30 pounds heavier, while being arguably as fast and as explosive. Gianni's is more agile, but it's not night and day.

I agree with Davis being stronger and explosive but no way he is faster than Giannis.



There really isn't much proof since there aren't many clips of Davis going full speed, but a slightly slower Davis is said to Have tied with Tyreke in a foot race, who is ridiculously fast even with injuries.

Length also plays a big role as well as 1 foot by Davis could mean 3 by Tyreke :lol:
The thing is Giannis does it constantly in almost every game, he picks the ball and goes down the floor in 3 dribbles or so . There many clips showcasing his speed on the floor and with the ball mainly outrunning other defenders.
We also can see Giannis being way behind and still catching the opponent , he is a well know as a great chase down blocker.
User avatar
pelifan
RealGM
Posts: 14,237
And1: 21,691
Joined: Aug 12, 2014
Location: Small market
 

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#116 » by pelifan » Tue Aug 2, 2016 10:31 pm

AussieBuck wrote:
pelifan wrote:
AussieBuck wrote:Giannis is younger and less experienced. He'll be the better player soon enough on their current trajectories.


Age 21 Davis vs age 21 Giannis on their 2nd season in the league there is no comparison. Davis 21 and 10. Davis had less experience being 6'10" as Giannis has had as well.

To the 2nd point, if you really feel 100% confident in that statement it's homerism to say the least.

If you want to play that game Davis is closer to a year older than the same age in their respective seasons. Davis has had great box score numbers from the start but the enormous impact is something we're still waiting on. As I've said if you're charting their respective progress Davis' graph starts out great but now is looking like a log curve. I had him as an sure thing ATG so I'm guessing he'll take off again at some point and the impact will catch up to the box score but it hasn't played out that way so far. Giannis has had year on year exponential improvement so yeah, trajectories. :)

As to the experience being 6'10 thing I have no idea what you're going with there. Giannis made it from 6'9 to 6'11 throughout his first year at the Bucks. I'm guessing he should be listed at 7 foot by regular NBA convention but like Garnett would prefer not to. From memory Davis finished growing before he hit the NBA ~9 months older than Giannis. Could be wrong there but I don't really see a lot of significance.


Firstly, I didn't use Anthony Davis' historical 2015 season in which he was 21 and turned 22 in march. I use Anthony Davis's 2nd year in the league in which he was 20, turning 21 in march compared to Giannis' third season (my mistake calling it Giannis' 2nd season). Secondly Anthony Davis also wen from 6'10" to 7ft after becoming pro. Thirdly show me Giannis' much superior impact. If he wants to match Davis' trajectory he needs to have an MVP type season this year and be a top 50 realgm peaks guy. So if we do the comparison of there career up to this point:

age: 16-17
6'3" Anthony Davis
?????? Giannis

age 17-18
high school phenom Davis
tantalizing prospect Giannis playing pro greek ball.

age 18-19
college player of the year Davis and #1 pick
NBA rook Giannis who shows flashes of star potential

age 19-20
Rookie Davis 13.5 and 8.2
Sophomore Giannis 12.7 and 6.7 in 10% more mpg

age 20-21
Sophomore Anthony Davis 21 and 10 and 3
3rd year Giannis 17, 7 and 4

So AD has been better every year up to this point with even less time to adjust against top level competition. Giannis has faced better level of competition every year and has had less changes in his body.

Not to mention AD gets more steals despite Giannis supposedly being a longer better perimeter defender.
Image
MyUniBroDavis
General Manager
Posts: 7,827
And1: 5,034
Joined: Jan 14, 2013

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#117 » by MyUniBroDavis » Tue Aug 2, 2016 10:43 pm

Wingspan: as large as his wingspan is, Davis's is almost 5 inches longer, so this isn't even close.

Bobam Marjanovic got the biggest wingspan if im not mistaken , that doesn't mean he is athletic just that he got freakish arms. You a combination of many things in order to convert into athleticism


What?
Also, it was said in an article, just look up Davis wingspan grew


Huh? isnt Davis listed 6.10 ? While Giannis is 6.11 ?
http://www.basketball-reference.com/players/d/davisan02.html
Height: 6-10 ▪ Weight: 253 lbs.


http://www.nba.com/pelicans/news/anthony-davis-238-pounds-may-still-be-growing-6-10/

Compare pictures of his rookie year to now. Nba listed height is usually wrong anyway lol

Giannis went from 6.8 to 6.11 in offseason alone. Giannis was 2.10 lbs when he came and now is 222 lbs. Despite that he became more quick and more explosive as he put muscles and trained his body.


How much of it was muscle, and how much of it was that he grew 3 inches? Also, Davis did the same, but went from 220 to 242

Ermm no, he is not, From all the top 8 in transitions corers Giannis was the second most efficient behind only Lebron James.


For all players who have over 100 possessions, Davis is the most efficient in the league. Also, klay and KD are more efficient in that category as well.mgiannis scores 1.22ppp. Davis scores 1.36ppp, a huge drop from last year iirc

Shooting is part of technique that can be learner anytime, A.K.A look at Kawhi.


Can make it harder. There are always exceptions, but typically larger hands make it harder to shoot. Also, 15 inches vs 12 inches. I think Gianni's will get better at this area though

His body is perfectly build so he wont consume much energy like the other do, because of how his hips and his body in general allow Giannis to do those ridiculous non stop Jumps and the eurostep Dunks.he doesnt need time to recover like others.
"One of the hallmarks of athleticism, transferring energy is what allows Antetokounmpo to bounce around the floor like he's on a pogo stick."
Pretty clear


This seems like a really long way to phrase pylometric ability. Those Eurostep dunks are more of a one leg vs two leg thing, it's hard to explain but it really isn't as complicated as the article says it is. Davis is known, probably more so, for doing this as well



Giannis played and plays under bad coaches as well only post ASB he actually played his natural position and flourished.
The thing is with Giannis is how flexible he is with positions, last year he guarded ALL of them, From PG to C.
Giannis is not as good on posting ( but respectable) because he gets pushed by bigger C's, hence why he plays mostly PF on defense.


While this is a good point, let's talk about coaching. The difference is Monty let him face up and do his thing. Gentry made him more of a back to the basket player, and made him pop too much instead of roll. You don't understand how much that ffffffffed up Davis's offensive game. Honestly, I've written an essay on how bad the Pelicans coaching is, but to be blunt it's not close to the same thing, because Gianni's got to "have his way" eventually. Davis hasn't

I expect next year to be where he has to prove himself
Whirrun
Sophomore
Posts: 249
And1: 73
Joined: Jul 05, 2016

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#118 » by Whirrun » Tue Aug 2, 2016 10:44 pm

MyUniBroDavis wrote:Hardly fair, it's a bigger part of Durante game, and he is extremely efficient, but it's not as if Davis isn't good in transition.


It's a bigger part of Durant's game because he runs the floor better.

Out of all players with 100 plus possessions, he is first, at 1.36ppp Kd is at 1.33ppp


Right, so Durant gets you a couple hundred more points on nigh identical efficiency? He's comfortably the superior player in transition.

Durant does get more rebounds per rebound chance than Davis, but there are 2 problems with this.

1, Davis is elite in this category, getting 65.7% of his rebound opportunities, behind only deandre and Drummond, and 2, Durant generally won't rebound against the centers as much (looking at avg rebound distance, while Durant should be further for obvious reasons he is a clear outlier).


Neither of these things negates the fact that relative to their role & position, Durant is the superior rebounder.

Hip, thigh, and core strength? You realize this also plays a part in, well, strength, right? Davis is arguably faster, and clearly more explosive (let's not act as if lebron really sprinted in that race, he was running at a moderately fast pace, he was going full Throttle)


Davis is neither faster nor more explosive from a stand still. I do believe he's a more explosive leaper though. Bounce and overall strength are his two athletic advantages in this comparison imo.

Here's the thing. I agree that Gianni's and Durant are more fluid than AD. But Davis isn't like some deandre Jordan. He is very fluid for his size. VERY. when's the last time you saw a big men jab step hesitate and fade away, and do that stuff? Exactly.


I very much believe Davis is comparable to Jordan athletically. In some instances I'd favor the latter, especially around the rim on offense.

As for the "perfect body" there's one thing. Davis at this point is around 6ft11-7ft, but his wingspan allegedly grew to 7ft7 3/4. So yeah like he wins.


Davis is 6'10 with a 7'5 wingspan. He's shorter than KD and the same height as Giannis while being the least mobile of the 3 and carrying the shortest standing reach.

It's not about speed and stuff, it's about the combination of size, strength, and speed. You could definitely argue (and I think so tbh) that Davis is faster than both in a foot race, and he is much stronger than either of them. He is more "physically gifted" than either, and requires less effort to jump and do that stuff than either of them.


The Davis party has provided nothing to substantiate these claims that he's faster than Durant & Giannis. Meanwhile, there's been multiple clips showing both of them getting down the floor and to the basket in two dribbles.

Let me put it this way. Give 2015 davis Durant's jump shot. Who scares you more? Better yet, take it away from both of them.


AD has a jump shot, yet KD comfortably remains the superior player. Why? Because his overall package is more dominant than what AD brings to the table. In large part because of what he's able to do on the perimeter(32/8/5, for example) at 6'11, 240 with a 7'5 wing span.

As for ball handling, that stuff is true. But, ya know, the most important part is the ball handling part. And "ball handling ability" hardly proves any of that is true, it's simply stuff needed. Going by that logic, John wall can handle the ball better than steph curry, or every street baller is more athletic and nimble than the average nba sg or sf.


You're basically proving our points. John Wall's handle isn't as strong as Curry's(whose underrated athletically. His lateral quickness and quick twitch movements are lethal), but he's still able to get the the rim at will due to his overall athletic package.

In the same vein, despite AD's handle being inferior to GA & KD, he should be able to still get to the basket at will given his alleged athletic advantages. This isn't the case though... why?

Also, let's talk about their respective ceilings, instead of projections. If we are going there for Gianni's arguement

Alright, one guy has the ceiling of the top of Bill gates house.

The other has the ceiling of the Hubble telescope

Like holy crap you have no idea how many things that had to go wrong went wrong for Davis this year. If you take 2015 Davis and give him a legitimate good coach then that's already higher than Gianni's will ever reach. You don't understand how incredibly fffffffed up 2015 was.

2016 there were injuries and he just didn't finish well at times.


Davis is the better player and he has the higher ceiling(jump shot, skill, IQ, defense), but that doesn't mean he's more athletic. The two notions are mutually exclusive.
User avatar
AussieBuck
RealGM
Posts: 42,367
And1: 20,885
Joined: May 10, 2006
Location: Bucks in 7?
 

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#119 » by AussieBuck » Tue Aug 2, 2016 10:48 pm

pelifan wrote:
AussieBuck wrote:
pelifan wrote:
Age 21 Davis vs age 21 Giannis on their 2nd season in the league there is no comparison. Davis 21 and 10. Davis had less experience being 6'10" as Giannis has had as well.

To the 2nd point, if you really feel 100% confident in that statement it's homerism to say the least.

If you want to play that game Davis is closer to a year older than the same age in their respective seasons. Davis has had great box score numbers from the start but the enormous impact is something we're still waiting on. As I've said if you're charting their respective progress Davis' graph starts out great but now is looking like a log curve. I had him as an sure thing ATG so I'm guessing he'll take off again at some point and the impact will catch up to the box score but it hasn't played out that way so far. Giannis has had year on year exponential improvement so yeah, trajectories. :)

As to the experience being 6'10 thing I have no idea what you're going with there. Giannis made it from 6'9 to 6'11 throughout his first year at the Bucks. I'm guessing he should be listed at 7 foot by regular NBA convention but like Garnett would prefer not to. From memory Davis finished growing before he hit the NBA ~9 months older than Giannis. Could be wrong there but I don't really see a lot of significance.


Firstly, I didn't use Anthony Davis' historical 2015 season in which he was 21 and turned 22 in march. I use Anthony Davis's 2nd year in the league in which he was 20, turning 21 in march compared to Giannis' third season (my mistake calling it Giannis' 2nd season). Secondly Anthony Davis also wen from 6'10" to 7ft after becoming pro. Thirdly show me Giannis' much superior impact. If he wants to match Davis' trajectory he needs to have an MVP type season this year and be a top 50 realgm peaks guy. So if we do the comparison of there career up to this point:

age: 16-17
6'3" Anthony Davis
?????? Giannis

age 17-18
high school phenom Davis
tantalizing prospect Giannis playing pro greek ball.

age 18-19
college player of the year Davis and #1 pick
NBA rook Giannis who shows flashes of star potential

age 19-20
Rookie Davis 13.5 and 8.2
Sophomore Giannis 12.7 and 6.7 in 10% more mpg

age 20-21
Sophomore Anthony Davis 21 and 10 and 3
3rd year Giannis 17, 7 and 4

So AD has been better every year up to this point with even less time to adjust against top level competition. Giannis has faced better level of competition every year and has had less changes in his body.

Not to mention AD gets more steals despite Giannis supposedly being a longer better perimeter defender.

Dude you aren't reading my posts. I haven't said at any point that Giannis has "much superior impact." I said that he'd be better soon at their current trajectories. Davis has great stats but hasn't been a high impact guy so I don't really see how what I've said is particularly offensive. I mean you aren't suggesting that he's been a superstar up to this point right?
emunney wrote:
We need a man shaped like a chicken nugget with the shot selection of a 21st birthday party.


GHOSTofSIKMA wrote:
if you combined jabari parker, royal ivey, a shrimp and a ball sack youd have javon carter
User avatar
Prez
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 27,332
And1: 44,669
Joined: Jan 26, 2015
 

Re: Best Athlete: Kevin Durant vs. Anthony Davis vs. Giannis Antetokounmpo 

Post#120 » by Prez » Tue Aug 2, 2016 10:49 pm

pelifan wrote:
AussieBuck wrote:
pelifan wrote:
Age 21 Davis vs age 21 Giannis on their 2nd season in the league there is no comparison. Davis 21 and 10. Davis had less experience being 6'10" as Giannis has had as well.

To the 2nd point, if you really feel 100% confident in that statement it's homerism to say the least.

If you want to play that game Davis is closer to a year older than the same age in their respective seasons. Davis has had great box score numbers from the start but the enormous impact is something we're still waiting on. As I've said if you're charting their respective progress Davis' graph starts out great but now is looking like a log curve. I had him as an sure thing ATG so I'm guessing he'll take off again at some point and the impact will catch up to the box score but it hasn't played out that way so far. Giannis has had year on year exponential improvement so yeah, trajectories. :)

As to the experience being 6'10 thing I have no idea what you're going with there. Giannis made it from 6'9 to 6'11 throughout his first year at the Bucks. I'm guessing he should be listed at 7 foot by regular NBA convention but like Garnett would prefer not to. From memory Davis finished growing before he hit the NBA ~9 months older than Giannis. Could be wrong there but I don't really see a lot of significance.


Firstly, I didn't use Anthony Davis' historical 2015 season in which he was 21 and turned 22 in march. I use Anthony Davis's 2nd year in the league in which he was 20, turning 21 in march compared to Giannis' third season (my mistake calling it Giannis' 2nd season). Secondly Anthony Davis also wen from 6'10" to 7ft after becoming pro. Thirdly show me Giannis' much superior impact. If he wants to match Davis' trajectory he needs to have an MVP type season this year and be a top 50 realgm peaks guy. So if we do the comparison of there career up to this point:

age: 16-17
6'3" Anthony Davis
?????? Giannis

age 17-18
high school phenom Davis
tantalizing prospect Giannis playing pro greek ball.

age 18-19
college player of the year Davis and #1 pick
NBA rook Giannis who shows flashes of star potential

age 19-20
Rookie Davis 13.5 and 8.2
Sophomore Giannis 12.7 and 6.7 in 10% more mpg

age 20-21
Sophomore Anthony Davis 21 and 10 and 3
3rd year Giannis 17, 7 and 4

So AD has been better every year up to this point with even less time to adjust against top level competition. Giannis has faced better level of competition every year and has had less changes in his body.

Not to mention AD gets more steals despite Giannis supposedly being a longer better perimeter defender.

Look, I'm not trying to argue about Giannis being better than Davis at any point or anything like that, but this growth argument really doesn't stack up to Giannis' background. Giannis didn't even start playing basketball seriously until late 2008, and before that grew up in poverty selling watches and wallets on the street for grocery money. His background as a basketball prospect was absolute garbage. You wanna talk time to adjust? Talk about the guy who didn't start playing until he was 13-14 years old, didn't play against top HS/AAU competition growing up, and didn't go to the best college team in America to prepare him specifically for the NBA...not the guy who grew taller while getting MORE athletic.

Return to Player Comparisons