I've been staying out of this thread because I wanted to try something different (and insane) this year. I've always wondered how much of my rankings in the past has just been a result of the feedback loop using already ordered lists and filtering it myself. So this year I grabbed a top 50 list, sorted it alphabetically and then ranked every player myself without having any idea what their consensus ranking was by the draft experts and talking heads. This is especially easy for me because I don't pay a ton of attention to college basketball outside of the tournament, so while I recognized some of the names I still had no idea where they were expected to fall (Hey, Johnny Juzang. I remember him being talked about in the tournament! Does that mean he's projected to be a high pick? Turns out...no).
I knew this was going to result in a ton of hot takes that look extremely foolish in hindsight, and it did. But to my surprise my top 5 ended up being what seems to be the consensus (The one exception to my "knew nothing" rule was Chet Holmgren. It ended up being impossible to not hear his name come up as a lottery pick).
Full list below for those interested, but here are some highlights of those I massively overrated, underrated, and ended up more or less the same spot on the rankings I looked at afterwards. Number in parentheses denotes how much higher or lower I ranked them compared to the consensus mocks I looked at.
Top 5 I most overrated: Jabari Walker (+35), Wendell Moore (+21), Dalen Terry (+18), Bryce McGowens (+18), Iverson Molinar (+18).
Top 5 most underrated: Ousmane Dieng (-34), Tari Eason (-27), Jeremy Sochan (-26), Ochai Agbaji (-20), Jaylin Williams (-20)
Top 5 closest rankings in first round: Blake Wesley (0.17), Kennedy Chandler (0.67), Christian Braun (1), Jaden Hardy (1), TyTy Washington (1.29)
Thank you for listening to my Ted Talk. My full ranking:
1. Jaden Ivey
2. Shaedon Sharpe
3. Chet Holmgren
4. Jabari Smith
5. Paolo Banchero
6. Bennedict Mathurin
7. Mark Williams
8. Dalen Terry
9. Dyson Daniels
10. EJ Liddell
11. Ryan Rollins
12. AJ Griffin
13. Wendell Moore
14. Bryce McGowens
15. TyTy Washington
16. Trevor Keels
17. Nikola Jovic
18. Jabari Walker
19. Blake Wesley
20. Jalen Duren
21. Keegan Murray
22. Kennedy Chandler
23. Jaden Hardy
24. Malaki Branham
25. Christian Braun
26. Jalen Williams
27. Kendall Brown
28. Johnny Davis
29. Patrick Baldwin
30. Caleb Houstan
31. Walker Kessler
32. Iverson Molinar
33. Jamaree Bouyea
34. Aminu Mohammed
35. Ochai Agbaji
36. Ibou Dianko
37. Jaylin Williams
38. Jeremy Sochan
39. Josh Minott
40. MarJon Beauchamp
41. Hugo Besson
42. Jean Montero
43. Tari Eason
44. Johnny Juzang
45. John Butler
46. Max Christie
47. Orlando Robinson
48. Ismael Kamagate
49. Ousmane Dieng
Note: This list only goes to 49 because Leonard Miller pulled out (hehehe)