EvanZ wrote:The-Power wrote:EvanZ wrote:Philon won't be a good defender. Guys like him never are.
None of these point guards will be "good" defenders if they are high usage. That's just not reality. The best you can hope for is basically Stephen Curry on defense.
What do you mean by ‘guys like him’? Is it simply about his size or about more than just that?
It's mostly skinny high usage guards are never good defenders.
Or really any high usage point guards. They just exert way too much energy on offense to be good on the other end. Pretty much without exception.
Jrue Holiday, Cade Cunningham, Dennis Schroder, Amen Thompson, Chris Paul, Russell Westbrook, Fred VanVleet, Kyle Lowry, Mike Conley, Jason Kidd, Stephon Castle, Immanuel Quickley, the current MVP Shai Gilgeous-Alexander? All these guys had usage rates above 20%, most above 25%, several above 30%.
Stephen Curry can never be the "best you can hope for" on defense.
EvanZ wrote:FarBeyondDriven wrote:EvanZ wrote:Philon won't be a good defender. Guys like him never are.
None of these point guards will be "good" defenders if they are high usage. That's just not reality. The best you can hope for is basically Stephen Curry on defense.
Peterson will be an elite defender. Flemings should be well above average for the position as well due to his quickness.
There's zero chance Peterson will be an elite defender and have anywhere near 30% usage. That just isn't a thing that happens in the NBA.
It does though, and those people who can do it usually become types of superstars, like Kobe Bryant, Michael Jordan (both of whom have extremely similar physical proportions to Peterson), and Dwyane Wade did.
Peterson is mocked as the #1 pick right now in what is supposed to be one of the strongest drafts ever, so it makes sense to see potential in him to break the mold the same way these greats did. The type of potential and raw talent to have the capability of this is why, even though he hasn't yet played 5 full games, he's seen as being above Boozer and Dybantsa.
People would probably be disappointed if Peterson only ever became as good as Jrue Holiday. That's more of a goal for the Kingston Flemingses and Darius Acuffs of the world. Darryn is going to be aiming for the stars.