payitforward wrote:nate33 wrote:I kinda like the guys we're looking at: Okongwu, Halliburton and Vassell, better than the guys at the top of the draft: Ball, Edwards, Wiseman.
It's an interesting draft that way, isn't it? Theoretically, value for pick position should remain constant. Personally, I don't think that's true very often, but this year it really seems radical; value for pick position seems to get better & better as you head down the pick positions (up to a point, obviously).
Agreed... there are plenty of reasons for this, but I think the most obvious one is archetype. I was talking to a friend of mine about a year ago who did some scouting and he said, "Unless the player is a generational talent that changes the way the game is played, prospects are bucketed into archetypes. And if that archetype doesnt exist or has shown high failure rates... warning signs are noted."
The easiest archetype is starts with with defense. Can you defend multiple positions well, or one position at an elite level?
The 2nd is off-ball. Can you score points without having plays drawn up/ball pounding? Do you garner ORBs and easy buckets?
Its clear the the players in the 8-15 range settle perfectly into this. Okongwu, Vassell, Haliburton, Okoro, Achuiwa, Nesmith
OTOH, the hardest archetype is the ball centric guard with poor/questionable defense. Because unless you are Harden, Curry, Kyrie, Gil, etc. you become stuck in no mans land of not good enough to lead a team, but unable to fill any other role. See DLO & Lavine.
And even those Elite players I mentioned have a major issue, which is, even with their production does their play style mitigate that of their teammates due to ball watching(Harden?)? Do they get frustrated and "Low energy" over the course of a year by standing around the 3 point line?
Ball, Edwards, Killian Hayes... None of them project to be good defenders, none of them move well without the ball, and none show to be proficient off the C&S. So if they become some high usage lead guard with a 54% TS and bad defense... they go from Lotto pick with All-Star ceiling to 6th man/ out of the league REAL quick. Fultz, Monk, DSJ, Brandon Jennings, Mudiay, Exum, Waiters, Rivers, etc.
My question in the draft is, what Jr/Sr. PG ends up the Brunson, Milton, Graham, Brogdan 2nd round pick?
Winston, Flynn, Riller, and Pritchard look to be the guys to keep an eye on.