Knicksfan1992 wrote:rammagen wrote:Knicksfan1992 wrote:
This is the worst of all Geno takes...
no i would say yours is. Geno is a disaster and to say anything less is really a mystery, why because he was bad with the Jets he will magically change and be good with the Giants? get real the guy is a mental midget. nothing I said was untrue and completely verifiable. Or you mean he did not make the same mistakes repeatedly or he did not get into a fight with a 260 lber when he bailed on an event and offered to pay back the player in question never mind he was supposed to be a team leader? what do you base your opinion on? because it must not have been seeing him play.
Geno sucks almost as bad your limited post because there is some substance to geno but not your post
Show me tape of Geno not making reads and I'll believe you. And yes everything you said was untrue.
http://www.footballoutsiders.com/film-room/2015/film-room-ryan-fitzpatrick
But yeah let me see what you pull out of your bs hot take rants that has any sort of actual qb evaluation.
so lets review how did Geno hurt his knee when he had a chance to start last yr,,, oh he held onto the ball too long history proves you wrong as well as stats. geno made the same mistakes over and over again and did not learn from them. I would have loved for Geno to succeed but he did not. The main reason why he failed was himself, he did not learn from his basic mistakes. he could read a defense not really, when he had his best games he was a one or two read qb. With the field split in half. I have seen him miss open receivers again and again once I can see but when the defense leaves people open and baits into the throw they want you to make you are not a startin qb in the nfl. Look at his stats they are bad beyond bad way too many turnovers but yeah he makes reads. The issue is with Geno he does not think. . AT best he is a career backup stop making him into something he is not a productive smart qb. everyone knows what Geno is a turn over waiting to happen a qb that can snatch defeat out of victory. I saw every Jet Game and he made no progress. even with bad receivers you can not blame every interception and sack on the the other players around him. I am not sure if you want to play him because every geno fan will have a built in excuse, the Gmen receivers were hurt and they are.
The link you posted is about blasting fitzpatrick and pumping Geno and they even say he is not a high bar to clear. stop and take the geno tinted glasses off and give really critical review of the qb not the person the qb. You will see he has not progressed from his 2nd yr. Is that the Jets fault maybe but after giving him chance after chance and watching him make the same mistakes again and again and blow those chances he is what he is. Geno thought after 8-8 he could cost he could not he never learned and mentally lazy he never learned the mental game.
He played in 36 games for teh jets and 36 interceptions to 28 tds factor in the fumbles and has 43 turn overs. Not all of those turn overs are on the receiver or the linemen it was because geno never learned to throw the ball away hence last yr when he got hurt it was because he held onto the ball to long and never threw it away.
The below areticles can be from any Geno Smith game just change the dates
http://nypost.com/2017/08/22/geno-smith-to-see-some-familiar-faces-with-his-future-on-the-line/
http://www.nj.com/giants/index.ssf/2017/08/full_geno_smith_experience_on_display_again_giants.html
review from a preseason game
Smith completed 11-of-17 (64.7 percent) passes for 79 yards. He finished with a 50.9 passer rating. He had two carries for four yards and was sacked one time for a loss of nine yards.
ANALYSIS
Smith has performed exactly as expected in his first two preseason games with the Giants: Flashes of the talent that made him a second-round pick by the Jets in the 2013 draft mixed with the mind-numbing turnovers that ruined his four seasons with Gang Green. The rollercoaster continued on Monday night.
Smith had a prime opportunity to seize the backup job and he appeared to be on his way when he ran the offense smoothly after relieving Eli Manning. Smith engineered the Giants' best drive with a steady diet of safe passes early in the fourth quarter, but he threw a killer interception at the Browns' 4-yard line.
Coach Ben McAdoo was clearly unhappy with Smith's performance.
"He took a timeout in the fourth quarter that I didn't like. He threw an interception on the goal line which I didn't like," McAdoo said. "Those things stood out to me. Other than that, he played pretty good."
GRADE: D+
Smith erased all of his positive work with the terrible interception deep in Cleveland's territory. McAdoo's postgame remarks indicated that he won't have much patience for such mistakes going forward.
