Knickstape1214 wrote:dakomish23 wrote:Knickstape1214 wrote:KP's defense was much better at the 4 than the 5 this past season. 82games.com's stats back that claim up.
What were the most used lineups where he's at the 5? If it's him at the 5 and defensive scrubs 1-4, that's not a good indicator.
I'm basing my opinion on what I saw this season. 3 games to me that stick out where he played the 5 a lot, especially in the 2nd half, was the 1st BKN game, 1st LAL game and the 1st MIN game.
If you were building the best defensive team from this roster, where would you have him playing?
Also what about the fit offensively?
http://www.82games.com/1617/16NYK12.HTM
We didn't have a good defensive lineup really at any point last year and if I'm basing something on stats, I'm using a larger sample size over just a three game one. You'd think the defense would be better because it'd bring him closer to the rim, but aside from a couple of games, his defense on the perimter was fine - it was his PnR defense that was an issue, but that was an issue whether he was playing the 4 or 5 because a) we had no scheme and b) look who the defensive PG was involved in the action most of the time.
I know KP was -11 within 6 feet (which is absurd) and we should try to keep him closer to the rim, but our defense was bad when he was playing at the 5. Using his mobility and ability to alter shots weak side, recover / rotate, etc is what we should be doing until he's strong enough to play the 5 (which we shouldn't rush into and, even then, I don't know we should be doing it that often).
Offensively the fit is better because more spacing.
If I'm building the best defensive team, I'm putting him at the 4 now and not thinking twice about it.
I am actually seeing a lot of evidence to the opposite.
Out of our top 5 most used lineups, only one had KP at C and it was the only lineup that was positive (+14). It was by far our best lineup out of the top 5 most used with the best offense and the best defense rating.
The next lineup with KP at C, was the 6th most used lineup and it was also positive (+1). Actually looking thru our top 20 most used lineups, 4 had KP at C, and only one lineup was negative (-1). The rest were positive.
Looking closely at the most used lineup with KP at C (Anthony, C.Lee, K.Porzingis, D.Rose, L.Thomas) and it was very effective.
ORating: 112.6
DRating: 103.2
+14 overall
There are also a lot of other KP at C lineups that faired very well. In the right lineup no doubt KP can be very effective at C and it is where he can be utilized to maximize his effectiveness
http://stats.nba.com/lineups/traditional/#!?Season=2016-17&SeasonType=Regular%20Season&TeamID=1610612752&sort=PLUS_MINUS&dir=1



























