ImageImageImage

Butler has requested a trade, the saga continues

Moderators: Domejandro, Calinks, Worm Guts

Ethomasp31
Pro Prospect
Posts: 852
And1: 367
Joined: Jul 11, 2014
       

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#961 » by Ethomasp31 » Wed Oct 17, 2018 2:15 pm

Mattya wrote:
Slim Tubby wrote:
shrink wrote:So many bad takes here.

It's frustrating to see people invent things to justify blaming whoever they want.


I respect your opinion as much as any other poster on here but is it really that hard to believe that Taylor didn't want to commit $190M to a player that will be 34 years old at the end of his contract? That's $86M for Wiggy, KAT and Butler alone for 19/20...it's a feasible argument not that any of us would know.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Considering he was willing to pay Shabazz and Gorgui 25+ million for their production and well as expected contracts to Wiggins, KAT, and LaVine, I’m doubting he was pulling cheapskate for the first winner he has had in over a decade. And if this is the case then...


KGdaBom wrote:If we weren't intending to max Jimmy we never should have traded for him. Top 10 players get maxed.


This is the same owner who luckily got turned down by Spree for that ridiculous contract offer. The same owner who always paid KG top dollar.


I agree....Taylor has never been cheap about paying players and would pay Butler the max along with Wiggins and Towns. He wouldn’t have made the trade if he wasn’t willing to do that.
AirP.
RealGM
Posts: 37,484
And1: 32,250
Joined: Nov 21, 2007

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#962 » by AirP. » Wed Oct 17, 2018 2:21 pm

Killboard wrote:This franchise is a dumpster fire. KG can be wrong sometimes, but Taylor doesn't know anything about basketball. How you are OK with your GM holding a disgruntled player asking for a trade just to throw under the bus your own players and risk to no get anything in return?

Taylor is with Thibs on this. They probably planned everything along the way. It's really disgusting. I wouldn't blame Towns if he already decided he is going out as soon as he can. What a joke.


You act as if this had never happened before. The biggest one I remember was Kobe trying to force a trade and was targeting Chicago in 2007, Chicago wouldn't give up Luol Deng so it never happened. Then came the P.Gasol trade and LA won 2 more Championships with Kobe. Oh yeah, their young center Bynum went on to have his first good year the season after Kobe tried to force a trade.

https://www.cbssports.com/nba/news/kobe-bryant-on-2007-trade-request-bulls-were-my-no-1-choice/
Howard Cosell
Rookie
Posts: 1,181
And1: 313
Joined: Jun 01, 2013

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#963 » by Howard Cosell » Wed Oct 17, 2018 2:43 pm

Update:

Source (H)

Twolves have been discussing trade talks with Clippers for the much of the last week. Lots of pieces would need to be included in any trade with Clippers.

If deal is made from today through first week of the NBA season the franchise which could make it happen with Taylor is the Houston Rockets. Gordon & Tucker + FRP would make it happen.

Stay tuned.
Dewey
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,913
And1: 1,078
Joined: May 22, 2001

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#964 » by Dewey » Wed Oct 17, 2018 2:50 pm

AirP. wrote:
Killboard wrote:This franchise is a dumpster fire. KG can be wrong sometimes, but Taylor doesn't know anything about basketball. How you are OK with your GM holding a disgruntled player asking for a trade just to throw under the bus your own players and risk to no get anything in return?

Taylor is with Thibs on this. They probably planned everything along the way. It's really disgusting. I wouldn't blame Towns if he already decided he is going out as soon as he can. What a joke.


You act as if this had never happened before. The biggest one I remember was Kobe trying to force a trade and was targeting Chicago in 2007, Chicago wouldn't give up Luol Deng so it never happened. Then came the P.Gasol trade and LA won 2 more Championships with Kobe. Oh yeah, their young center Bynum went on to have his first good year the season after Kobe tried to force a trade.

https://www.cbssports.com/nba/news/kobe-bryant-on-2007-trade-request-bulls-were-my-no-1-choice/

ya it's like where have people been? Players have been forcing trades for years... thats just the character of some people.
Flip response to Love wanting out, "He has no reason to be upset, you're either a part of the problem or a part of the solution"
User avatar
Killboard
Analyst
Posts: 3,374
And1: 943
Joined: Jul 16, 2010

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#965 » by Killboard » Wed Oct 17, 2018 2:53 pm

AirP. wrote:
Killboard wrote:This franchise is a dumpster fire. KG can be wrong sometimes, but Taylor doesn't know anything about basketball. How you are OK with your GM holding a disgruntled player asking for a trade just to throw under the bus your own players and risk to no get anything in return?

Taylor is with Thibs on this. They probably planned everything along the way. It's really disgusting. I wouldn't blame Towns if he already decided he is going out as soon as he can. What a joke.


You act as if this had never happened before. The biggest one I remember was Kobe trying to force a trade and was targeting Chicago in 2007, Chicago wouldn't give up Luol Deng so it never happened. Then came the P.Gasol trade and LA won 2 more Championships with Kobe. Oh yeah, their young center Bynum went on to have his first good year the season after Kobe tried to force a trade.

https://www.cbssports.com/nba/news/kobe-bryant-on-2007-trade-request-bulls-were-my-no-1-choice/


So Kobe made a national interview in the first practice of the season to say he is better than anyone else and that the other players are lazy and didnt care? We should probably do this as much as we can.

Maybe if I would imply Towns is close to Bynum in stats or professional aproach, or the wolves were closer to the lakers in free agent marketing, who can go out there and get someone of Towns caliber for 5 o 6 seasons, I could see your point or be more calm about it.
Crazy-Canuck
RealGM
Posts: 29,960
And1: 7,975
Joined: Nov 24, 2003

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#966 » by Crazy-Canuck » Wed Oct 17, 2018 2:54 pm

Howard Cosell wrote:Update:

Source (H)

Twolves have been discussing trade talks with Clippers for the much of the last week. Lots of pieces would need to be included in any trade with Clippers.

If deal is made from today through first week of the NBA season the franchise which could make it happen with Taylor is the Houston Rockets. Gordon & Tucker + FRP would make it happen.

Stay tuned.


If you are going to use fake sources to quote yourself, at least have us getting something good.
User avatar
D1SGRUNTL3D
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,104
And1: 2,080
Joined: Jan 23, 2006
Location: Minnesota
   

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#967 » by D1SGRUNTL3D » Wed Oct 17, 2018 3:14 pm

Killboard wrote:Taylor Interviewed:
http://www.startribune.com/glen-taylor-wolves-working-to-trade-butler-thibodeau-s-job-safe/497734421/

Taylor was asked to assess how Tom Thibodeau, the Wolves coach and president of basketball operations, has handled the Butler situation.

“Well, I’m OK with it,” Taylor said. “Initially, when Butler told [Thibodeau] he wanted to leave, you know Tom did everything he could to try to keep Jimmy here and I understand that. They have a close relationship.

“Thibs brought him here so that he would stay here. But eventually I think that in listening to Jimmy, Thibs and I are lined up on this. We need to be looking at a trade



This franchise is a dumpster fire. KG can be wrong sometimes, but Taylor doesn't know anything about basketball. How you are OK with your GM holding a disgruntled player asking for a trade just to throw under the bus your own players and risk to no get anything in return?

Taylor is with Thibs on this. They probably planned everything along the way. It's really disgusting. I wouldn't blame Towns if he already decided he is going out as soon as he can. What a joke.
Maybe because keeping disgruntled player 1 yr is better than taking back terrible contracts that last for 3?
User avatar
Killboard
Analyst
Posts: 3,374
And1: 943
Joined: Jul 16, 2010

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#968 » by Killboard » Wed Oct 17, 2018 3:14 pm

Dewey wrote:
AirP. wrote:
Killboard wrote:This franchise is a dumpster fire. KG can be wrong sometimes, but Taylor doesn't know anything about basketball. How you are OK with your GM holding a disgruntled player asking for a trade just to throw under the bus your own players and risk to no get anything in return?

Taylor is with Thibs on this. They probably planned everything along the way. It's really disgusting. I wouldn't blame Towns if he already decided he is going out as soon as he can. What a joke.


You act as if this had never happened before. The biggest one I remember was Kobe trying to force a trade and was targeting Chicago in 2007, Chicago wouldn't give up Luol Deng so it never happened. Then came the P.Gasol trade and LA won 2 more Championships with Kobe. Oh yeah, their young center Bynum went on to have his first good year the season after Kobe tried to force a trade.

https://www.cbssports.com/nba/news/kobe-bryant-on-2007-trade-request-bulls-were-my-no-1-choice/

ya it's like where have people been? Players have been forcing trades for years... thats just the character of some people.


Force a trade is fine. Throw your team under the bus isnt. A GM who ommits to trade an all star a whole summer isnt. An all star that mounts an interview after his first training of the season to bash his mates isnt. A coach that allows it and endorse it isnt. An owner that is fine with all of this isnt.
User avatar
Killboard
Analyst
Posts: 3,374
And1: 943
Joined: Jul 16, 2010

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#969 » by Killboard » Wed Oct 17, 2018 3:19 pm

D1SGRUNTL3D wrote:
Killboard wrote:Taylor Interviewed:
http://www.startribune.com/glen-taylor-wolves-working-to-trade-butler-thibodeau-s-job-safe/497734421/

Taylor was asked to assess how Tom Thibodeau, the Wolves coach and president of basketball operations, has handled the Butler situation.

“Well, I’m OK with it,” Taylor said. “Initially, when Butler told [Thibodeau] he wanted to leave, you know Tom did everything he could to try to keep Jimmy here and I understand that. They have a close relationship.

“Thibs brought him here so that he would stay here. But eventually I think that in listening to Jimmy, Thibs and I are lined up on this. We need to be looking at a trade



This franchise is a dumpster fire. KG can be wrong sometimes, but Taylor doesn't know anything about basketball. How you are OK with your GM holding a disgruntled player asking for a trade just to throw under the bus your own players and risk to no get anything in return?

Taylor is with Thibs on this. They probably planned everything along the way. It's really disgusting. I wouldn't blame Towns if he already decided he is going out as soon as he can. What a joke.
Maybe because keeping disgruntled player 1 yr is better than taking back terrible contracts that last for 3?



You are missing Thibodeu knew this since May. We now are recieving offers after the whole league has the rosters set and already mesmerized with their rookies, even without mention how Jimmy value cratered after the infamous practice and bashing.

The real problem is we are toying with KAT in the meantime. If he has some sense of decency he is probably thinking about going out right now, even if he is going to be quiet about it for some more time.
KGdaBom
RealGM
Posts: 23,340
And1: 6,375
Joined: Jun 22, 2017
         

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#970 » by KGdaBom » Wed Oct 17, 2018 3:21 pm

wesleyt95 wrote:
minimus wrote:It is better for Jimmy to start this season with MIN with 10-0 record and get traded in a strong team. I still think TOR, PHI can make a decent offer.


Robert Covington + Landry Shamet + 2019 FRP
OR Robert Covington + Dario Saric

Norman Powell + OG Anunoby

Keep an eye out on Shamet's performance, he's a rookie 6-5 athletic combo guard that can shoot

RoCo and Saric are both good still young and on good contracts. That has kind of been my dream deal. Philly got abused by Boston last night. They may be a bit more ready to deal.
minimus
RealGM
Posts: 13,752
And1: 5,241
Joined: Jan 28, 2011
Location: Germany, Stuttgart area
 

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#971 » by minimus » Wed Oct 17, 2018 3:34 pm

KGdaBom wrote:
wesleyt95 wrote:
minimus wrote:It is better for Jimmy to start this season with MIN with 10-0 record and get traded in a strong team. I still think TOR, PHI can make a decent offer.


Robert Covington + Landry Shamet + 2019 FRP
OR Robert Covington + Dario Saric

Norman Powell + OG Anunoby

Keep an eye out on Shamet's performance, he's a rookie 6-5 athletic combo guard that can shoot

RoCo and Saric are both good still young and on good contracts. That has kind of been my dream deal. Philly got abused by Boston last night. They may be a bit more ready to deal.



Maybe PHI is already concerning about Jimmy calling Embiid and Simmons "soft"
AirP.
RealGM
Posts: 37,484
And1: 32,250
Joined: Nov 21, 2007

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#972 » by AirP. » Wed Oct 17, 2018 3:52 pm

Killboard wrote:Force a trade is fine. Throw your team under the bus isnt. A GM who ommits to trade an all star a whole summer isnt. An all star that mounts an interview after his first training of the season to bash his mates isnt. A coach that allows it and endorse it isnt. An owner that is fine with all of this isnt.


Most players don't work as hard as Butler, calling them out on that isn't that bad except both regularly give sub-nba effort on the court but because of their situation with a small market, don't get pulled.

I still wouldn't be surprised if Butler signs an extension next summer with Minnesota. I'm sticking with what I've said all along, Thibs is playing hardball with Butler and Taylor. Taylor doesn't feel comfortable giving up the money to retain Butler and Butler wants the money he feels he won't get in Minnesota. If Minnesota has a strong year (which they could after a rocky start) it will be extremely hard for Taylor not to do what it takes to retain Butler.

Minnesota isn't a FA destination, you have to try to keep and acquire any elite level talent you can get, it's why so many people have been on the Wiggins bandwagon in hopes he becomes that. Adding "good" players around Towns isn't going to help this team be anything but around a .500 team, you have to have top end talent.

If this franchise wants to win, you have to get top end talent, moving Butler is the exact opposite of that and lowers the ceiling of this team, 1 star can't do it alone in the NBA, go ask KG, Kobe, AD, MJ...
User avatar
Killboard
Analyst
Posts: 3,374
And1: 943
Joined: Jul 16, 2010

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#973 » by Killboard » Wed Oct 17, 2018 4:18 pm

DP
User avatar
Killboard
Analyst
Posts: 3,374
And1: 943
Joined: Jul 16, 2010

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#974 » by Killboard » Wed Oct 17, 2018 4:18 pm

AirP. wrote:
Killboard wrote:Force a trade is fine. Throw your team under the bus isnt. A GM who ommits to trade an all star a whole summer isnt. An all star that mounts an interview after his first training of the season to bash his mates isnt. A coach that allows it and endorse it isnt. An owner that is fine with all of this isnt.


Most players don't work as hard as Butler, calling them out on that isn't that bad except both regularly give sub-nba effort on the court but because of their situation with a small market, don't get pulled.


I dont know how to objectively measure hard work. Maybe is talk too loud, to the right reporters or TV networks.
Maybe is about have good metrics in RPM, BPM, WS. If it is the former, Jimmy works really hard and is unparalleled. If it is the latter... well maybe Towns work as hard as him. Or harder at the same age, hell... if you take into account how many assists Butler had to KAT in clutch time for the whole season he maybe cares about winning even more than Butler!


AirP. wrote:I still wouldn't be surprised if Butler signs an extension next summer with Minnesota. I'm sticking with what I've said all along, Thibs is playing hardball with Butler and Taylor. Taylor doesn't feel comfortable giving up the money to retain Butler and Butler wants the money he feels he won't get in Minnesota. If Minnesota has a strong year (which they could after a rocky start) it will be extremely hard for Taylor not to do what it takes to retain Butler.


I dont really care for Butler. He already expressed his will and isnt commited on paper. In the other hand, the asset under control that is as good as Butler has expressed his will to stay here, signed on paper, and most probably sand bagging and alienated with his coach. I would be worried why.

AirP. wrote:Minnesota isn't a FA destination, you have to try to keep and acquire any elite level talent you can get, it's why so many people have been on the Wiggins bandwagon in hopes he becomes that. Adding "good" players around Towns isn't going to help this team be anything but around a .500 team, you have to have top end talent.

Well, you have right about keeping talent. Thats the reason why you dont toy around with 22 YO All NBA player who recently signed for 5 seasons. Maybe we can draft better. Maybe we can develop young players. Good coaches and GM's find a way. Just like Utah after losing Hawyard and Hill last season.

AirP. wrote:If this franchise wants to win, you have to get top end talent, moving Butler is the exact opposite of that and lowers the ceiling of this team, 1 star can't do it alone in the NBA, go ask KG, Kobe, AD, MJ...
Well, moving Butler is something that needs to be done if he is going to bash his teamates. If he does care about winnning he is going to make them compromise and grow. If he dont he is going to alienate them going publicly about being the best dog in the alley and treating the others like rookies.
wesleyt95
Rookie
Posts: 1,158
And1: 277
Joined: Sep 23, 2018
 

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#975 » by wesleyt95 » Wed Oct 17, 2018 4:43 pm

KGdaBom wrote:
wesleyt95 wrote:
minimus wrote:It is better for Jimmy to start this season with MIN with 10-0 record and get traded in a strong team. I still think TOR, PHI can make a decent offer.


Robert Covington + Landry Shamet + 2019 FRP
OR Robert Covington + Dario Saric

Norman Powell + OG Anunoby

Keep an eye out on Shamet's performance, he's a rookie 6-5 athletic combo guard that can shoot

RoCo and Saric are both good still young and on good contracts. That has kind of been my dream deal. Philly got abused by Boston last night. They may be a bit more ready to deal.


Might be the best deal unless KBD does well and proves he's our future starting 4, otherwise RoCo, Shamet + 1st has more upside
AirP.
RealGM
Posts: 37,484
And1: 32,250
Joined: Nov 21, 2007

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#976 » by AirP. » Wed Oct 17, 2018 5:00 pm

Killboard wrote:I dont know how to objectively measure hard work. Maybe is talk too loud, to the right reporters or TV networks.
Maybe is about have good metrics in RPM, BPM, WS. If it is the former, Jimmy works really hard and is unparalleled. If it is the latter... well maybe Towns work as hard as him. Or harder at the same age, hell... if you take into account how many assists Butler had to KAT in clutch time for the whole season he maybe cares about winning even more than Butler!

Just watching the games you can tell who is giving good effort and who isn't.

Killboard wrote:I dont really care for Butler. He already expressed his will and isnt commited on paper. In the other hand, the asset under control that is as good as Butler has expressed his will to stay here, signed on paper, and most probably sand bagging and alienated with his coach. I would be worried why.

I get it, but he's a high level assets that can't really be replaced with 2 good level assets if you have Championship aspirations. Very few teams have won Championships in the modern era without multiple elite level players.

Killboard wrote:Well, you have right about keeping talent. Thats the reason why you dont toy around with 22 YO All NBA player who recently signed for 5 seasons. Maybe we can draft better. Maybe we can develop young players. Good coaches and GM's find a way. Just like Utah after losing Hawyard and Hill last season.

I don't see it that way, I think there's a lot of luck in finding an early gem lower in the draft. Teams that are built on competing and winning can take chances on potential/bust candidates way easier because they can take their time on developing the players vs a bad team whose fan base desperately wants to add a good player quickly to the roster. Look at Butler and K.Leonard, both did very little their first 3 years in the league but worked on their skills and when ready were put in roles to succeed. In Minnesota, if the fanbase was told, you won't see the real Okogie till his 4th year the fans would be going after Thibs not developing his player fast enough. This is also why fans are so big on Wiggins and Towns where as if this had been a good team, fans might say, they' or one of them are not ready to be big contributors yet. It's just a different mindset based off desperation to find good players.

Mitchell is a special type of player, not just because of his athletic ability or skills, but his work ethic and his effort. The kid got hurt in the playoffs and still wanted to go out and compete and help his team. Not sure I've ever seen anything like that on Minnesota's bench except from Butler.

Killboard wrote:Well, moving Butler is something that needs to be done if he is going to bash his teamates. If he does care about winnning he is going to make them compromise and grow. If he dont he is going to alienate them going publicly about being the best dog in the alley and treating the others like rookies.


He bashed his 2 teammates' (weird, only 2 of them also, he's not really said anything about anyone else) because of their effort level, if you think he hadn't been saying that for a while without results behind closed doors before going to the media I don't know what to tell you (I'm pretty sure he's the type of person who would tell them to their face). I kinda believe that both have had it easier being the best players on a bad team and with that, not much pressure to be good or do the best they can. This is one of the things I hoped Thibs would bring to Minnesota, bringing in players with good effort levels, creating an environment about winning and then take some chances in the draft like he did last year with Patton (who without health levels had the ability to be really good for his size/athletic ability).
AirP.
RealGM
Posts: 37,484
And1: 32,250
Joined: Nov 21, 2007

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#977 » by AirP. » Wed Oct 17, 2018 5:24 pm

This should be great for the franchise moving forward, basically Butler saying there are 2 different sets of rules based on who the player is.
Read on Twitter
Klomp
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 69,568
And1: 22,940
Joined: Jul 08, 2005
Contact:
   

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#978 » by Klomp » Wed Oct 17, 2018 5:28 pm

AirP. wrote:Just watching the games you can tell who is giving good effort and who isn't.

I don't totally agree.

Long striders look like they aren't trying as hard as runners with a short stride, since there's less time between feet touching the ground. I actually think that's part of the perception problem with Wiggins. Vikings fans have done the same with Anthony Barr.
tsherkin wrote:The important thing to take away here is that Klomp is wrong.
Esohny wrote:Why are you asking Klomp? "He's" actually a bot that posts random blurbs from a database.
Klomp wrote:I'm putting the tired in retired mod at the moment
wco81
RealGM
Posts: 26,844
And1: 11,466
Joined: Jul 04, 2013
       

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#979 » by wco81 » Wed Oct 17, 2018 5:30 pm

Phoenix already has Booker on a huge extension. They’re going to trade one of their high pick wing on a rookie deal like Jackson to max out a 30 year old Butler?

That could put them over the cap and they haven’t even made the playoffs with their current core.
AirP.
RealGM
Posts: 37,484
And1: 32,250
Joined: Nov 21, 2007

Re: Butler has requested a trade part III Game time 

Post#980 » by AirP. » Wed Oct 17, 2018 5:37 pm

Klomp wrote:
AirP. wrote:Just watching the games you can tell who is giving good effort and who isn't.

I don't totally agree.

Long striders look like they aren't trying as hard as runners with a short stride, since there's less time between feet touching the ground. I actually think that's part of the perception problem with Wiggins. Vikings fans have done the same with Anthony Barr.

I do get what you're saying but I'm not talking about that. It's not perception of speed when other people are getting back faster or a player is just standing still. I'm actually less concerned about Towns' effort vs Wiggins, Towns just seems to end up in the wrong position on defense way too often and most of the time he does, he's not looking for where he should be. I don't know if he just doesn't know where to go (doubtful) or he just forgets/doesn't do it during the games.

This is why I sometimes post pics when I hear a player did good defensively because they had a few good defensive plays but time after time during the game just gave up easy baskets because they weren't trying/giving effort on defense. Wiggins and Towns have the ability to be monsters on the defensive end and are nowhere close to being that consistently enough to gameplan with even though from time to time they show you what they could be.

Return to Minnesota Timberwolves