Knightro wrote:pepe1991 wrote:Every player looks good in highlights. Drafting guy straight from highschool, with basically zero any serious basketball in his life ( U16 fiba Copa America tournament from 2019 as last reliable data? ) and frying top 5 pick on him would be simply too risky.
From few highlights, 6'5- 185, hard shots taker, not some uber athlete, not point guard. Basically best case is Jalen Green.
He was top 10 on espn's list of top 100 recruit. Fine. Nico Mannion was 6th, RJ Hampton was 4th i think, Cole was second. Nico lasted 1 years in nba, RJ Hampton will probably probably around 5, Cole will stick longer but non of them are "stars" because of list.
Key reason why one year college rule was added to nba was to save poor franchsies from stupidity of their GMs and drafting next Kawme, Eddy Curry and Darius Miles within top 5.
btw Calipari 2 weeks ago or so pretty much said he is nowhere near ready to play and he has no intentions to play him, but if they get killed by injuries, he might reconsider giving him 7 min a game![]()
https://www.on3.com/teams/kentucky-wildcats/news/john-calipari-doesnt-expect-shaedon-sharpe-to-play-this-year-hes-a-ways-away/
full interview.
Look, if Orlando is sitting allstar who is injuried, if Suggs was doing fantastic or at least good enough where you are confident he is your PG of future than sure, take a bigger gamble and go on upside of 6'6 shooting guard over well scouted others. But Magic are far away from it. They need to nail this pick or this rebuild is ***ed.
I mean his situation is pretty unique since he graduated high school 8 months earlier than he was normally would have and enrolled in college 6 months earlier than he normally would have.
Under normal circumstances he'd still be playing high school ball for the another 2-3 months, then he'd enroll at Kentucky in the summer and spend the next four months doing nothing but practicing and training before making his college debut in November.
He literally only just got to Kentucky like two weeks ago and hasn't had the opportunity to do any of the training and practicing that all the other guys on Kentucky have gotten to do. His entire timeline basically got jolted forward by 6-8 months.
A guy like TyTy Washington has only played 18 college games, but he's been on Kentucky's campus for 7 months and gotten to train and lift weights and practice that entire time. Of course Sharpe isn't ready compared to a guy like that.
And as far as recruiting rankings go... nothing is ever perfect, but there's plenty of all-stars and other multi-year solid pros all throughout the top 5 of these recruiting rankings. As many or more hits than complete misses that's for sure.
I'm simply not drafting player with 0 data on. I can't imagine how would scouting process for him would go. Scouts entering emty arena to watch him dribble chairs or playing 1 on 1 vs college teammate? That went great for former 5th overall pick Exum
From only actual tracked official gamel, witch date back in 2019, when Canda won silver, he averaged 13 points, around 3 rebounds and assists. His 2FG were on point ( like 68% or so), his 3 ball was meh 4/12, his FTs were meh ( 6-10). That was 2 and half years ago. He grew up from 6'5 to 6'6 ( allegedly) , his reported weight is around 185. OKey. That's basically all you know about him , other than he is 5 star recruit.
And as go as that ESPN's list goes, i think Magic today have at least 6 ( could be more, i just don't bother to check ) 5 star recruits on current roster. And ones from past, 5 star recruits include guys like... Zimmerman.
Also i think in 2018 ( or 19, can't remember) half of 5 star recruits didn't make it to nba.
I don't know, i would just stay off. Magic are not in situation where they can gamble.



























