Chris Paul to Miami
Moderators: Andre Roberstan, HartfordWhalers, BullyKing, Texas Chuck, MoneyTalks41890, Mamba4Goat, pacers33granger, Trader_Joe, loserX
Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Forum Mod
- Posts: 29,647
- And1: 21,052
- Joined: Oct 13, 2009
Chris Paul to Miami
Ok so this is my attempt to split the issues and find something everyone can save face on.
OKC out: CP, Nader, Burton, 2021 MIA 1st, 2023 MIA 1st
MIA out: JJ, Dion, Dragic, Herro
Thunder move on from CP and get a good fit at the SG position next to SGA.
Heat get their picks and flexibility back while sacrificing the most recent pick.
OKC out: CP, Nader, Burton, 2021 MIA 1st, 2023 MIA 1st
MIA out: JJ, Dion, Dragic, Herro
Thunder move on from CP and get a good fit at the SG position next to SGA.
Heat get their picks and flexibility back while sacrificing the most recent pick.
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 4,790
- And1: 1,021
- Joined: Sep 11, 2009
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
MoneyTalks41890 wrote:Ok so this is my attempt to split the issues and find something everyone can save face on.
OKC out: CP, Nader, Burton, 2021 MIA 1st, 2023 MIA 1st
MIA out: JJ, Dion, Dragic, Herro
Thunder move on from CP and get a good fit at the SG position next to SGA.
Heat get their picks and flexibility back while sacrificing the most recent pick.
Way too much from Heat. They are not going to give up any positive value to take back Paul.
EDIT: I guess if they get more positive value back than they value more than Herro they may.
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Senior Mod - NBA Player Comparisons
- Posts: 28,425
- And1: 8,669
- Joined: Aug 14, 2004
- Location: South Florida
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
The trade works as JJ and Dragic for Paul with or without Dion's salary on the trade checker (to my surprise, that's a big salary).
(a) Would either side do it straight up for JJ and Dragic?
(b) Is Dion considered positive value?
(c) How much difference does getting their picks back make to Miami (assuming the Paul deal makes them win more so the picks are worth a bit less)?
I hate to include guys like Herro (and Nader and Burton) because every team overvalues its young guys.
(a) Would either side do it straight up for JJ and Dragic?
(b) Is Dion considered positive value?
(c) How much difference does getting their picks back make to Miami (assuming the Paul deal makes them win more so the picks are worth a bit less)?
I hate to include guys like Herro (and Nader and Burton) because every team overvalues its young guys.
“Most people use statistics like a drunk man uses a lamppost; more for support than illumination,” Andrew Lang.
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 54,996
- And1: 16,197
- Joined: Jun 23, 2001
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
penbeast0 wrote:The trade works as JJ and Dragic for Paul with or without Dion's salary on the trade checker (to my surprise, that's a big salary).
(a) Would either side do it straight up for JJ and Dragic?
(b) Is Dion considered positive value?
(c) How much difference does getting their picks back make to Miami (assuming the Paul deal makes them win more so the picks are worth a bit less)?
I hate to include guys like Herro (and Nader and Burton) because every team overvalues its young guys.
(a) OKC probably would, Miami cannot. Literally, cannot. They have to be below the apron due to the sign and trade with Jimmy Butler.
(b) No, not by anyone.
(c) It's the difference.
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Forum Mod
- Posts: 29,647
- And1: 21,052
- Joined: Oct 13, 2009
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
BBallFreak wrote:penbeast0 wrote:The trade works as JJ and Dragic for Paul with or without Dion's salary on the trade checker (to my surprise, that's a big salary).
(a) Would either side do it straight up for JJ and Dragic?
(b) Is Dion considered positive value?
(c) How much difference does getting their picks back make to Miami (assuming the Paul deal makes them win more so the picks are worth a bit less)?
I hate to include guys like Herro (and Nader and Burton) because every team overvalues its young guys.
(a) OKC probably would, Miami cannot. Literally, cannot. They have to be below the apron due to the sign and trade with Jimmy Butler.
(b) No, not by anyone.
(c) It's the difference.
Unsurprisingly Miami continues to leak and play in the media while OKC doesnt. If Miami had no interest they would stay quiet. They do, so they aren’t. You’ve gotta see that
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 54,996
- And1: 16,197
- Joined: Jun 23, 2001
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
Not even close. You've got to see that no one actually wants Paul - not even you guys.
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Forum Mod
- Posts: 29,647
- And1: 21,052
- Joined: Oct 13, 2009
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
BBallFreak wrote:Not even close. You've got to see that no one actually wants Paul - not even you guys.
So what do you make of the MIA posturing? Genuinely curious
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Forum Mod - Pacers
- Posts: 15,072
- And1: 6,584
- Joined: Sep 26, 2006
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
I think it's more the Heat want their picks back and can get a good, but massively overpaid player back more than them wanting Paul. He's probably the worst 2nd star fit for a Butler led team and Riley knows that.
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Forum Mod
- Posts: 29,647
- And1: 21,052
- Joined: Oct 13, 2009
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
pacers33granger wrote:I think it's more the Heat want their picks back and can get a good, but massively overpaid player back more than them wanting Paul. He's probably the worst 2nd star fit for a Butler led team and Riley knows that.
Who do they possibly have a shot at? Butler is 30 next year, 31 for FA?
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 54,996
- And1: 16,197
- Joined: Jun 23, 2001
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
I don't think it's posturing. I think they genuinely don't care about Paul.MoneyTalks41890 wrote:BBallFreak wrote:Not even close. You've got to see that no one actually wants Paul - not even you guys.
So what do you make of the MIA posturing? Genuinely curious
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Forum Mod - Pacers
- Posts: 15,072
- And1: 6,584
- Joined: Sep 26, 2006
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
MoneyTalks41890 wrote:pacers33granger wrote:I think it's more the Heat want their picks back and can get a good, but massively overpaid player back more than them wanting Paul. He's probably the worst 2nd star fit for a Butler led team and Riley knows that.
Who do they possibly have a shot at? Butler is 30 next year, 31 for FA?
For me at least Butler and no one else would be preferable to Butler and Paul (at his salary at least). Maybe there's a chance the two don't have issues, but I would doubt it honestly and Butler clearly wanted to be the guy since he turned down more money from a contender. Could very easily be a poor man's version of Houston with the same problem of having that massive deal on the books and less ability to move it.
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 54,996
- And1: 16,197
- Joined: Jun 23, 2001
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
Who thought Paul George and Russell Westbrook were going to shake free? We don't know yet, but it's smarter to be lean and ready then take on bloated stupidity, while sacrificing assets you should be getting in order to do it.MoneyTalks41890 wrote:pacers33granger wrote:I think it's more the Heat want their picks back and can get a good, but massively overpaid player back more than them wanting Paul. He's probably the worst 2nd star fit for a Butler led team and Riley knows that.
Who do they possibly have a shot at? Butler is 30 next year, 31 for FA?
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Forum Mod
- Posts: 29,647
- And1: 21,052
- Joined: Oct 13, 2009
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
pacers33granger wrote:MoneyTalks41890 wrote:pacers33granger wrote:I think it's more the Heat want their picks back and can get a good, but massively overpaid player back more than them wanting Paul. He's probably the worst 2nd star fit for a Butler led team and Riley knows that.
Who do they possibly have a shot at? Butler is 30 next year, 31 for FA?
For me at least Butler and no one else would be preferable to Butler and Paul (at his salary at least). Maybe there's a chance the two don't have issues, but I would doubt it honestly and Butler clearly wanted to be the guy since he turned down more money from a contender. Could very easily be a poor man's version of Houston with the same problem of having that massive deal on the books and less ability to move it.
Well without Paul that’s an 8 seed at best with CP they are more like a top 4 seed. So that’s up to butler I guess
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Forum Mod
- Posts: 29,647
- And1: 21,052
- Joined: Oct 13, 2009
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
BBallFreak wrote:Who thought Paul George and Russell Westbrook were going to shake free? We don't know yet, but it's smarter to be lean and ready then take on bloated stupidity, while sacrificing assets you should be getting in order to do it.MoneyTalks41890 wrote:pacers33granger wrote:I think it's more the Heat want their picks back and can get a good, but massively overpaid player back more than them wanting Paul. He's probably the worst 2nd star fit for a Butler led team and Riley knows that.
Who do they possibly have a shot at? Butler is 30 next year, 31 for FA?
Problem is you don’t have the assets for either. So doesn’t really matter who shakes loose. We have your picks.
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 54,996
- And1: 16,197
- Joined: Jun 23, 2001
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
I'm sorry, we don't have Bam, Herro, Winslow, and $30 million in expiring contracts?MoneyTalks41890 wrote:BBallFreak wrote:Who thought Paul George and Russell Westbrook were going to shake free? We don't know yet, but it's smarter to be lean and ready then take on bloated stupidity, while sacrificing assets you should be getting in order to do it.MoneyTalks41890 wrote:
Who do they possibly have a shot at? Butler is 30 next year, 31 for FA?
Problem is you don’t have the assets for either. So doesn’t really matter who shakes loose. We have your picks.
Don't try to strongarm is into taking your bad contract. Keep him if you'd like, but keep him away from us...
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Forum Mod
- Posts: 29,647
- And1: 21,052
- Joined: Oct 13, 2009
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
BBallFreak wrote:I'm sorry, we don't have Bam, Herro, Winslow, and $30 million in expiring contracts?MoneyTalks41890 wrote:BBallFreak wrote:Who thought Paul George and Russell Westbrook were going to shake free? We don't know yet, but it's smarter to be lean and ready then take on bloated stupidity, while sacrificing assets you should be getting in order to do it.
Problem is you don’t have the assets for either. So doesn’t really matter who shakes loose. We have your picks.
You know I’m not in the business of undervaluing those guys, but you have a slim chance of adding someone with the present potential of Paul without any picks.
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 54,996
- And1: 16,197
- Joined: Jun 23, 2001
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
Quite frankly, your evaluation process is your own and I don't really care about it. Chris Paul is a bad move for the Miami franchise without our picks coming back to us. Good luck finding someone else to take him!MoneyTalks41890 wrote:BBallFreak wrote:I'm sorry, we don't have Bam, Herro, Winslow, and $30 million in expiring contracts?MoneyTalks41890 wrote:
Problem is you don’t have the assets for either. So doesn’t really matter who shakes loose. We have your picks.
You know I’m not in the business of undervaluing those guys, but you have a slim chance of adding someone with the present potential of Paul without any picks.
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Forum Mod - Pacers
- Posts: 15,072
- And1: 6,584
- Joined: Sep 26, 2006
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
MoneyTalks41890 wrote:pacers33granger wrote:MoneyTalks41890 wrote:
Who do they possibly have a shot at? Butler is 30 next year, 31 for FA?
For me at least Butler and no one else would be preferable to Butler and Paul (at his salary at least). Maybe there's a chance the two don't have issues, but I would doubt it honestly and Butler clearly wanted to be the guy since he turned down more money from a contender. Could very easily be a poor man's version of Houston with the same problem of having that massive deal on the books and less ability to move it.
Well without Paul that’s an 8 seed at best with CP they are more like a top 4 seed. So that’s up to butler I guess
I get it, he's the only available star level guy out there right now and comes at a negative or neutral valuation so it's a chance to score some on court value. I'd hesitate to say a CP/Butler led team gets homecourt in the playoffs though. Certainly would be a higher seed than not having Paul, but I'm not sure that's a 2nd round team.
But being completely honest, I personally dislike Paul the person and have always thought Paul the player, though great, is overrated. Maybe he would elevate the team to a new level, but Houston thought that too.
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Forum Mod
- Posts: 29,647
- And1: 21,052
- Joined: Oct 13, 2009
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
BBallFreak wrote:Quite frankly, your evaluation process is your own and I don't really care about it. Chris Paul is a bad move for the Miami franchise without our picks coming back to us. Good luck finding someone else to take him!MoneyTalks41890 wrote:BBallFreak wrote:I'm sorry, we don't have Bam, Herro, Winslow, and $30 million in expiring contracts?
You know I’m not in the business of undervaluing those guys, but you have a slim chance of adding someone with the present potential of Paul without any picks.
I look forward to us reconciling this dispute once Miami trades for him.
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
-
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 54,996
- And1: 16,197
- Joined: Jun 23, 2001
Re: Chris Paul to Miami
I look forward to you guys being saddled with him for the foreseeable future, or giving us our picks back.MoneyTalks41890 wrote:BBallFreak wrote:Quite frankly, your evaluation process is your own and I don't really care about it. Chris Paul is a bad move for the Miami franchise without our picks coming back to us. Good luck finding someone else to take him!MoneyTalks41890 wrote:
You know I’m not in the business of undervaluing those guys, but you have a slim chance of adding someone with the present potential of Paul without any picks.
I look forward to us reconciling this dispute once Miami trades for him.
Return to Trades and Transactions