karch34 wrote:Mattya wrote:karch34 wrote:I think the biggest issue for Wiseman is that there's 3 college games to draw assumptions from. I think it could be a brilliant pick that could allow us to go smaller at the wing than we'd maybe try otherwise or it's another big taken at the top that doesn't work out. Ceiling is high and floor is low for the top 3 in my mind and the concern.
You think Wiseman’s floor is low? He has the highest floor in the draft if you ask me and probably not particularly close even in the top 3.
3 games of 20 and 10 against week competition doesn't tell me much. High school reports are bigger and more athletic vs competition might be reason for hype before season so hard to go by. Lack of tape a concern.
Do I think at worst he can be an above average and potentially elite rim defender and a poor man's Capella? Without a doubt. Do I hate idea of him at 1? No. Great fit potential? Yes.
I'm just saying with #1 overall at crucial point for franchise that I'm not without concerns and trade down for proven production/defined role with shot at nitger player with at least one defined skill set at lower cost gives me more comfort. Might not be the right path but I see the argument.
Wiseman is a glass half full or half empty discussion and talent evaluation.
Zion was the most hyped NBA draft prospect and outlier of any #1 overall value since Davis or maybe even James. Does everyone know Zion was ranked 5th in his class coming out of high school (espn had him 3rd).
Wiseman was a unanimous #1 recruit in his high school class by all legitimate rankings.
You can also find early 2019 NBA draft mocks in which Zion is not top 3. BR had one where he was not top 10.
I am not saying Wiseman is same NBA draft prospect as Zion, or that high school rankings prove anything in direct correlation to NBA draft slotting.
But imagine if Wiseman plays more than 3 games. Does his freak size and athletic abilities, prove he is more than just that (in Zion’s parallel more than a YouTube jumper)? Does Wiseman trend upwards in NBA draft hype, starting from a even more hyped launch point than outlier Zion? So Wiseman glass half full.
But Wiseman didn’t. He played 3 games. 3 games that leave scouts, talking heads, fans, NBA executives guessing if Wiseman would trend down as a hyped NBA draft prospect. Could he be just a really tall guy with freak abilities (just a leaper in Zion’s parallel)? Would Wiseman be like many other #1 high school top recruits and sink in hype based on NCAA play? So Wiseman glass half empty.