Rank these late first - early second PGs
Moderators: Marcus, Duke4life831
Rank these late first - early second PGs
- clyde21
- RealGM
- Posts: 61,708
- And1: 69,196
- Joined: Aug 20, 2014
Rank these late first - early second PGs
Jalen Brunson
Tony Carr
Jevon Carter
Trevon Duval
Keenan Evans
Devonte Graham
Aaron Holiday
Elie Okobo
Kerwin Roach
Landry Shamet
Khyrie Thomas
In which order would draft these guys in?
Tony Carr
Jevon Carter
Trevon Duval
Keenan Evans
Devonte Graham
Aaron Holiday
Elie Okobo
Kerwin Roach
Landry Shamet
Khyrie Thomas
In which order would draft these guys in?
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 14,879
- And1: 3,479
- Joined: Feb 11, 2012
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
Landry Shamet
Elie Okobo
Jalen Brunson
Trevon Duval
Khyri Thomas
Kerwin Roach
Jevon Carter
Aaron Holiday
Devonte Graham
Tony Carr
Keenan Evans
Only Shamet as a clear cut 1st round guy
Elie Okobo
Jalen Brunson
Trevon Duval
Khyri Thomas
Kerwin Roach
Jevon Carter
Aaron Holiday
Devonte Graham
Tony Carr
Keenan Evans
Only Shamet as a clear cut 1st round guy
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 4,776
- And1: 1,226
- Joined: Jul 23, 2013
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
Fischella wrote:Landry Shamet
Elie Okobo
Jalen Brunson
Trevon Duval
Khyri Thomas
Kerwin Roach
Jevon Carter
Aaron Holiday
Devonte Graham
Tony Carr
Keenan Evans
Only Shamet as a clear cut 1st round guy
Are you ranking guards or point guards? Tony Carr, Kerwin Roach, and Khyri Thomas are not point guards in the NBA. Might even throw Keenan Evans in there. Khyri Thomas specifically can’t handle the ball. I think you can make the argument for Roach at point, but even then he’s a long ways away from being that. If you have Roach as a point I would also throw Tyus Battle in there.
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
- EvanZ
- RealGM
- Posts: 12,732
- And1: 3,220
- Joined: Apr 06, 2011
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
Agree with Shamet being the only clear cut first rounder of this group. I have Khyrie going late first, but I see him as a combo guard. I think Shake might end up being a point guard, or at least a backup point guard, and I have him going in the first round right after Shamet. A lot (maybe most) of these guys aren't really point guards.
I was right about 3 point shooting. I expect to be right about Tacko Fall. Some coach will figure out how to use Tacko Fall. This movement towards undersized centers will sweep ng back. Back to the basket scorers will return to the NBA.
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
-
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,687
- And1: 1,757
- Joined: Apr 02, 2016
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
Wheres bruce brown?
1st rd
Jalen Brunson
Landry Shamet
2nd rd
Trevon duval
Elie okobo
Tony carr
Khyri thomas maybe undrafted
Undrafted
Aaron holiday
Devonte graham
Kerwin roach
Jevon carter
Keenan evans
1st rd
Jalen Brunson
Landry Shamet
2nd rd
Trevon duval
Elie okobo
Tony carr
Khyri thomas maybe undrafted
Undrafted
Aaron holiday
Devonte graham
Kerwin roach
Jevon carter
Keenan evans
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGsy
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 4,776
- And1: 1,226
- Joined: Jul 23, 2013
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGsy
EvanZ wrote:Agree with Shamet being the only clear cut first rounder of this group. I have Khyrie going late first, but I see him as a combo guard. I think Shake might end up being a point guard, or at least a backup point guard, and I have him going in the first round right after Shamet. A lot (maybe most) of these guys aren't really point guards.
Shake is no way a point in the NBA. His footspeed just isn’t good enough to get into the lane and he doesn’t have a handle. To be a point in the NBA the #1 requirement is the ability to get into the paint to either dish or finish via at the hoop or via floater. They have to A) have a good enough handle/first step to get around a defender or B) Be quick enough/crafty enough to get a guy off via pick&roll. Otherwise they’re just playmaking from the wing, which is a wing’s job.
With that said, Okobo, Brunson and Duval could all be Late first rounders, but only because the lack of depth at PG. Hard to look past the skill of Brunson/the success of skilled point guards that aren’t athletic or big in the NBA right now. He could really bolster a playoff team’s bench. And I think he’s crafty enough to do what someone like D’Angelo Russell does on P&Rs, especially since he’s also so good posting up. And Duval could be a huge asset that might fit better in the NBA thanks to his physical gifts. I’ve never seen someone so athletic and good as passing that doesn’t make it in the NBA. He’d be a good gamble Late first.
To add to this, he’s older and 23 year old players don’t get drafted in the first round, but I’m high on DeVonte Graham. He’s a really underrated passer and the next best after Trae Young IMO. I could see him making an Ish Smith type of impact on a team.
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGsy
- EvanZ
- RealGM
- Posts: 12,732
- And1: 3,220
- Joined: Apr 06, 2011
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGsy
doordoor123 wrote:Shake is no way a point in the NBA. His footspeed just isn’t good enough to get into the lane and he doesn’t have a handle. To be a point in the NBA the #1 requirement is the ability to get into the paint to either dish or finish via at the hoop or via floater. They have to A) have a good enough handle/first step to get around a defender or B) Be quick enough/crafty enough to get a guy off via pick&roll. Otherwise they’re just playmaking from the wing, which is a wing’s job.
In another thread you said Gary Trent is going to be "prime Tim Hardaway". Can you explain how Shake is not a point guard but Gary Trent (who can't handle at all) is "prime Tim Hardaway"?
I was right about 3 point shooting. I expect to be right about Tacko Fall. Some coach will figure out how to use Tacko Fall. This movement towards undersized centers will sweep ng back. Back to the basket scorers will return to the NBA.
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
- Cammo101
- Mr. Mock Draft
- Posts: 30,398
- And1: 1,765
- Joined: Feb 11, 2006
- Location: Austin, TX
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
Khyrie Thomas
Elie Okobo
Trevon Duval
Aaron Holiday
Jalen Brunson
Landry Shamet
Devonte Graham
Tony Carr
Jevon Carter
Keenan Evans
Kerwin Roach
Elie Okobo
Trevon Duval
Aaron Holiday
Jalen Brunson
Landry Shamet
Devonte Graham
Tony Carr
Jevon Carter
Keenan Evans
Kerwin Roach
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGsy
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 4,776
- And1: 1,226
- Joined: Jul 23, 2013
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGsy
EvanZ wrote:doordoor123 wrote:Shake is no way a point in the NBA. His footspeed just isn’t good enough to get into the lane and he doesn’t have a handle. To be a point in the NBA the #1 requirement is the ability to get into the paint to either dish or finish via at the hoop or via floater. They have to A) have a good enough handle/first step to get around a defender or B) Be quick enough/crafty enough to get a guy off via pick&roll. Otherwise they’re just playmaking from the wing, which is a wing’s job.
In another thread you said Gary Trent is going to be "prime Tim Hardaway". Can you explain how Shake is not a point guard but Gary Trent (who can't handle at all) is "prime Tim Hardaway"?
First off, I said in his prime Trent is going to be Hardaway, who was a really similar player in college. Shake is SLOW. He can’t get into the paint. Even around picks he won’t be able to get to the basket because he’s just so slow. I don’t even think he can lose a man off of a pick in the NBA. He’s all pull-ups.
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
-
- Bench Warmer
- Posts: 1,318
- And1: 236
- Joined: Nov 16, 2013
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
Holiday
Brunson
the rest
Brunson
the rest
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
- GimmeDat
- Forum Mod - Bulls
- Posts: 23,915
- And1: 16,880
- Joined: Sep 27, 2013
- Location: Australia
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
Okobo
Shamet
Thomas
Holiday
Brunson
Duval
Roach
Carter
Graham
Carr
Evans
Shamet
Thomas
Holiday
Brunson
Duval
Roach
Carter
Graham
Carr
Evans
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
-
- Assistant Coach
- Posts: 3,959
- And1: 1,749
- Joined: Aug 03, 2012
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
Brunson
Okobo
Carter
Shamet
Holiday
Thomas
Graham
Duval
Roach
Evans
I'd put Shamorie Ponds at least 3rd on this list if he were included (Duval is just a month younger and Okobo is the only one who's less than a year older). I could see a team with multiple first-rounders using a mid-first round pick on Okobo to stash him like the Celtics did with Yabusele.
Okobo
Carter
Shamet
Holiday
Thomas
Graham
Duval
Roach
Evans
I'd put Shamorie Ponds at least 3rd on this list if he were included (Duval is just a month younger and Okobo is the only one who's less than a year older). I could see a team with multiple first-rounders using a mid-first round pick on Okobo to stash him like the Celtics did with Yabusele.
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 15,734
- And1: 3,655
- Joined: Jun 15, 2017
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
clyde21 wrote:Jalen Brunson
Tony Carr
Jevon Carter
Trevon Duval
Keenan Evans
Devonte Graham
Aaron Holiday
Elie Okobo
Kerwin Roach
Landry Shamet
Khyrie Thomas
In which order would draft these guys in?
Okobo Duval Brunson Holiday and Carr could get late first looks. Other PG listed unlikely. Carter would make sense early 2nd if a playoff team bought a pick.
Khyri Thomas is a 2 guard big east dpoy and wont fall past 20 sure he could play some point by committee but is not a floor general.
Shake Milton is a late 1st PG as well
SUNDOWN BRINGS A WELCOME CHANGE TO EVERYTHING THAT'S HIDING
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
-
- Sixth Man
- Posts: 1,636
- And1: 1,727
- Joined: Feb 06, 2018
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
Jevon Carter screams spurs, raptors, lakers type pick
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
-
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,106
- And1: 1,434
- Joined: Nov 28, 2017
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
Okobo is the wildcard prospect. If he blows up during the combine he could rise up a tier below Sexton and Young.
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 4,776
- And1: 1,226
- Joined: Jul 23, 2013
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
sportsyard wrote:Jevon Carter screams spurs, raptors, lakers type pick
Doesn’t scream any of those IMO. Maybe Spurs, but they already have a ton of young point guards. Raptors will mostly always draft on upside and analytics. It’s also hard to see them taking Carter since they have both Wright and VanVleet. And the Lakers are the farthest team from taking Carter. The Lakers last year drafted a bunch of players that are really good at running in transitions and finishing in transition. They also picked guys that can shoot and had potential on defense. Carter is a half-court type of player, he’s a solid shooter but definitely not the type of shooter they need, and the only value he has to them is as a defender, but they’re pretty set at wing defense. Lonzo and Hart are both really good defenders.
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
-
- Forum Mod
- Posts: 35,065
- And1: 64,609
- Joined: Jun 16, 2015
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
Shamet
Duval
Brunson
Brunson and Shamet to me have great chances at being a really good backup PG. Duval has the higher ceiling with his size/athleticism/handle. I can see a team taking Duval late 1st round like the Spurs did with Murray a couple years ago.
Then I got Khyrie Thomas in a group by himself after those guys. Everyone else is behind him and I don't think have a chance going 1st round.
I don't know much about Okobo but from the few videos I've seen, I can see putting him in that first group. He looks like an enticing guy late 1st round. But again this is based off of just a few videos of watching him.
Duval
Brunson
Brunson and Shamet to me have great chances at being a really good backup PG. Duval has the higher ceiling with his size/athleticism/handle. I can see a team taking Duval late 1st round like the Spurs did with Murray a couple years ago.
Then I got Khyrie Thomas in a group by himself after those guys. Everyone else is behind him and I don't think have a chance going 1st round.
I don't know much about Okobo but from the few videos I've seen, I can see putting him in that first group. He looks like an enticing guy late 1st round. But again this is based off of just a few videos of watching him.
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 14,879
- And1: 3,479
- Joined: Feb 11, 2012
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
Half those guys aren't PGs yeah, I was just ranking the guys he provided.
Ponds would be up there to me, same with Carsen Edwards if he stays in this draft
Ponds would be up there to me, same with Carsen Edwards if he stays in this draft
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
-
- Starter
- Posts: 2,207
- And1: 1,163
- Joined: May 14, 2016
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
DeAnthony Melton?
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 12,765
- And1: 11,537
- Joined: May 16, 2011
- Location: Northern Kentucky
Re: Rank these late first - early second PGs
I am surprised Trevon Duval is now considered a 2nd rounder. It may take time but I am convinced will be a good NBA player.
Fire Mazzulla