Phil can GTFO now (he's wiling to deal KP) part II

poeman · Post #1041 » by **poeman** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:26 pm

For those that want to see JD & The Straight Shot aka Jim Dolan perform in the city tonight

http://www.citywinery.com/newyork/jd-the-straight-shot-6-22.html

Post #1042 » by **GONYK** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:27 pm

frogfood wrote:
GONYK wrote:
Honestly asking. At what point does it make sense to see what you can get for him?

Could Phil have handled Anthony better? Absolutely. But I'm referring to the quotes he gave in articles. I don't have any issue with Phil saying that if Melo wants to win, he should seek a trade, since we will be rebuilding.

That is a fair statement to me.

Yes, maybe in a vacuum but in reality, Melo didn't take it well at ALL. Come on.

Yes, but does someone taking offense to a statement make the statement innately offensive?

I'm honestly asking you, is what Phil said inherently unfair? Regardless of how Melo received it.

NOOB77 · Post #1043 » by **NOOB77** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:27 pm

shtolky wrote:
NYKfan77 wrote:
Sark wrote:

Read on Twitter

So true.

Yes becuase Okafor and Russell are just as good as KP great comparison random knick dude.

Is Towns being shopped? How about Gannis ?? Are they being shopped?

KP is not being shopped...if the Pelicans call Minny and offer Davis and a pick for Towns, is he being shopped because they picked up the phone?

KP is being shopped it is clear they are having back and forth discussions and we have set a price on KP that is being shopped because he has a price tag.

frogfood · Post #1044 » by **frogfood** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:27 pm

Rotten Apple wrote:
reload141 wrote:Surely you guys won't trade him. Surely Dolan would step in and end this nonsense?

Dolan has a gig tonight. Pretty sure he's at sound check.

Is he gonna sing his Trayvon Martin song? lol.

pylb · Post #1045 » by **pylb** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:28 pm

reload141 wrote:Surely you guys won't trade him. Surely Dolan would step in and end this nonsense?

Are you suggesting Knicks fans should rest their hopes on Dolan?

frogfood · Post #1046 » by **frogfood** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:28 pm

GONYK wrote:
frogfood wrote:
GONYK wrote:
Honestly asking. At what point does it make sense to see what you can get for him?

Could Phil have handled Anthony better? Absolutely. But I'm referring to the quotes he gave in articles. I don't have any issue with Phil saying that if Melo wants to win, he should seek a trade, since we will be rebuilding.

That is a fair statement to me.

Yes, maybe in a vacuum but in reality, Melo didn't take it well at ALL. Come on.

Yes, but does someone taking offense to a statement make the statement innately offensive?

I'm honestly asking you, is what Phil said inherently unfair? Regardless of how Melo received it.

That's exactly it actually. It's called reading the room.

Post #1047 » by **GONYK** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:28 pm

frogfood wrote:
Sark wrote:
god shammgod wrote:
one of those guys was actually traded. the other it's well known they would like to trade. so what does that tell you ?

p.s. the other 2 are disappointments

If Thibadeau took calls on Karl Towns, would you say "FIRE HIM NOW" or would you say "see what you can get"?

Give me your honest answer.

Dude...that hasn't happened. And guess why?

Probably because Towns attended his meetings and answered his phone calls.

reload141 · Post #1048 » by **reload141** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:29 pm

pylb wrote:
reload141 wrote:Surely you guys won't trade him. Surely Dolan would step in and end this nonsense?

Are you suggesting Knicks fans should rest their hopes on Dolan?

At the moment who is crazier, Dolan or Phil?

Traveyknicks23 · Post #1049 » by **Traveyknicks23** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:29 pm

GONYK wrote:
frogfood wrote:
Sark wrote:

If Thibadeau took calls on Karl Towns, would you say "FIRE HIM NOW" or would you say "see what you can get"?

Give me your honest answer.

Dude...that hasn't happened. And guess why?

Probably because Towns attended his meetings and answered his phone calls.

They side stepped that question :lol:

thebuzzardman · Post #1050 » by **thebuzzardman** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:29 pm

Dkillanyk4lyf wrote:

Read on Twitter

Well, they didn't complete a deal in time for the TV special. Must mean it's a no go. :noway:

frogfood · Post #1051 » by **frogfood** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:29 pm

shtolky wrote:
NYKfan77 wrote:
Sark wrote:

Read on Twitter

So true.

Yes becuase Okafor and Russell are just as good as KP great comparison random knick dude.

Is Towns being shopped? How about Gannis ?? Are they being shopped?

KP is not being shopped...if the Pelicans call Minny and offer Davis and a pick for Towns, is he being shopped because they picked up the phone?

Phil is not just picking up the phone.

Rotten Apple · Post #1052 » by **Rotten Apple** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:29 pm

frogfood wrote:
Rotten Apple wrote:
reload141 wrote:Surely you guys won't trade him. Surely Dolan would step in and end this nonsense?

Dolan has a gig tonight. Pretty sure he's at sound check.

Is he gonna sing his Trayvon Martin song? lol.

I hope not :lol:

Post #1053 » by **GONYK** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:29 pm

frogfood wrote:
GONYK wrote:
frogfood wrote:
Yes, maybe in a vacuum but in reality, Melo didn't take it well at ALL. Come on.

Yes, but does someone taking offense to a statement make the statement innately offensive?

I'm honestly asking you, is what Phil said inherently unfair? Regardless of how Melo received it.

That's exactly it actually. It's called reading the room.

Is Phil's responsibility to the Knicks or to Carmelo Anthony.

If Melo wants to win now, and Phil wants to rebuild, then what is the right way to address it?

CrazyKnicks · Post #1054 » by **CrazyKnicks** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:29 pm

I Boston meets our asking price, then I would be happy with a deal. My only concern is how do we start a rebuild by trading KP but keep Melo? Makes no sense, Melo has to go also and probably before KP does.

shtolky · Post #1055 » by **shtolky** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:30 pm

NYKfan77 wrote:
shtolky wrote:
NYKfan77 wrote:

Yes becuase Okafor and Russell are just as good as KP great comparison random knick dude.

Is Towns being shopped? How about Gannis ?? Are they being shopped?

KP is not being shopped...if the Pelicans call Minny and offer Davis and a pick for Towns, is he being shopped because they picked up the phone?

KP is being shopped it is clear they are having back and forth discussions and we have set a price on KP that is being shopped because he has a price tag.

You have no idea what's going on. All we have heard is that we've been taking calls from other teams. That's not shopping in my opinion. Semantics, whatever. Phil is doing nothing wrong in doing what is best for the team.

Rotten Apple · Post #1056 » by **Rotten Apple** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:30 pm

CrazyKnicks wrote:I Boston meets our asking price, then I would be happy with a deal. My only concern is how do we start a rebuild by trading KP but keep Melo? Makes no sense, Melo has to go also and probably before KP does.

NO TRADE CLAUSE.

shtolky · Post #1057 » by **shtolky** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:31 pm

frogfood wrote:
shtolky wrote:
NYKfan77 wrote:

Yes becuase Okafor and Russell are just as good as KP great comparison random knick dude.

Is Towns being shopped? How about Gannis ?? Are they being shopped?

KP is not being shopped...if the Pelicans call Minny and offer Davis and a pick for Towns, is he being shopped because they picked up the phone?

Phil is not just picking up the phone.

You sure do know a lot of stuff. Thibs has never received a call for Towns. Bucks have never received a call for Giannis. A trade won't happen. Pretty amazing that you know all this stuff.

Knicksrule2k4 · Post #1058 » by **Knicksrule2k4** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:31 pm

We should all go to one of Dolan's gigs and protest the state of the Knicks lol

Traveyknicks23 · Post #1059 » by **Traveyknicks23** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:32 pm

If melo wants to stay what's the issue?

Shoryuken · Post #1060 » by **Shoryuken** » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:32 pm

msg channel is giving a knicks top rookie performance and its kristaps lol