ImageImageImageImageImage

The truth about FVV

Moderators: DG88, niQ, Duffman100, tsherkin, Reeko, lebron stopper, HiJiNX, 7 Footer, Morris_Shatford

Danny1616
General Manager
Posts: 9,690
And1: 12,725
Joined: May 26, 2007

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#221 » by Danny1616 » Fri Nov 12, 2021 10:17 pm

sidsid wrote:
Danny1616 wrote:
sidsid wrote:
The bigger problem is the expectations of the transition over from Lowry to Fred. The org has positioned it as some sort passing of the torch, which might apply to giving a good quote, but is nothing of the sort on the court.

There are 2 old hall of fame undersized PGs currently playing in this league who can manage an offense like no other. They understand the game on another level. Meanwhile, former MVP and walking triple double Westbrook has been passed around like a bad contract for years now and is currently killing the Lakers.

If what they did was easy, everyone would be doing it because there is nothing special about them physically outside of Kyle's enormous ass.

Fred is a combo guard who's strengths are mainly off-ball with a coach, and understandable offseason circumstances, forcing him into a bigger role that automatically limits the ceiling of a team on the offensive end.

He's never going to be Lowry. Our team's strengths right now are defense, turnovers and offensive rebounding to compensate for our limited ceiling in other offensive areas. That's baked in. Fred making a few more jump shots or nailing an extra drive and kick pass isn't going to change that fundamental problem. Possessions died in Ibaka's hands while they zipped around in Gasol's. No amount of complaining was going to change their skillsets.

The avenues to change that, in the near term, are also limited. Expecting a full systemic change to take advantage of some faster than expected development from Barnes and OG just doesn't usually happen in the middle of the regular season (if there's a window, it's the all star break, but even then). Courtside mentioned it in another thread, but what you're more likely to see is just adding some different sets to the offense as the season rolls along.

So, what you have to make due with this year is mostly individual improvement.

What you can get mad at, is FVV, the player playing the most minutes in the entire league, playing insane minutes on a back to back against Philly, a team who *checks notes* is missing its 2 best players while our sophomore PG picks up another DNP-CD in what *checks notes again* is supposed to be a development season. You can get mad at that because those things are entirely controllable and not baked in based on other structural limitations.


Your analysis may turn out to be correct, but we have no idea yet.

But at age 27, Fred and Kyle are actually pretty close in terms of production. Kyle didn't come to our team as a finished product, he made improvements every year.

Last year, Fred was 12th in the league in RPM and ahead of Lowry. We always praised Lowry for being an advanced stat guru, but Fred also has great advanced stats now. Like Lowry, Fred doesn't have to be great offensively to impact the game. He's a great on ball defender.

You are assuming that the team is passing the torch for the sake of it, but they wouldn't be passing the torch if they didn't think Fred was the right guy for that role.

It's literally his first month as a full time starting point guard not sharing the backcourt with Lowry. He's averaging 20, 7 and 5 on good shooting splits and great on ball defense. The team is 7-6. Why don't we give him a chance to show what he can over the course of a full season instead of coming to conclusions that he's some sort of finished product without the talent to become that guy.


And here's a prime example of why expectations are out of whack.

Westbrook had analytics that put him right up there with Curry and CP3. His assist numbers are great. At no point in his career has Westbrook ever been a PG who made his teammates better like Lowry can. Westbrook is a freak athlete with talent who got stats through shear force of will.

There isn't a stat for "Ibaka's been hustling on D for a while and hasn't touched the ball yet so I'm gonna feed him to make sure he stays motivated" to show what the greats do.

Fred is a guy who, even in a stretch of his worst basketball ever in the Philly series, still found time to *look off Kawhi* who was demanding the ball so he could go on another Ill advised drive to the hoop.

Lowry's career has been famously riddled with being stuck behind other players and under utilized until he finally broke out as soon as someone gave him usage and a team.

Fred has not had that problem. He's had prime minutes in every conceivable role. Lead of the bench mob offense. First sub off the bench for prime minutes with a championship lineup. Lead of the bench (non-mob offense). Prime starter minutes next to a hall of fame PG, even though it was undersized. Top ten minutes in the league starter. Lead guard playing *the most minutes in the league*.

I can't even conceive of better circumstances for a player to thrive and show you what he could do. If he had it in him, we'd have seen it by now.

He's made strides, but like most players in the league, it's getting better at the role he's most suited for, which for him is still mainly off-ball combo guard. He's got a mid-ranger he can comfortably use now in that role when he's run off the line.


Westbrook is much different from Fred. Westbrook historically has been a high turnover player who gambles like crazy defensively. Fred has been a low turnover player who is an excellent on ball defender and is in the correct position.

Are you seriously going to one playoff series in his 3rd year in the league as a back up PG as your argument? I could pull up Lowry's horrendous 2015 playoff series or even Lillard's horrific 2018 playoff series against the Pelicans if you want to play this game.
DelAbbot
RealGM
Posts: 14,974
And1: 21,495
Joined: May 22, 2019
   

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#222 » by DelAbbot » Fri Nov 12, 2021 10:48 pm

FVV certainly has bumped up his assist numbers this year, but that doesn't equate better playmaking / creating for others. He collects quite a number of Calderon/Rondo type assists.

FVV's shooting and defense is undeniably impactful for winning basketball, but do we want him as the main playmaker / ball handler when we compete in the playoffs? I feel he is a floor-raiser and not a ceiling raiser as the playmaker / ball handler (but he is more valuable as off-ball shooting guard).

FVV is certain to decline his 23M player option in 2023/2024, which means he only has 1 more season past this one at his current 21M AAV. Considering he is getting 39mins a game so far, and collecting all-star level numbers, he will be asking for 25M+ for his age 29 to 32 years. Do we want to extend him that? I'm leaning towards no, and we should trade him in a consolidation trade like we did DD for Kawhi
User avatar
vini_vidi_vici
RealGM
Posts: 18,685
And1: 21,203
Joined: Jun 29, 2006
 

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#223 » by vini_vidi_vici » Fri Nov 12, 2021 10:56 pm

The thing is, people incessantly harp on the negative here. The team is a +3 (5th on team) on, and the off is -6.7 (worst -) for the team.

The criticisms are dumb, hes not a PG? come to 2021. Hes a creator, both for himself (61% of his FGAs are uASTd), and others, 25.9 ASTr. He cant facilitate??

Image

The guy has some of the worst luck in terms of finishes on his passes in PnR. Shooters bricking, Roll Men missing bunnies. You watch the video associated and while I like Precious, its a bunch of his misses/lobs. On ISOs the team is shooting 6/22 off his passes. He is finding guys.

The people act like he should only be a C&S guy, where he is elite....

Image

He gets it done everywhere, off the dribble, the only issue is at the rim right? We all agree, it sucks to have a player with a flaw, albeit minor. Hes good in PnR, could be elite if those passing numbers bump up with made shots, hes very good in DHOs, hes not just a guy you park in the corner on a team devoid of facilitators (right now).

We already know FVVs defense.

Hes not tall?? got it.

I just think people destroying our #2 USG guy (OG 1), soon to be 3 with Spicy back, because he isnt a #1 is silly.
Image
iDRTG is terrible. ** Paid for by Pfizer Inc.
User avatar
vini_vidi_vici
RealGM
Posts: 18,685
And1: 21,203
Joined: Jun 29, 2006
 

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#224 » by vini_vidi_vici » Fri Nov 12, 2021 10:58 pm

ATLTimekeeper wrote:
sidsid wrote:
ATLTimekeeper wrote:He doesn't have to make the hall of fame to be a good player. Mike Conley is good. No one on the Jazz or Grizzlies ****es incessantly about his height, or thinks it's a systemic problem they'll never recover from.


No, but it's the types of criticism that comes from the standards and expectations of having those hall of fame talents and seeing it slowly dismantled post-chip. Seeing Kawhi leave and floundering in the playoffs, then Ibaka and Gasol leave and replaced with junk, and now finally Lowry orchestrating your offense for near a decade and then having to do without.

Not sure how Spurs fans took 15 years of excellence turned into grinding into a bubble team, but I assume it's rough there too. If you're the Knicks you're just super happy if Randle isn't Al Harrington 2.0.

Anyway, "why didn't Fred see that pass? Why didn't he find x player in his shooting pocket? Why has he taken too long on this possession?" Etc. It's because he doesn't have the talent to do better.

Welcome to the vast majority of teams in the league. Welcome to being, like, the Pacers who every year have to figure out a system and rely on precision and execution in order to leverage what talent they have.

It's clear that Fred as heliocentric offense isn't our long term future. It's going to be the development of the bigs and relieving Fred of the vast majority of the responsibilities he currently holds. Going back to something much closer to his role in the chip run while we try to replace Kawhi and Lowry and Gasol's impact in other ways.

We're just stuck here now in the interim just waiting on development and next season.


Lowry wasn't heading to the hall of fame at 27, though. You're either forgetting or weren't around for "Lowry can't hit JV on the roll." "Lowry can't get his own shot." "Lowry got stuffed by Pierce in game 7 because he's too short." "Lowry and DeMar are freezing out JV because they're jealous." "Lowry doesn't have "it"" "Lowry is getting cooked by John Wall because he's too slow." "Lowry chokes." Maybe it's some people's lot in life to be miserable watching the Raptors. I'm here to tell you that, rationally, it has nothing to do with Fred VanVleet. He's certified "good."

The Raptors with Kyle Lowry were the Pacers.


My personal favorite.Is Kyle Lowry the worst starting PG in the NBA?
Image
iDRTG is terrible. ** Paid for by Pfizer Inc.
User avatar
Badonkadonk
General Manager
Posts: 7,896
And1: 12,480
Joined: Jul 11, 2012

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#225 » by Badonkadonk » Fri Nov 12, 2021 11:14 pm

vini_vidi_vici wrote:The thing is, people incessantly harp on the negative here. The team is a +3 (5th on team) on, and the off is -6.7 (worst -) for the team.

The criticisms are dumb, hes not a PG? come to 2021. Hes a creator, both for himself (61% of his FGAs are uASTd), and others, 25.9 ASTr. He cant facilitate??

Image

The guy has some of the worst luck in terms of finishes on his passes in PnR. Shooters bricking, Roll Men missing bunnies. You watch the video associated and while I like Precious, its a bunch of his misses/lobs. On ISOs the team is shooting 6/22 off his passes. He is finding guys.

The people act like he should only be a C&S guy, where he is elite....

Image

He gets it done everywhere, off the dribble, the only issue is at the rim right? We all agree, it sucks to have a player with a flaw, albeit minor. Hes good in PnR, could be elite if those passing numbers bump up with made shots, hes very good in DHOs, hes not just a guy you park in the corner on a team devoid of facilitators (right now).

We already know FVVs defense.

Hes not tall?? got it.

I just think people destroying our #2 USG guy (OG 1), soon to be 3 with Spicy back, because he isnt a #1 is silly.

Great post for those who have no idea what they're actually watching, of course it'll be ignored by FVV's haters.
Image
sidsid
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,976
And1: 3,805
Joined: Jun 03, 2003

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#226 » by sidsid » Fri Nov 12, 2021 11:36 pm

vini_vidi_vici wrote:
ATLTimekeeper wrote:
sidsid wrote:
No, but it's the types of criticism that comes from the standards and expectations of having those hall of fame talents and seeing it slowly dismantled post-chip. Seeing Kawhi leave and floundering in the playoffs, then Ibaka and Gasol leave and replaced with junk, and now finally Lowry orchestrating your offense for near a decade and then having to do without.

Not sure how Spurs fans took 15 years of excellence turned into grinding into a bubble team, but I assume it's rough there too. If you're the Knicks you're just super happy if Randle isn't Al Harrington 2.0.

Anyway, "why didn't Fred see that pass? Why didn't he find x player in his shooting pocket? Why has he taken too long on this possession?" Etc. It's because he doesn't have the talent to do better.

Welcome to the vast majority of teams in the league. Welcome to being, like, the Pacers who every year have to figure out a system and rely on precision and execution in order to leverage what talent they have.

It's clear that Fred as heliocentric offense isn't our long term future. It's going to be the development of the bigs and relieving Fred of the vast majority of the responsibilities he currently holds. Going back to something much closer to his role in the chip run while we try to replace Kawhi and Lowry and Gasol's impact in other ways.

We're just stuck here now in the interim just waiting on development and next season.


Lowry wasn't heading to the hall of fame at 27, though. You're either forgetting or weren't around for "Lowry can't hit JV on the roll." "Lowry can't get his own shot." "Lowry got stuffed by Pierce in game 7 because he's too short." "Lowry and DeMar are freezing out JV because they're jealous." "Lowry doesn't have "it"" "Lowry is getting cooked by John Wall because he's too slow." "Lowry chokes." Maybe it's some people's lot in life to be miserable watching the Raptors. I'm here to tell you that, rationally, it has nothing to do with Fred VanVleet. He's certified "good."

The Raptors with Kyle Lowry were the Pacers.


My personal favorite.Is Kyle Lowry the worst starting PG in the NBA?


Lowry of course, made his own leaps as he broke out, but that didn't stop any of the talk.

Fond memories of the Bucks having the best PG in the playoff matchup in Eric Bledsoe. Probably a hot take after game 1 with DJ Augustine. We should have traded for Connelly, and why didn't we flip him for Kemba when we had the chance?

There was a tweet that summarized it pretty well: Lowry's career has been marked by him making everyone around him better, and then praising said players as better than him.

DeRozan (second team all NBA while never being better), Siakam (ditto), FVV (a finals MVP vote! Possibly the most insulting thing thus far to Lowry) and now, Tyler f****** Herro by a national reporter.

There's a pattern here. An embarrassing one. Stop comparing dudes to Lowry. His 16/7/5 or whatever may not blow your socks off, but guys like him are extremely rare. Expecting others to replicate his impact is very unlikely.
Dalek
RealGM
Posts: 13,867
And1: 10,659
Joined: Jan 24, 2005
Location: At the elbow - dropping dimes
 

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#227 » by Dalek » Fri Nov 12, 2021 11:43 pm

I do think FVV has taken some really good strides this year which get overlooked.

He has travelled distance wise second most on the court in the NBA - second to only Harrison Barnes. It kind of speaks to his Steph Curry like running that gets him to his open shots as well as when he has the ball and probes the defense.

He is the team's best shooter and his distance seems longer than ever before. His above the break 3s are up and he is 12 in attempts. I'd like to see that number go further up since we no longer have Kyle taking that type of shot.

When he is in control of the ball he is now more willing to pull-up from mid-range and shoot - his total fieldgoals are up to 13% from 10-16 feet which is more than double the attempts from last year. If he can master that middy then we have his next evolution.

I do get frustrated by the ball sticking to him, but he is working with a lot of young and inexperienced players so that might be a product of their own confusion on offense. I do wish he would get more comfortable with riskier passes off the dribble. He tends to hold and let the passing window close rather than force things. I do think he has some serious passing ability, but it feel like a trust thing about whether his guys will catch the ball or not.
ATLTimekeeper
RealGM
Posts: 42,132
And1: 23,472
Joined: Apr 28, 2008

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#228 » by ATLTimekeeper » Sat Nov 13, 2021 2:03 pm

vini_vidi_vici wrote:
ATLTimekeeper wrote:
sidsid wrote:
No, but it's the types of criticism that comes from the standards and expectations of having those hall of fame talents and seeing it slowly dismantled post-chip. Seeing Kawhi leave and floundering in the playoffs, then Ibaka and Gasol leave and replaced with junk, and now finally Lowry orchestrating your offense for near a decade and then having to do without.

Not sure how Spurs fans took 15 years of excellence turned into grinding into a bubble team, but I assume it's rough there too. If you're the Knicks you're just super happy if Randle isn't Al Harrington 2.0.

Anyway, "why didn't Fred see that pass? Why didn't he find x player in his shooting pocket? Why has he taken too long on this possession?" Etc. It's because he doesn't have the talent to do better.

Welcome to the vast majority of teams in the league. Welcome to being, like, the Pacers who every year have to figure out a system and rely on precision and execution in order to leverage what talent they have.

It's clear that Fred as heliocentric offense isn't our long term future. It's going to be the development of the bigs and relieving Fred of the vast majority of the responsibilities he currently holds. Going back to something much closer to his role in the chip run while we try to replace Kawhi and Lowry and Gasol's impact in other ways.

We're just stuck here now in the interim just waiting on development and next season.


Lowry wasn't heading to the hall of fame at 27, though. You're either forgetting or weren't around for "Lowry can't hit JV on the roll." "Lowry can't get his own shot." "Lowry got stuffed by Pierce in game 7 because he's too short." "Lowry and DeMar are freezing out JV because they're jealous." "Lowry doesn't have "it"" "Lowry is getting cooked by John Wall because he's too slow." "Lowry chokes." Maybe it's some people's lot in life to be miserable watching the Raptors. I'm here to tell you that, rationally, it has nothing to do with Fred VanVleet. He's certified "good."

The Raptors with Kyle Lowry were the Pacers.


My personal favorite.Is Kyle Lowry the worst starting PG in the NBA?


I think most people that were supportive of Kyle are also supportive of Fred. There are a few that can't handle transitions or something, or need to make 1:1 comparisons. They have different skills and their psychological make-up is different. They can both be really good in their own way.
User avatar
OAKLEY_2
RealGM
Posts: 20,177
And1: 9,173
Joined: Dec 19, 2008

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#229 » by OAKLEY_2 » Sat Nov 13, 2021 2:49 pm

Badonkadonk wrote:
vini_vidi_vici wrote:The thing is, people incessantly harp on the negative here. The team is a +3 (5th on team) on, and the off is -6.7 (worst -) for the team.

The criticisms are dumb, hes not a PG? come to 2021. Hes a creator, both for himself (61% of his FGAs are uASTd), and others, 25.9 ASTr. He cant facilitate??

Image

The guy has some of the worst luck in terms of finishes on his passes in PnR. Shooters bricking, Roll Men missing bunnies. You watch the video associated and while I like Precious, its a bunch of his misses/lobs. On ISOs the team is shooting 6/22 off his passes. He is finding guys.

The people act like he should only be a C&S guy, where he is elite....

Image

He gets it done everywhere, off the dribble, the only issue is at the rim right? We all agree, it sucks to have a player with a flaw, albeit minor. Hes good in PnR, could be elite if those passing numbers bump up with made shots, hes very good in DHOs, hes not just a guy you park in the corner on a team devoid of facilitators (right now).

We already know FVVs defense.

Hes not tall?? got it.

I just think people destroying our #2 USG guy (OG 1), soon to be 3 with Spicy back, because he isnt a #1 is silly.

Great post for those who have no idea what they're actually watching, of course it'll be ignored by FVV's haters.


It is one thing to collect stats and another to interpret them. How he compares in the league backs up the smell test and you are so right the haters have a bias against micro guards even ones that are wide and will switch onto bigs and win championships. FVV is a Lowry disciple and in every sense is like having KL still here. He is a killer down the stretch and would love to see those stats. To start this season we lost Lowry and Paskal and the real story is how Fred and OG and another weird hated player, Trentjr, have taken over. Is this the person we want handling the ball is the worst fn take on Fred ever. Yes he could pound the rock but this isn't Cory Joseph out there. It is Lowry II.
User avatar
Clay Davis
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,915
And1: 7,176
Joined: Nov 06, 2013
 

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#230 » by Clay Davis » Sat Nov 13, 2021 2:54 pm

Image
Steelo Green wrote:Even though you know somehow we all gotta go, as long as we believin' thievin' we'll be leavin' with some kind of dough.
User avatar
NBA Sheady
General Manager
Posts: 8,042
And1: 5,596
Joined: Nov 17, 2004

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#231 » by NBA Sheady » Sat Nov 13, 2021 3:07 pm

sidsid wrote:
ATLTimekeeper wrote:He doesn't have to make the hall of fame to be a good player. Mike Conley is good. No one on the Jazz or Grizzlies ****es incessantly about his height, or thinks it's a systemic problem they'll never recover from.


No, but it's the types of criticism that comes from the standards and expectations of having those hall of fame talents and seeing it slowly dismantled post-chip. Seeing Kawhi leave and floundering in the playoffs, then Ibaka and Gasol leave and replaced with junk, and now finally Lowry orchestrating your offense for near a decade and then having to do without.

Not sure how Spurs fans took 15 years of excellence turned into grinding into a bubble team, but I assume it's rough there too.


Can confirm. I've been a Spurs fan since before the Raptors existed. They suddenly have zero hall-of-famers and it's just a different equation.
The good thing about BI is he can shoot over defenders.
The bad thing about BI is he can shoot over defenders.
User avatar
InfraRedshaw
Pro Prospect
Posts: 852
And1: 817
Joined: Nov 23, 2012
     

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#232 » by InfraRedshaw » Sat Nov 13, 2021 3:31 pm

The truth about FVV is that he's a baller and a stone cold killer!

Yall got me starting to hate raps fans, and I'm a raps fan!!
Just 8* years ago Andrea Bargnani was my franchise player, you MF'ers can't rain on my parade
User avatar
ItsDanger
RealGM
Posts: 28,386
And1: 25,586
Joined: Nov 01, 2008

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#233 » by ItsDanger » Sat Nov 13, 2021 3:36 pm

A PG should create easier shots for their teammates. At least his FGA is down slightly this season. Baby steps. Your statistical analysis using averages ignores the opposition.
Organization can be defined as an organized body of people with a particular purpose. Not random.
mdenny
General Manager
Posts: 7,514
And1: 7,292
Joined: Jul 05, 2019
         

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#234 » by mdenny » Sat Nov 13, 2021 6:12 pm

vini_vidi_vici wrote:
ATLTimekeeper wrote:
sidsid wrote:
No, but it's the types of criticism that comes from the standards and expectations of having those hall of fame talents and seeing it slowly dismantled post-chip. Seeing Kawhi leave and floundering in the playoffs, then Ibaka and Gasol leave and replaced with junk, and now finally Lowry orchestrating your offense for near a decade and then having to do without.

Not sure how Spurs fans took 15 years of excellence turned into grinding into a bubble team, but I assume it's rough there too. If you're the Knicks you're just super happy if Randle isn't Al Harrington 2.0.

Anyway, "why didn't Fred see that pass? Why didn't he find x player in his shooting pocket? Why has he taken too long on this possession?" Etc. It's because he doesn't have the talent to do better.

Welcome to the vast majority of teams in the league. Welcome to being, like, the Pacers who every year have to figure out a system and rely on precision and execution in order to leverage what talent they have.

It's clear that Fred as heliocentric offense isn't our long term future. It's going to be the development of the bigs and relieving Fred of the vast majority of the responsibilities he currently holds. Going back to something much closer to his role in the chip run while we try to replace Kawhi and Lowry and Gasol's impact in other ways.

We're just stuck here now in the interim just waiting on development and next season.


Lowry wasn't heading to the hall of fame at 27, though. You're either forgetting or weren't around for "Lowry can't hit JV on the roll." "Lowry can't get his own shot." "Lowry got stuffed by Pierce in game 7 because he's too short." "Lowry and DeMar are freezing out JV because they're jealous." "Lowry doesn't have "it"" "Lowry is getting cooked by John Wall because he's too slow." "Lowry chokes." Maybe it's some people's lot in life to be miserable watching the Raptors. I'm here to tell you that, rationally, it has nothing to do with Fred VanVleet. He's certified "good."

The Raptors with Kyle Lowry were the Pacers.


My personal favorite.Is Kyle Lowry the worst starting PG in the NBA?


Great post in this thread with the stats. I started lurking the board when we added Garbo and Parker. Wasn't following it during the early lowry/derozan years. This Kyle thread gives me a better understanding amd context. I thought the Fred hate was more unprecedented-like. Guess it's just a pattern of a certain type of fan-talk. In anycase...I just started using ignore function so I can interact with more like-minded fans when I'm here. No hard feelings. I'm just not interested in those types of interactions.

There's a bit of a game played where if I glorify college prospects and trash our current players....I can never really be wrong. Because when I'm trashing those same prospects in 3 to 4 years.....noone will remember. It's like cheering for a mirage.

I criticize our players occasionally. I'd never see the point in doing it incessantly....like literally 30 to 40 times in a single day. But I guess we use this place in different ways. I'm not here to vent. For me that's like the guy who constantly complains when you go camping.
User avatar
Gold Dragon
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,016
And1: 4,598
Joined: Jul 02, 2006
Location: Oz
 

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#235 » by Gold Dragon » Sat Nov 13, 2021 9:32 pm

mdenny wrote:
vini_vidi_vici wrote:
ATLTimekeeper wrote:
Lowry wasn't heading to the hall of fame at 27, though. You're either forgetting or weren't around for "Lowry can't hit JV on the roll." "Lowry can't get his own shot." "Lowry got stuffed by Pierce in game 7 because he's too short." "Lowry and DeMar are freezing out JV because they're jealous." "Lowry doesn't have "it"" "Lowry is getting cooked by John Wall because he's too slow." "Lowry chokes." Maybe it's some people's lot in life to be miserable watching the Raptors. I'm here to tell you that, rationally, it has nothing to do with Fred VanVleet. He's certified "good."

The Raptors with Kyle Lowry were the Pacers.


My personal favorite.Is Kyle Lowry the worst starting PG in the NBA?


Great post in this thread with the stats. I started lurking the board when we added Garbo and Parker. Wasn't following it during the early lowry/derozan years. This Kyle thread gives me a better understanding amd context. I thought the Fred hate was more unprecedented-like. Guess it's just a pattern of a certain type of fan-talk. In anycase...I just started using ignore function so I can interact with more like-minded fans when I'm here. No hard feelings. I'm just not interested in those types of interactions.

There's a bit of a game played where if I glorify college prospects and trash our current players....I can never really be wrong. Because when I'm trashing those same prospects in 3 to 4 years.....noone will remember. It's like cheering for a mirage.

I criticize our players occasionally. I'd never see the point in doing it incessantly....like literally 30 to 40 times in a single day. But I guess we use this place in different ways. I'm not here to vent. For me that's like the guy who constantly complains when you go camping.


Is Lowry purposely playing bad/being fat to avoid being traded?!

Tonight is a reminder that Lowry is still terrible

This is from our championship year. Low quality posters will post low quality posts.

A lot of it is box score watching or ball watching and not being able to recognize the impact of defense and off ball activity. Some of it is using superficial stats like FGA, shooting percentage and minutes played to reinforce false narratives in their heads.

You learn to ignore some posters or use the ignore feature. Quality of posting is often inversely proportional to quantity. Sometimes legitimate criticism get lumped in with the crowd.




At this point in Fred’s career, we are all well aware of his weaknesses. What some fail to recognize is that he is systematically overcoming many of them this season and just continue to nitpick on those same things over and over and over ….

1) midrange has gone from a non-existent part of his game to a relative strength and it was because the scheme never allowed him to shoot that shot before

2) his playmaking and getting all his teammates involved in the offense, being able to read what defenses are giving him have improved this season. But critics continue to say but he is not a PG because he is not as good as some ideal in their head like Kyle or Luca or Paul at those pure PG skills. They don’t consider that this is his first year in the NBA as the primary PG with no one to fall back on and he is leading a squad of mostly young players and rookies trying to learn.
User avatar
pingpongrac
RealGM
Posts: 11,493
And1: 16,685
Joined: Mar 18, 2015
   

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#236 » by pingpongrac » Sat Nov 13, 2021 10:02 pm

Gold Dragon wrote:
mdenny wrote:
vini_vidi_vici wrote:
My personal favorite.Is Kyle Lowry the worst starting PG in the NBA?


Great post in this thread with the stats. I started lurking the board when we added Garbo and Parker. Wasn't following it during the early lowry/derozan years. This Kyle thread gives me a better understanding amd context. I thought the Fred hate was more unprecedented-like. Guess it's just a pattern of a certain type of fan-talk. In anycase...I just started using ignore function so I can interact with more like-minded fans when I'm here. No hard feelings. I'm just not interested in those types of interactions.

There's a bit of a game played where if I glorify college prospects and trash our current players....I can never really be wrong. Because when I'm trashing those same prospects in 3 to 4 years.....noone will remember. It's like cheering for a mirage.

I criticize our players occasionally. I'd never see the point in doing it incessantly....like literally 30 to 40 times in a single day. But I guess we use this place in different ways. I'm not here to vent. For me that's like the guy who constantly complains when you go camping.


Is Lowry purposely playing bad/being fat to avoid being traded?!

Tonight is a reminder that Lowry is still terrible

This is from our championship year. Low quality posters will post low quality posts.

A lot of it is box score watching or ball watching and not being able to recognize the impact of defense and off ball activity. Some of it is using superficial stats like FGA, shooting percentage and minutes played to reinforce false narratives in their heads.

You learn to ignore some posters or use the ignore feature. Quality of posting is often inversely proportional to quantity. Sometimes legitimate criticism get lumped in with the crowd.




At this point in Fred’s career, we are all well aware of his weaknesses. What some fail to recognize is that he is systematically overcoming many of them this season and just continue to nitpick on those same things over and over and over ….

1) midrange has gone from a non-existent part of his game to a relative strength and it was because the scheme never allowed him to shoot that shot before

2) his playmaking and getting all his teammates involved in the offense, being able to read what defenses are giving him have improved this season. But critics continue to say but he is not a PG because he is not as good as some ideal in their head like Kyle or Luca or Paul at those pure PG skills. They don’t consider that this is his first year in the NBA as the primary PG with no one to fall back on and he is leading a squad of mostly young players and rookies trying to learn.
Wow. It's a shame that a lot of the bad takes in those threads are from posters that have been running rampant over the past 10 months while most of the level-headed replies are from posters who have basically stopped posting on this forum.

I think it's pretty telling that FVV has the best on/off rating of any of our starters while being on the floor for 80% of the games. The difference of 9.7 is significantly higher than the next closest starter (Scottie at +1.7). He is also top 10 the entire league when it comes to WAR.

Having good advanced or good individual stats on their own are a starting point for making a case for someone's impact, but when you have both very good advanced stats while putting up 20/5/7, it should be extremely clear to everyone how good that player has been.

Sent from my Pixel 4 using RealGM mobile app
Image
ATLTimekeeper
RealGM
Posts: 42,132
And1: 23,472
Joined: Apr 28, 2008

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#237 » by ATLTimekeeper » Sat Nov 13, 2021 10:12 pm

mdenny wrote:Great post in this thread with the stats. I started lurking the board when we added Garbo and Parker. Wasn't following it during the early lowry/derozan years. This Kyle thread gives me a better understanding amd context. I thought the Fred hate was more unprecedented-like. Guess it's just a pattern of a certain type of fan-talk. In anycase...I just started using ignore function so I can interact with more like-minded fans when I'm here. No hard feelings. I'm just not interested in those types of interactions.

There's a bit of a game played where if I glorify college prospects and trash our current players....I can never really be wrong. Because when I'm trashing those same prospects in 3 to 4 years.....noone will remember. It's like cheering for a mirage.

I criticize our players occasionally. I'd never see the point in doing it incessantly....like literally 30 to 40 times in a single day. But I guess we use this place in different ways. I'm not here to vent. For me that's like the guy who constantly complains when you go camping.


Venting is fine. I think that's what the gamethread is good for. Unfortunately the ugly side of fandom is that some of these guys will hound these players on social media, and their families. And some of that frustration is in part because of faulty narratives stemming from gamethread vitriol. So, I don't ignore them because it doesn't really get me rattled and I'll support the fact checkers that routinely supply good information on the board.
Kingsway_fan
RealGM
Posts: 13,916
And1: 9,714
Joined: May 25, 2016
Location: Paris
 

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#238 » by Kingsway_fan » Sat Nov 13, 2021 10:14 pm

Got 99 complaints, but Fred is not one of them.
User avatar
execoftheyear
Analyst
Posts: 3,601
And1: 2,211
Joined: May 14, 2007

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#239 » by execoftheyear » Sun Nov 14, 2021 4:54 pm

Marty_Budda wrote:
execoftheyear wrote:
Marty_Budda wrote:My problem with Fred has always been he’d have one good game out of two -and he’d shoot us out of the game he’s not shooting well in. As long as he can keep playing well 2/3 games rather than 1/2 I’m happy to keep eating crow.


yes, because basketball is played on one side of the court. Fred is an elite defender. It's rare to have a player that plays the pg position handle the ball so much on offense and still be able to play at such a high level on defense. I think his off nights on the offensive end are excusable with how hard he plays on D and given our best players in Siakam and Barnes are out.

Ideally, once Siakam and Barnes come back, Fred will be more of an off ball spot up shooter with the occasional drive to the basket or mid range pull up to keep the defense honest. Also he still needs to be that guy in late clock situations. It's insane how clutch he is in those situations.


Where did I say he’s not a good defender? But if your shot isn’t falling there’s no reason you should pounding the air outta that rock for 20 seconds each position and be taking 20+ shots. Idc how good your defense is. He’s improved drastically in that regard this year.

Idk how you could disagree that Fvv stunk in about half the games he played in last year


I'm suspecting it's trust issues with so many new pieces. This should improve over time once players establish what they can do and then I expect FVV to defer a bit.
Los_29
RealGM
Posts: 15,060
And1: 13,684
Joined: Apr 10, 2021

Re: The truth about FVV 

Post#240 » by Los_29 » Sun Nov 14, 2021 5:51 pm

I am a massive fan of Lowry. He is the GROAT and I can't wait to see his jersey retired. However, people have been overrating his impact the past couple of years and completely underrating the impact of FVV. The Raptors were 12-14 without Lowry last year. Their record was much worse when they were without FVV. Two years ago the Raptors were 12-2 without Lowry.

Return to Toronto Raptors