76ciology wrote:jamaalstar21 wrote:76ciology wrote:Long term, I think Raps should replace both GTJ and FVV if they really want to be switchable on defense.
So you want them to eliminate guards entirely (as well as their 2 best shooters)? As far as switchable guards go, those 2 rate very highly. Trent is 6'6" (shoes) with a 6'9" wingspan. Fred is very stout against most matchups. Obviously forwards are inherently more switchable due to size, but a team needs to be able to do more than just switch on defense.
Even with Barnes out, this is arguably the most switchable team of all-time. They don't need to become more switchable, they need to shore up their primary weaknesses: rim pressure, backline defense, size at center, and shooting. I think the Raps knew all season they were short 1 rotation guard and 1 center. They chased centers hard at the trade deadline (Poetl, Nerlens Noel, Porzingis) before they settled for Thadd.
The Raps hoped they could fluster Embiid enough with their switching defense, but evidently clearly underestimated him. Even if they were even more switchable, it wouldn't have helped with this matchup. It's too important with Embiid to have at least 1 primary defender who can bother him. I bet the Raps continue their chase for a workable center this offseason. It's been their biggest problem since Gasol left.
Look how much better Raps played without FVV.
If Raps can replace FVV and GTJ with guys with size and can switch, they can win the Siakam vs your top scorer battle with their defense helping Raps wins the points per possession exchange. Its not that they’re missing a lot with FVV and GTJ, specially if you can replace them with guys who can space the floor for Siakam or a more developed Barnes to attack.
Siakam (and eventually Barnes) aren’t so skilled but you can always hunt the weak/small defender where they can score high points per possession against on ISO.
Not totally the same, but its similar to what Celts has built with a heavy wing roster that has the secret sauce on how to play elite defense with how the game is being called.
Thats just my opinion and you know better for you have watched more raps game than me so i can be wrong.
Dont get me wrong, I'm all for the premise of replacing small guards with wings. I also fully agree that the Raptors can fully cede primary ball handling responsibilities to Siakam/Barnes. But with the Raps already fairly thin on shooting, replacing their 2 most potent shooters (fvv+gtj) sounds like a tall order. 6'7+ dudes who with strong outside shooting and better defense than Trent and Fred sounds like an unrealistic dream. GTJ is a good fit there. He's switchable across 3 positions and very disruptive. Fred has been hurt for months (and it seems to be getting worse) but during his healthy first half, he was absolutely blowing up pick & rolls and rarely looking over matched. I agree that Fred is hurting them right now, and if they had someone on the roster to take his minutes, I'd advocate for it (if Barnes is healthy we might see it more, and this team needs more Thadd).
If Siakam is your main scorer.. it's not great but it can be workable if you have better conditions around him. I agree that they don't
need guards (or small ball handlers), but they really need more shooting. I like Siakam/Barnes/OG playing mismatch bully ball, but that only works if they have space to do that. Otherwise you have a Lakers situation where you most talented lineups have no space to run their preferred actions (lebron postup, AD/Bron pick & roll). What the Raptors lack most is a primary rim protector (they have like 3-4 secondary/tertiary rim protectors but no one to truly hold it down and turn this top 10 defense into a top 5 defense), and a good source of rim pressure (Siakam can only play bully ball against a good matchup, so take that away and the Raps offense becomes somewhat punchless even though they are scrappy and intelligent).
But hey if the Raps can find or develop 2 more shooting wings, then good for them. I will be curious to see if Dalano Banton and Justin Champagnie can become good shooters.